Interview with Shin Beom-cheol, Senior Research Fellow at the Sejong Institute
"North Korea Aims to Neutralize Our Response to Its Landmine Provocation"
"Threat to Resume Loudspeaker Broadcasts to South Korea Likely a Bluff for Now"

■ Broadcast: Asia Economy's "So Jongseop's Current Affairs Show" (Monday-Friday, 4 p.m.)

■ Host: So Jongseop, political specialist ■ Producer: Lee Miri, PD

■ Guest: Shin Beomcheol, Senior Research Fellow at the Sejong Institute (October 22)

※ Please be sure to cite "So Jongseop's Current Affairs Show" when quoting this article.


So Jongseop: North Korea's recent moves are unusual. Kim Yo Jong, a department director of the Workers' Party of Korea, has delivered a forceful message and said the country would resume broadcasts toward the South. There have been various analyses of North Korea's intentions and proposals for how we should respond. We are joined by phone by Shin Beomcheol, Senior Research Fellow at the Sejong Institute and a former vice minister of national defense. Mr. Shin, what do you think North Korea's intentions are?


Shin Beomcheol: I think North Korea is strongly determined to take the initiative in the situation and avoid being put on the defensive by its mine provocations. That's why it keeps hinting at additional measures and taking a hard line. I believe its ultimate goal is to neutralize South Korea's response.

Kim Yo Jong, director of a department of North Korea's Workers' Party, inspected key points at a southern border fortification construction site alongside senior commanders of the Korean People's Army General Staff, the Korean Central News Agency reported on the 21st. Yonhap News Agency

Kim Yo Jong, director of a department of North Korea's Workers' Party, inspected key points at a southern border fortification construction site alongside senior commanders of the Korean People's Army General Staff, the Korean Central News Agency reported on the 21st. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

So Jongseop: Kim Jong Un has stayed out of it, while Kim Yo Jong is at the forefront, making harsh statements. Should we see this as a division of roles based on a strategic decision?


Shin Beomcheol: There are aspects that have remained consistent, as well as some changes.What has remained consistent is that Kim Yo Jong delivers messages to South Korea and handles the harsh rhetoric. That has not changed. But this time, there is also a somewhat unusual aspect: Kim Yo Jong personally inspected the area along the Military Demarcation Line, which they call the border. That is quite unusual.


That's because, in the North Korean system, power comes from the barrel of a gun, and only the supreme leader has personally inspected the military. So, even if Kim Jong Un delegated this authority to her, the fact that she is doing something like this can only be seen as evidence that Kim Yo Jong's status has risen. In any case, while it appears that she has Kim Jong Un's authorization, we can also see that the range of roles Kim Yo Jong can take on within the North Korean regime has expanded.


So Jongseop: Isn't this the first time Kim Yo Jong has come down to the border that North Korea claims as its own and inspected the area?


Shin Beomcheol: It is. That's why I said it was unusual. It is clear that Kim Ju Ae is the heir apparent, but she is still young, so I think it would have been difficult for North Korea to put her at the forefront. That's why Kim Yo Jong, who is currently by Kim Jong Un's side, is taking the lead in these matters.

The Korean Central News Agency reported on the 21st that Department Director Kim Yo Jong inspected a fortification construction site along the southern border on the 20th, accompanied by senior commanders of the Korean People's Army General Staff. Yonhap News Agency

The Korean Central News Agency reported on the 21st that Department Director Kim Yo Jong inspected a fortification construction site along the southern border on the 20th, accompanied by senior commanders of the Korean People's Army General Staff. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

So Jongseop: I see. Kim Yo Jong went so far as to mention Assemblyman Kim Byeong-ju and even the name of the presidential special adviser on defense policy, saying, "You should shut your mouth right now. You're a minnow," and strongly criticizing him. What do you think was the reason?


Shin Beomcheol: From Kim Yo Jong's perspective, Assemblyman Kim Byeong-ju mentioned her by name on social media. She was probably first expressing her displeasure about that. Still, she singled him out because he is not only a lawmaker but also serves as the president's special adviser on defense policy. She may have intended to send a tough message to the South Korean government. She probably would not have gone this far if he had been an ordinary lawmaker, but I believe she responded directly to Assemblyman Kim Byeong-ju because he serves as the president's special adviser on defense policy.


So Jongseop: I see. North Korea said it would operate loudspeakers sometime in October. Do you think it will actually do so?


