"Mandatory Tender Offers Need Stronger Rules to Prevent Loopholes"
Sharp criticism at Governance Forum seminar
Pro rata purchases aren't foolproof... Rules needed to block loopholes
Measures needed, including mandatory board negotiations
"Rules should also address the scope and purpose of joint holdings"
Presenters take part in a panel discussion at a seminar titled “Directors’ Duty of Loyalty and the Introduction of a Mandatory Tender Offer System,” hosted by the Korea Corporate Governance Forum in Yeouido, Yeongdeungpo-gu, Seoul, on the 22nd.
View original imageAmid heated debate over introducing a "mandatory tender offer system" to protect ordinary shareholders when corporate control changes hands, experts have warned that simply introducing the system is not enough: directors' "duty of loyalty to shareholders" must first be established, along with carefully crafted acquisition rules. They also noted that the proposed alternative of pro rata purchases requires rules and standards to prevent controlling shareholders from exploiting loopholes.
Lee Sang-hoon, a professor at Kyungpook National University Law School, made the remarks on October 22 at a seminar titled "Directors' Duty of Loyalty and the Introduction of a Mandatory Tender Offer System," hosted by the Korea Corporate Governance Forum. He pointed to problems with the current alternative bill put forward by the National Assembly's Political Affairs Committee.
The mandatory tender offer bill that has passed the National Assembly's Political Affairs Committee is built around a partial purchase of "50% plus one share" and a "prior purchase" that gives priority to buying the controlling shareholder's shares. Professor Lee sharply criticized the proposal, saying, "The controlling shareholder is guaranteed the sale of 100% of their shares, while ordinary shareholders get an opportunity only to sell whatever remains. In effect, this is a bad system that reduces ordinary shareholders to 'second-class citizens.'"
Voices are growing, particularly among some market participants and asset managers, calling for pro rata purchases of all shareholders' shares at the same rate instead of prior purchases. However, Professor Lee cautioned that pro rata purchases are no panacea. "It is unlikely that controlling shareholders will readily accept a pro rata purchase," he said, warning that "there is a high risk they will circumvent the rules by offering separate side deals or special benefits exclusively to controlling shareholders as 'indirect compensation.'" For pro rata purchases to lead to genuine equality among shareholders, he said, rules must be put in place to block indirect compensation to controlling shareholders at the outset and strictly require the same price and the same opportunity for all.
Above all, Professor Lee stressed that the foundation for all these systems must be the legal establishment of "directors' duty of loyalty to protect shareholders' proportionate interests." Although the United States has no mandatory tender offer system, ordinary shareholders receive 100% of the same consideration in M&A transactions thanks to a strong "duty of loyalty to shareholders" established under case law. Without this principle, mechanically introducing a system alone could repeat the past mistake of formulaic merger-ratio rules being exploited as a shield for transactions involving controlling shareholders, he warned.
As alternatives, Professor Lee proposed substantially strengthening board accountability by requiring boards to: ▲ negotiate directly from the due diligence stage of M&A transactions to secure ordinary shareholders' share of the proceeds; ▲ conduct a majority-of-the-minority (MoM) vote in tender offers, excluding interested parties; and ▲ review whether controlling shareholders received special benefits when transactions close.
"A mandatory tender offer is not a decision made solely by the controlling shareholder; it uses the resources of the entire company," Professor Lee said. "Ordinary shareholders will be genuinely protected only if a system is in place that requires boards, which wield the company's authority, to actively participate in negotiations among shareholders and take responsibility."
Meanwhile, Kim Min-guk, CEO of VIP Asset Management, pushed back against concerns that introducing mandatory tender offers would dampen M&A activity during the panel discussion that followed. "The number of M&A transactions in Japan actually increased even after it introduced legislation requiring mandatory tender offers," he said. "There is no evidence that the introduction of regulation itself prevents M&A. Once consistent rules are in place, the market adapts rationally and transactions continue." He argued that the system could have the positive effect of filtering out "bad M&A" that destroys corporate value and exploits ordinary shareholders, while helping establish sound M&A practices.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Lee Jong-eun, an attorney at Nexus Law Firm, highlighted the possibility of circumventing the rules through friendly shareholdings, or joint shareholdings. He explained that a controlling stake could be secured through friendly shareholders after acquiring less than the 25% stake that triggers a mandatory tender offer. "As in the UK, the scope of 'joint holdings' should be clearly defined and regulated," he said. "It is also essential to establish detailed rules, as in Hong Kong, to thoroughly assess special benefits (economic gains) provided to controlling shareholders and require them to be shared with ordinary shareholders or forcibly reflected in the tender offer price."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.