France's national debt nears 120% of GDP
Fiscal woes shake even the education system

South Korea's free school meals and uniforms...
Hard to cut spending that has become "entitlements"
National Pension raises domestic stock allocation
O

France has been struggling recently. Its gross domestic product (GDP) stands at around $3.17 trillion, while its national debt is approaching 120% of GDP. Interest payments alone are expected to come close to 100 trillion won this year, equivalent to 19% of the government's net revenue.


The resulting unrest is shaking the entire country. Poor-quality classes caused by teacher shortages, leaking buildings and broken toilets, and educational environments where rats and cockroaches appear: these are all realities at Saint-Exupery High School, the epicenter of the unrest. Teachers took collective action first, and students joined them. The protests have spread across France.


Students hold signs during a protest in Paris, France, on the 5th. They have been staging large-scale demonstrations day after day over rising prices and the deterioration of public finances and services in France, demanding lower university tuition and improvements to educational conditions. AP-Yonhap News

Students hold signs during a protest in Paris, France, on the 5th. They have been staging large-scale demonstrations day after day over rising prices and the deterioration of public finances and services in France, demanding lower university tuition and improvements to educational conditions. AP-Yonhap News

View original image

Whether for a household or a country, managing finances is always a difficult task. You can spend only what you have, and spending beyond your means leads to trouble. Once you get used to accounting classifications that treat debt as an asset, it is easy to fall into the illusion that other people's money is your own. Tightening the reins again after they have been loosened comes with tremendous pain. That is why fiscal belt-tightening is so difficult. Is there really a politician who would dare propose cutting spending that has, by now, become a perceived right?


Free school meals are a good example. School lunches have long since become a fond memory recalled only by generations now in their 40s and older. In 2021, free school meals were fully implemented at every elementary, middle and high school nationwide. That came 10 years after Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon risked his position in 2011 by opposing free school meals. This year, free school meals are now the "default" for parents. They have taken root as a system people take for granted. It is hard even to imagine returning to the days of packed lunches. Government spending has also more than doubled, rising from 309 trillion won in 2011 to 727 trillion won this year. As the country has grown fiscally richer, people have come to enjoy more. That is unquestionably a happy and welcome development. School uniforms have also become free. But that does not mean free school meals or free uniforms can be claimed as rights.


The National Pension Fund presents a somewhat different case. In May this year, it raised the allocation to domestic stocks from the original 14.9% to 20.8%. This revised a plan to reduce the allocation to around 15% by the end of 2025. As a booming stock market rapidly increased the share of domestic stocks, the fund chose to sustain the momentum of the bull market rather than reduce its domestic stock allocation to check the market's extraordinary boom. Including strategic investments, the allocation rose to as much as 23.8%, which soon became a burden as the market shifted sharply. Just two months later, as the stock market began plunging in July, the National Pension Fund's market-stabilizing role was not being exercised. This was the result of failing to reduce the allocation as planned at a time when it should have done so, because the fund was concerned about public opinion.


All these cases suggest that we need to revisit the principles of fiscal management. These principles are always necessary, whether resources are abundant or scarce. For a sailor crossing uncertain seas, what matters is not an exciting, thrilling voyage, but one that is as predictable as possible, whether the waters are calm or a storm is raging. Moreover, a country's finances are fundamental to running the nation. Above all, they must be managed with predictability and stability as the top priorities. To achieve that, the most important thing is to maintain a debt ratio that can be managed under any circumstances. At some point, France failed to manage its debt ratio, while the National Pension Fund, intoxicated by the boom, changed a domestic stock allocation benchmark that had been set long ago.


Norway's sovereign wealth fund, valued at $2.3 trillion, is the world's largest. Built from revenue generated by oil and natural gas, the fund follows principles that are simple but clear: "earn more, but do not lose"; "make no domestic investments that could disrupt the market"; and "maintain a strict separation from politics." It is also guaranteed independence from fiscal and monetary policy. All investment and voting records are transparently disclosed to the public. For Norway, the sovereign wealth fund is for the future, not the present. These are points we should examine closely.


The Minister of Health and Welfare chairs the National Pension Fund Management Committee. The ministers of relevant government agencies, including the Ministry of Finance and Economy, participate as ex officio members. This structure leaves pension management independent neither from politics nor from fiscal and monetary policy. As a rule, meeting records are disclosed one year after a meeting, but in exceptional cases disclosure can be delayed until four years later. The decisions made in May this year will be disclosed in 2030, four years later, due to their sensitive nature. There are clear limits to transparency. When pension management is influenced by politics and the prevailing climate, its principles are undermined. That makes it harder to respond to an uncertain future.


Fiscal rules are mechanisms that set statutory limits on national debt or fiscal deficits and call for efforts to adhere to them under all circumstances. The eurozone's fiscal rules set limits of 60% of GDP for public debt and 3% for the fiscal deficit. France is nearing 120% and 6%, respectively. It has strayed far from the fiscal rules it is supposed to follow. The government tried to cut various essential expenditures, including old-age pensions, but failed to do so. The further it strays from fiscal rules, the harder fiscal belt-tightening becomes. This is the fundamental cause of the unrest in France today.


Rep. Bae Jun-young of the People Power Party, chair of the Economic and Fiscal Subcommittee of the National Assembly’s Finance and Economy Planning Committee, declares the opening of a meeting on the 4th. The subcommittee reviewed bills including the Future Response Fund Act and amendments to the National Finance Act. Yonhap News

Rep. Bae Jun-young of the People Power Party, chair of the Economic and Fiscal Subcommittee of the National Assembly’s Finance and Economy Planning Committee, declares the opening of a meeting on the 4th. The subcommittee reviewed bills including the Future Response Fund Act and amendments to the National Finance Act. Yonhap News

View original image

South Korea is one of the few OECD member countries that have not legislated fiscal rules. As of this year, public debt is slightly above 50% of GDP, and the deficit is around 4%. The figures alone may suggest that the situation is still manageable, but they create a misleading impression. They do not include 1,200 trillion won in pension liabilities. Including these liabilities would push the figure well above 80% of GDP. Add the rapid aging of the population, which will create an enormous fiscal burden in the future, and there is suddenly plenty of cause for concern. In fact, warning signs that South Korea needs fiscal rules have been evident for a long time. The government has submitted amendments to the National Finance Act several times, but the National Assembly has yet to respond, amid disputes between the ruling and opposition parties.


There is an even greater concern these days. The National Finance Act sets out principles for managing fiscal surpluses. Unpaid local grants must be settled, and the funds must first be used for the Public Funds Repayment Fund and repayment of national debt. Only after that may they be used for supplementary budgets or carried forward as revenue for the following year. With an unprecedented semiconductor boom this year expected to generate more than 50 trillion won in excess tax revenue, the government is considering allocating resources to the Future Response Fund. This would be another attempt to violate the rules, following the case of the National Pension Fund. It stands in contrast to Norway's sovereign wealth fund, which steadfastly adheres to the principle of "earn more, but do not lose" and rigorously maintains its independence and transparency.


France first breached the eurozone's fiscal rules in 2002. There may have been various causes, including the global financial crisis and COVID-19, but from the government's perspective, this was an unmistakable failure of fiscal management. It was also a failure of innovation. France fell short in its efforts to innovate through the Fourth Industrial Revolution and the AI revolution. It failed to adequately address any of these challenges: rising public spending, declining tax revenue and waning innovation. But these are all just excuses. A capable captain does not blame the rough seas. They prepare for crises in advance and remain vigilant in the present. We must not grow complacent over record tax revenues from the semiconductor boom, or because our debt and fiscal deficit are lower than those of competing countries. The waves are always higher than expected. That is why, as we watch the unrest in France, we must think again about the importance of principles.



[Beyond Lee Hyukwoo's Frame] France Today: How to Keep It from Becoming Our Tomorrow... View original image


Lee Hyukwoo, Professor of Public Administration at Pai Chai University (Chair of the Regulatory Monitoring Committee at the Good Regulation Citizens' Forum)


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing