"Government card news on grant reform fails to reflect local education finance conditions"
The superintendents' council to produce and distribute its own card news

The 16 provincial and metropolitan superintendents of education across the country have pushed back against the government's card news on its proposed reform of local education finance grants, saying it presents a one-sided account that does not reflect actual education finance conditions. They argue that the card news highlights only the increase in grant funding while failing to account for declining revenue and essential education expenses beyond personnel costs. In response, they plan to create and distribute their own card news.


On October 22, the Korean Council of Superintendents of Education announced that it would launch a second public information campaign with 16 provincial and metropolitan offices of education to explain the problems with the government's account of the grant reform proposal.


Korea Council of Education Superintendents

Korea Council of Education Superintendents

View original image

Earlier, on October 14, the Ministry of Finance and Economy distributed card news titled "Misconceptions and Facts About Grant Reform" through the Korea Policy Briefing website. The council, however, said the card news emphasizes only the government's position without reflecting actual local education finance conditions and spending structures, and focused its rebuttal in particular on the explanation concerning teacher personnel costs.


For example, in response to concerns that the grant reform could make it difficult to pay teacher personnel costs, the government said in the card news that "the increase in personnel costs can be covered sufficiently." It cited the fact that grants in 2027 would increase by KRW 7.2 trillion from the previous year's original budget, while the increase in personnel costs would be only KRW 2.5 trillion.


The council, however, pointed out that the government had used figures that did not include the supplementary budget.


The government said grants would increase by 10.1%, comparing the 2026 original budget of KRW 71.7 trillion with its 2027 proposal of KRW 78.9 trillion. But grants, including this year's supplementary budget, amount to KRW 76.4 trillion, the council said. On that basis, next year's grants would increase by about KRW 2.43 trillion, or just 3.2%.


The council also said that declines in other education finance revenues should be taken into account.


According to the council, revenue is expected to fall by a total of KRW 1.87 trillion next year, including about KRW 274.1 billion in additional national grants for free high school education and about KRW 1.6 trillion from the local education tax levied on tobacco consumption. The council said that after subtracting the increase in personnel costs and the decline in revenue from the KRW 7.2 trillion grant increase cited by the government, the remaining funds would shrink to about KRW 2.83 trillion. It also cited the government's plan to transfer about KRW 1.8 trillion in education tax revenue to the Special Account for Higher and Lifelong Education Support as an additional cost burden.


The council also pointed to teacher shortages in schools. As of this year, it said, schools are short a total of 18,089 teachers: 503 fixed-term subject and special education teachers beyond the authorized staffing quota, and 17,586 non-subject teachers, including health, nutrition, librarian, and professional counseling teachers. The council estimated that hiring enough teachers to fill the gap would require an additional KRW 1.0889 trillion annually. It also emphasized that essential expenses beyond teacher personnel costs, including school operating expenses, meal costs, utility bills, and renovations to aging facilities, continue to accrue.


The council said the financial burden on education offices would grow further when declines in transfers from local governments, the expanded burden on education offices for national policy projects such as after-school programs and Neulbom School, and the funding required for new policies such as the integration of early childhood education and childcare are also taken into account.


The council emphasized, "Concluding that there is 'ample room' based only on a comparison of the increase in grants and the increase in personnel costs does not reflect actual education finance conditions. To assess the sustainability of local education finance, it is necessary to consider not only the scale of grant increases but also declining revenue, essential expenditures, and additional costs arising from national policies."



The council plans to produce a second set of card news to correct problems in the government's explanation and inform the public about actual local education finance conditions, and to conduct a joint campaign with 16 provincial and metropolitan offices of education.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing