"It is illogical to claim that excluding the SCIA from open meetings ensures political neutrality"
Directly rebuts AI-use criticism: "I didn’t cite Gemini because I didn’t know"

On Oct. 22, President Lee Jae-myung said, regarding the controversy over whether the head of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency (SCIA) should attend Cabinet meetings, that "giving up the authority to direct and supervise the SCIA would violate the Constitution and the Government Organization Act and constitute grounds for impeachment," and that it would be "a crime punishable as dereliction of duty." He reiterated his rebuttal to arguments against the SCIA chief attending Cabinet meetings on the grounds of investigative agencies' political neutrality, stressing that the president's administrative oversight is a constitutional duty, not a matter of choice.


President Lee Jae-myung delivers remarks at the Autumn Sports Festival held at Wanggung Elementary School in Iksan, North Jeolla Province, on Oct. 22, 2026. Yonhap News.

President Lee Jae-myung delivers remarks at the Autumn Sports Festival held at Wanggung Elementary School in Iksan, North Jeolla Province, on Oct. 22, 2026. Yonhap News.

View original image

On X (formerly Twitter) that day, Lee wrote, "The Constitution and the Government Organization Act explicitly state that all ministries and agencies, whether the Public Prosecution Office, the Korea Meteorological Administration or the National Fire Agency, are subject to the direction and supervision of the president and the prime minister," adding, "The president's direction and supervision of state affairs is both a power and a responsibility."


He continued, "Are you saying the SCIA should not be directed or supervised, in violation of the Constitution and the law?" He also asked, "Are you saying that direction and supervision should not take place in open meetings, but behind closed doors?"


He criticized the argument that excluding the SCIA from open meetings would ensure political neutrality, calling it "illogical," and said, "The demand that the SCIA not attend open Cabinet meetings is an absurd argument that runs counter to the Constitution, the law and common sense."


Lee also directly countered criticism that he had responded to the controversy by quoting an answer from Gemini, a generative artificial intelligence (AI). "I didn't cite Gemini because I didn't know the answer. I did so to show just how elementary the logic was, how far it strayed from the facts and how low its level was," he explained.


On Oct. 21, Lee had also introduced an answer from Gemini, calling arguments against the heads of the Public Prosecution Office and the SCIA attending Cabinet meetings "unconstitutional sophistry." At the time, Lee said, "Correcting the misguided perception and practice of treating investigative agencies as special cases is also part of normalizing what has become abnormal," adding, "There is no need to worry; I will not direct investigations into specific cases."


The controversy erupted on Oct. 20, when Kim Ji-yong, the first head of the SCIA, attended a Cabinet meeting presided over by the president for the first time since taking office. Kim was criticized over concerns that the independence and political neutrality of investigative agencies could be undermined after he was shown taking notes as Lee spoke during a live broadcast. Opposition parties, including the People Power Party, argued that the agency chief's regular face-to-face meetings with the president could in themselves serve as an implicit pressure on investigations.


At a briefing that morning, Cheong Wa Dae also pushed back against criticism of the president's alleged reliance on AI and the attendance of investigative agency chiefs at Cabinet meetings. Senior Secretary for Public Communications Seong Gi-hong asked whether political independence could be said to have been secured even when the prosecutor general did not attend Cabinet meetings, and explained that it was inappropriate to equate attendance at Cabinet meetings with political control over investigative agencies or interference in investigations into individual cases.


Article 11 of the Government Organization Act stipulates that, as head of the government, the president shall direct and supervise the heads of all central administrative agencies in accordance with laws and regulations. Article 8 of the Cabinet Meeting Regulations, however, states that the head of a central administrative agency may attend a Cabinet meeting when the chair deems it necessary. Some interpretations therefore hold that the president's administrative oversight authority and the obligation of investigative agency chiefs to attend Cabinet meetings are separate legal issues.



With Lee directly rebutting the criticism for a second consecutive day, the debate over investigative agency chiefs attending Cabinet meetings appears to be widening into a clash between the president's administrative oversight authority and the political neutrality of investigative agencies.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing