Lee Steps Directly Into Debate Over Investigative Agencies' "Neutrality"
Two straight days of rebuttals on social media... Lee escalates rhetoric, stands by policy
Cites "unconstitutional sophistry," "grounds for impeachment" and "dereliction of duty"
Blue House backs him in separate briefing
Unprecedented attendance
President Lee Jaemyung has entered the debate over the attendance of heads of investigative and prosecution agencies at Cabinet meetings, and has stepped up his rebuttals day after day. After calling opposition to their attendance “unconstitutional sophistry,” he went so far as to cite “grounds for impeachment” and the “crime of dereliction of duty,” making clear that he would stick to his existing policy. Cheong Wa Dae also backed the president’s position in a separate briefing. However, some say its hard-line response to concerns raised by some about the political neutrality of investigative agencies has instead widened the debate.
President Lee Jaemyung speaks at a Cabinet meeting held at Cheong Wa Dae on Oct. 20, 2026. Yonhap News.
View original imageOn Oct. 22, President Lee wrote on X, formerly Twitter: “Giving up the authority to direct and supervise the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency is a violation of the Constitution and the Government Organization Act and grounds for impeachment,” adding that it would be “a crime punishable by criminal penalties for dereliction of duty.” He continued: “Are you saying that the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency should not be directed and supervised because doing so would violate the Constitution and the law?” and asked, “Are you saying that direction and supervision should not take place at public meetings, but behind closed doors and in private?”
He stressed: “It is illogical to say that excluding them from attending public meetings would ensure political neutrality,” adding, “The claim that the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency should not attend open Cabinet meetings is sophistry that runs counter to the Constitution, the law, and common sense.” His argument is that the president’s authority to direct and supervise administrative agencies is not optional, but a constitutional duty.
The previous day, President Lee also introduced an answer from the generative artificial intelligence (AI) tool Gemini, calling the claim that the heads of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency and the Prosecution Agency could not attend Cabinet meetings “unconstitutional sophistry.” He also said, “Correcting the misguided perception and practices of treating agencies with investigative authority as special cases is part of normalizing what is abnormal,” adding, “There is no need to worry, as I will not direct investigations into specific cases.”
After facing criticism for using an AI response as a basis for governing, he issued another rebuttal on Oct. 22. President Lee explained, “I did not cite Gemini because I didn’t know the answer. I did so to show just how the argument runs counter to even basic logic and facts, and how low its standard is.”
Cheong Wa Dae also came to his defense. Senior Presidential Secretary for Public Relations and Communication Seong Gihong held a separate briefing at the Chunchugwan press center that morning and rejected reports that the president was relying on AI to govern, calling them “misleading or distorting the facts.” He explained that President Lee had already stated his position on the matter at a Cabinet meeting on Oct. 13, and that AI had been used as a tool to check provisions of the Constitution and the law. He added categorically, “Cabinet meetings will not address anything related to directing investigations or prosecutions in specific individual cases.”
Cheong Wa Dae also countered that the absence of prosecutors general from past Cabinet meetings had not necessarily guaranteed political neutrality. Its position was that shifting contacts between those in power and investigative agencies from behind closed doors to open Cabinet meetings could instead increase transparency. While acknowledging concerns about agency heads attending, it disagreed with the view that their attendance itself was the cause of the problem.
The attendance of investigative agency heads at Cabinet meetings is a measure introduced after the Lee Jae-myung administration took office. After President Lee instructed heads of external agencies to attend Cabinet meetings late last year, the acting heads of the prosecution service and the National Police Agency attended starting Jan. 20, 2026. According to materials submitted by the Ministry of the Interior and Safety to People Power Party lawmaker Shin Dong-wook, there had been no instances of a prosecutor general attending a Cabinet meeting between 2000 and December 2025. The National Police Agency chief had attended only three times during the same period.
Concerns were also raised in January 2026 that the independence of investigative agencies could be undermined, but the debate did not gain momentum at the time. Both the prosecution service and the police were then being led by acting heads, and the move was largely seen as an administrative efficiency measure to expand Cabinet meeting attendance to external agencies more broadly. This time, however, the political significance has changed because the first head of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency, established following the abolition of the Prosecutors’ Office and the separation of investigation and prosecution functions, attended in person.
The opposition, including the People Power Party, argues that the investigative agency heads’ regular face-to-face meetings with the president could itself exert unspoken pressure. The People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy also urged that their regular attendance be suspended, saying it could place political pressure on investigative and prosecution agencies even without specific instructions on cases.
The prevailing view in legal circles is that it would be difficult to prohibit attendance itself under the law. Article 8 of the Cabinet Meeting Regulations stipulates that the chair may have the head of a central administrative agency attend when deemed necessary. However, this provision permits attendance; it does not require investigative agency heads to attend regularly. This is why some say the president’s authority to direct and supervise agencies should be considered separately from whether their attendance at Cabinet meetings is appropriate.
Kim Jiyong, chief of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency, delivers remarks at a Cabinet meeting presided over by President Lee Jaemyung at Cheong Wa Dae on Oct. 20, 2026. Yonhap News
View original imageSome in political circles have also questioned President Lee’s response. The debate has taken a different turn after the president countered questions about whether the agency heads’ attendance was advisable with phrases such as “unconstitutional sophistry” and “the crime of dereliction of duty.” Some argue that the issue was amplified as he responded to criticism from some quarters by treating it as a challenge to his constitutional authority.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
However, as President Lee and Cheong Wa Dae have repeatedly reaffirmed the attendance policy, the way the meetings are conducted is unlikely to change in the immediate future. “The key issue in the debate going forward will be how much political neutrality the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency and the Prosecution Agency, established as part of prosecution reform, can secure within the president’s system for directing government affairs,” a ruling-party official said.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.