Banks Conduct "Too-Late" Audits Only After Incidents Hit... Respond Slowly Despite Warnings from Overseas Regulators
[The True Face of K Banks Beyond Borders] ④
Vulnerabilities at Bank Woori Saudara Identified Two Years Before Incident
Shinhan Bank Vietnam Found to Have Deficiencies in Credit Management
KB Prasac, Hit by Embezzlement and Breach of Trust, Excluded from Head Office's Annual Audit Plan
Criticism is mounting that banks have failed to break the vicious cycle of financial incidents, as their internal control systems continue to function poorly despite repeated sanctions and warnings from local regulators. Banks that have pledged to strengthen internal controls have not made their oversight of overseas branches effective, exposing limitations not only in preventing incidents but also in responding to them after they occur.
Indonesian business daily Warta Ekonomi reported in June 2025, citing remarks by Dian Ediana Rae, the banking supervision chief at Indonesia’s Financial Services Authority (OJK), that the regulator had been warning about vulnerabilities in the transaction process since 2023. Another Indonesian outlet, Bloomberg Technoz, also reported that OJK had identified weaknesses in the letter-of-credit transaction process at Bank Woori Saudara during an inspection in 2023 and warned the bank. If local media reports are accurate, the local financial regulator had identified the relevant issues about two years before the financial incident occurred.
According to the office of Rep. Kim Jae-seop of the People Power Party on October 22, Woori Bank discovered the financial incident at Bank Woori Saudara on May 27, 2025. If the regulator’s warning came at the end of 2023, Woori Bank failed to identify problems with the transactions during its own inspections for about 17 months. Woori Bank said, “We received no separate warning or notice in advance, either directly or informally, regarding letter-of-credit transactions involving purchased foreign exchange.”
An inspection by Vietnam’s financial authorities also brought the credit management procedures at an overseas branch under scrutiny. Shinhan Bank Vietnam’s Da Nang Branch did not obtain sufficient documentation during the loan review process to verify borrowers’ ability to repay. It also failed to comply with the intervals set out in internal regulations for checking how funds were used after loans were disbursed. Shortcomings were also identified in the management of collateral and guarantee documents, as well as in tracking and managing assets acquired with loan proceeds. Vietnam’s financial authorities issued a total of nine recommendations for improvement to Shinhan Bank Vietnam’s head office and Da Nang Branch.
Shinhan Bank called the measures “general recommendations” and said, “Interpreting the inspection results as indicating serious problems with the overall credit review and post-loan management systems at Shinhan Bank Vietnam differs from the actual findings.” However, according to the Council for International Financial Cooperation (CIFC), as of May 2026, Korean banks operated a total of 20 locations in Vietnam, including local subsidiaries, branches, and offices. The fact that Shinhan Bank alone received such recommendations suggests that its internal control procedures are not functioning properly on the ground. Shinhan Bank also suffered two embezzlement incidents in Vietnam, one last year and another this year. Receiving recommendations from local authorities after repeated financial incidents suggests that the bank’s follow-up measures were inadequate.
On October 12, the Shanghai Office of China’s National Financial Regulatory Administration imposed a fine of 800,000 yuan (approximately KRW 160 million) on Hana Bank China’s Shanghai Pudong Branch. The violations involved inflating deposit and loan performance figures and charging fees on loans. Of the 18 sanctions against financial companies announced that day by the Shanghai Office, Hana Bank China was the only foreign bank.
Although financial incidents have occurred repeatedly in Southeast Asia, critics say audits of overseas subsidiaries by their head offices have not done enough to prevent them. According to Rep. Kim’s office, KB Prasac Bank, which suffered three financial incidents last year involving embezzlement, occupational breach of trust, and fraud, was not included in the 2025 annual audit plan of its parent company, KB Kookmin Bank. KB Kookmin Bank conducted audits only after financial incidents occurred in Indonesia and Cambodia, sending staff from its audit department at headquarters to carry out inspections belatedly. Critics say the fact that overseas subsidiaries where incidents occurred had not been included in the head office’s audit plans in advance may have limited the bank’s ability to identify and address potential risks early.
A KB Kookmin Bank official said, “It is not practical to audit every overseas location each year, so we select locations with internal control deficiencies based on factors such as their internal control ratings and risk levels. In the case of KB Prasac, we conducted an on-site inspection separately after a financial incident occurred.”
Criticism has also been raised that while Korean banks are expanding their overseas businesses, their internal controls over local subsidiaries and their oversight of overseas operations are failing to keep pace. According to the Financial Supervisory Service’s data on overseas sanctions, from 2020 through July 2024, Hana Bank received the most sanctions from foreign financial authorities among Korea’s five major banks, with 49. Shinhan Bank followed with 33, KB Kookmin Bank with 32, and Woori Bank with 16. NongHyup Bank received no sanctions.
When financial incidents recur because of inadequate oversight of overseas subsidiaries, they can not only damage a bank’s credibility but also erode the trust of local financial authorities and constrain business activity. They can also weigh on earnings. Woori Bank’s 11 overseas subsidiaries posted combined net losses of KRW 57.083 billion in the first half of 2026, largely because they could not offset the KRW 142.549 billion net loss at Bank Woori Saudara.
Bin Ki-beom, a professor in the Division of Economics and Statistics at Myongji University, said, “Financial incidents at overseas subsidiaries are a negative issue for the domestic head office in their own right, regardless of their scale, because they force it to bear unnecessary costs. If a subsidiary is listed on a local securities market, embezzlement or breach of trust can lead to issues being raised at shareholder meetings by local shareholders, as well as civil and criminal proceedings such as lawsuits and complaints. Such subsidiaries cannot avoid sanctions from local financial authorities, so banks need to pay even greater attention to preventing financial incidents overseas.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Lee Chang-min, a professor in the Department of Business Administration at Hanyang University, said, “Incidents at overseas subsidiaries can also damage the brand recognition of their domestic head offices. Even non-financial multinational companies manage risks rigorously because they can face sanctions from local authorities when problems arise at independent suppliers in their supply chains, not just at wholly owned subsidiaries. Korean banks operating overseas should likewise further strengthen their internal control systems for managing local financial incidents to meet the standards expected of multinational companies.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.