Shin Beomcheol: For now, I think it's a threat. Operating loudspeakers would cost North Korea more than it would gain. If we take countermeasures, the North Korean soldiers near the Military Demarcation Line will hear the truth about what they regard as their supreme leader's dignity being broadcast. I think that would do more harm to North Korea than simply troubling our soldiers or residents in nearby areas. So I think the first message is a strong call for the South Korean government not to operate its loudspeakers.


Even so, it seems there is some friction on the ground right now. When North Korean troops cross the Military Demarcation Line, we issue warning shots as a countermeasure. If tensions escalate in the course of such incidents, North Korea might operate the loudspeakers it said it would use. However, I don't think the impact would be that great. South Korea is an open society, so we can filter out any messages that come from North Korea. In fact, North Korea would suffer more if we broadcast the truth. So I think the main purpose of North Korea's threat about the loudspeakers is to intimidate the South first and prevent the South Korean government from responding.

Director Kim Yo Jong said on the 22nd that the loudspeakers aimed at South Korea would be placed on standby within days. The loudspeakers installed in a border area of North Korea, seen from Songhae-myeon, Ganghwa-gun, Incheon, on the same day. Yonhap News Agency

Director Kim Yo Jong said on the 22nd that the loudspeakers aimed at South Korea would be placed on standby within days. The loudspeakers installed in a border area of North Korea, seen from Songhae-myeon, Ganghwa-gun, Incheon, on the same day. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

So Jongseop: The Ministry of National Defense has said it will respond proportionately. Do you think that is an appropriate message?


Shin Beomcheol: Yes. The Ministry of National Defense seems to have a consistent position: it will take corresponding measures in response to provocations. However, the Ministry of Unification seems to have a somewhat different position, so coordination is necessary. In any case, I don't think the military should appear to back down in a situation like this. At a higher level, the National Security Office may need to try behind-the-scenes contact with North Korea to ease tensions. The North also has reasons to be uncomfortable if tensions rise. So the Ministry of National Defense should respond according to principle, and when North Korea realizes it cannot get what it wants, dialogue can begin. That was the practice in inter-Korean relations in the past. In other words, I think the Ministry of National Defense should continue to talk about proportionate responses and firm measures.


It is important to make North Korea feel the need for dialogue. If we respond to its actions in good faith and let ourselves be led along, North Korea could instead see that as more effective. That's why I think we should respond according to principle and take corresponding measures in areas other than military clashes.


So Jongseop: What do you think about the possibility of an accidental incident or something similar leading to a military clash?


Shin Beomcheol:  The possibility of a military clash in the border area remains open. That's why our military continues to maintain its readiness. Kim Yo Jong said she had ordered a new response capability to be placed on standby. We need to determine what that actually is. North Korea may have additionally deployed long-range artillery nearby, so our intelligence authorities need to assess this accurately. We also need to strengthen our readiness so that we can concentrate firepower in any area and avoid being pushed back in a possible local clash. If we are prepared for such a situation, North Korea will not dare to provoke us. A country launches a provocation when it believes it can succeed; if it believes it will fail, it cannot provoke us. I think that is the key to preventing North Korean provocations this time.

※ Click the video to watch the full program.



So Jongseop: How do you think the government should respond to this situation? I'm also curious about your outlook for inter-Korean relations.


Shin Beomcheol: In fact, I thought we should have taken a tougher stance at the outset of the land mine explosion incident. The incident happened on September 21. I think it would have been better if we had expressed a firmer position from late September through early October. In any case, our government seems to have responded cautiously to facilitate dialogue with North Korea, particularly because there is a possibility of a North Korea-U.S. summit on the sidelines of APEC on November 18.


It seems the government took those factors into consideration. We cannot change the past, so under the current circumstances, we should take necessary measures while avoiding accidental clashes with North Korea. We can carry out mine-clearing operations, for example, and if North Korea operates its loudspeakers, even though that possibility is not high, we will have to respond in kind. As the possibility of a North Korea-U.S. summit on the sidelines of APEC remains open, we should coordinate with the United States so that the occasion can lead to inter-Korean dialogue. We should also consistently convey the necessary messages to North Korea behind the scenes, even if they are not made public.



We should exchange messages more actively behind the scenes, not only about the mine issue but also about inter-Korean relations in general: what kind of relationship North Korea hopes to have with the South, where we can cooperate, and what we need to insist on. That will help both sides better understand each other. It will not be easy to achieve what we want. That is the international situation right now. Even so, I think the most important thing is to build common ground that can prevent provocations and, first and foremost, maintain peace and stability on the Korean Peninsula.

[Interview] Shin Beomcheol: "The Military Must Not Appear to Back Down. It Must Respond in Principle" [Current Affairs Show] View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing