Unmeasurable "equal value" makes the labor market rigid

Uniform compensation that ignores individual differences is unfair

Good intentions to protect regular employees shift costs onto young people

Go beyond wage protection and secure

[The View] Wage System Reform Could Send a Chill Through the Hiring Market View original image

The government has announced plans to draw up a detailed roadmap by this December to legislate the principle of equal pay for work of equal value. This shows the government’s strong commitment to implementing the policy. In principle, of course, workers who create the same value should not be unfairly paid less simply because they are not regular employees. But now, as youth unemployment rises and advances in artificial intelligence (AI) accelerate structural changes in the labor market more than ever, the policy’s economic and managerial effects need to be examined dispassionately. Good intentions behind a policy to narrow wage gaps do not always produce just outcomes.


The most important economic question is who can define and assess work of equal value, and according to what criteria. This is not merely a difficult problem to measure; it is closer to an impossible one. For example, suppose two employees perform the same programming job. One completes a particular task in an hour, while the other takes three hours to finish the same task. Although they do the same job, there is a clear difference in their performance and productivity. In that case, would it not be fairer to reward them differently according to their productivity? Moreover, it would also be necessary to account for whether these differences in performance stem from individual abilities, team characteristics, the work environment, or other factors.


Even companies with professional human resources departments struggle every year to conduct performance reviews—that is, to measure each employee’s contributions. It would be even harder for third parties such as government agencies or courts to measure them objectively. If the standard for determining work of equal value is vague, and people receive the same compensation even when they work hard or achieve better results, who would make an extra effort? From a worker’s perspective, doing less work during set hours while receiving the same compensation could instead be a rational choice. The policy could even encourage employees to shirk their duties. This could not only undermine individual motivation but also weaken productivity across the organization.


Next, the managerial effects on businesses must be considered. The principle of equal pay for work of equal value is likely to be implemented in a way that increases companies’ wage costs. To cover these higher costs, companies are likely to cut back on new hiring. They may then respond by reducing working hours, automating some tasks, or outsourcing them. Paradoxically, those who could suffer the most in this process are the most vulnerable people in the job market: young people who have not even managed to get a foot in the door. When hiring new workers, companies find it difficult to accurately assess their actual productivity. If wages cannot be adjusted to reflect initial productivity and the time needed to adapt to the job, hiring new employees whose abilities have not yet been proven becomes an even greater burden. In other words, companies may find it better not to hire an applicant than to hire someone whose capabilities have not been verified.


As uncertainty in the labor market grows further amid the advent of the AI era, what we need is not rigid employment regulation but a labor market that can respond flexibly to change. Companies can hire new workers if they have the flexibility to do so, and opportunities open up for young people when new jobs are created. When opportunities open up, the economy can regain its vitality. The greater the burden on companies, the more likely they are to close the door to hiring. Conversely, to encourage companies to open that door wide, we must ensure flexibility while compensating workers fairly for the value of their labor.


More important than the good intentions or stated rationale behind a policy is making practical judgments, based on scientific research and empirical evidence, about who actually benefits and who bears the costs. A better labor market should do more than protect the wages of those who already have jobs; it should also provide opportunities for those who have yet to find work.



Na-gyeong Gyeong, Professor of Business Administration at Sungkyunkwan University


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing