Art historian who brought cultural heritage to the public through “My Cultural Heritage Exploration”
Calligraphy by a pro-Japanese collaborator exhibited as a patriot’s work... Controversy over inadequate verification and conflicts of interest
Resig

Last July, Park Yong Hyun, the son of independence activist Park Won Geun, visited the National Museum of Korea’s special exhibition “Our Table” and knelt in front of a work presented as his father’s calligraphy, weeping. He was moved that the national museum had found a trace of an independence activist whose personal effects had not survived. But the calligraphy was not his father’s. It was a work by Park Jungyang, a pro-Japanese collaborator. It was also revealed that the person who had personally recommended the work was Yoo Hongjun, the museum’s director and its owner.

Yoo Hongjun, director of the National Museum of Korea, listens to a committee member's questions during a parliamentary audit by the Culture, Sports and Tourism Committee at the National Assembly on the 19th. Yonhap News Agency.

Yoo Hongjun, director of the National Museum of Korea, listens to a committee member's questions during a parliamentary audit by the Culture, Sports and Tourism Committee at the National Assembly on the 19th. Yonhap News Agency.

View original image

Yoo Hongjun, an art historian who helped popularize Korea’s cultural heritage through his “My Exploration of Cultural Heritage” series and director of the National Museum of Korea, has ultimately announced his intention to resign. It has been 15 months since he took office last July. The National Museum of Korea, on the verge of surpassing 7 million visitors, has suffered a blow to its academic credibility amid controversy over the display of its director’s personal collection and inadequate verification.


In a statement issued through the National Museum of Korea on the 21st, Yoo said, “The deep trust that the public has placed in the National Museum of Korea and the value built up by our museum staff have been brought down in an instant by my personal mistake.”


He continued, “I take full responsibility for all the criticism,” adding, “I have concluded that stepping down as director is the right thing to do to restore the museum’s tarnished reputation.” He decided his future just two days after lawmakers from both the ruling and opposition parties criticized him during a parliamentary audit by the National Assembly’s Culture, Sports and Tourism Committee on the 19th, where he promised to improve the verification system.


The controversy began with “Ilbansigukeun,” a work included in the special exhibition “Our Table,” which opened on July 1. The phrase means “Even a single bowl of rice is a blessing from the nation.” The museum identified the calligraphy as the work of Park Won Geun (1912–1950), an independence activist from Boeun, North Chungcheong Province, on the basis of the name “Park Won Geun” inscribed on the work.


However, questions about who wrote the work arose in August after it became known that Park Jungyang (1874–1959), a pro-Japanese collaborator, had used the name Park Won Geun while studying in Japan. The museum removed the work on August 10 and asked seven experts in calligraphy, modern and contemporary history, ancient documents, and conservation science to verify it. On September 7, it officially announced that the calligraphy was by Park Jungyang.


Yoo Hongjun, director of the National Museum of Korea, explains the controversial work "Ilbansigukeun" at the "Taste vs. Taste" special lecture held in conjunction with the special exhibition "Our Table." Yonhap News

Yoo Hongjun, director of the National Museum of Korea, explains the controversial work "Ilbansigukeun" at the "Taste vs. Taste" special lecture held in conjunction with the special exhibition "Our Table." Yonhap News

View original image

The fact that Park Jungyang had used the name Park Won Geun was also recorded in the government’s 2009 “Report on the Investigation into Pro-Japanese, Anti-National Acts.” This prompted criticism that the national museum had proceeded with the exhibition without adequately comparing the work with previously published historical records and other examples of the calligrapher’s handwriting.


At first, the incident was viewed as an academic error in identifying the author of an exhibit. The situation changed when documents submitted to the National Assembly on the 15th confirmed that Yoo owned the work.


Yoo bought the calligraphy at an online auction in 2019 for 50,000 won. It was listed at the time as a work by “Park Deokwon,” who had taken part in a Joseon diplomatic mission to Japan. Yoo explained that he had bought it intending to donate it to the Buyeo Cultural Center and submitted it because it suited the theme of the special exhibition.


The issue was how the decision to exhibit the work was made. According to documents submitted to the National Assembly, the work was not included in the original list of exhibits finalized in February. But after Yoo recommended it on May 8, a consent form for its exhibition and a receipt for its transfer were prepared on the 19th, and its location in the exhibition was finalized on the 22nd after a report to the director. It took 14 days from the recommendation to the final decision on where to display it.


It also emerged that no sufficiently thorough independent appraisal had been conducted to verify the author of the work. Asked during the parliamentary audit on the 19th why he was certain the calligraphy was by Park Won Geun, Yoo replied, “Because calligraphy history is my field of expertise.” Critics questioned whether the director’s expert judgment had effectively taken the place of the museum’s internal verification procedures.


The use of an institution head’s personal collection in an exhibition also became controversial in itself. Since a National Museum exhibition could affect a work’s value, critics said the potential conflict of interest should have been carefully examined. Yoo explained that he had no intention of gaining personal benefit and had planned to donate the work after the exhibition.


Another factor that fueled the controversy was the failure to disclose who owned the work. After removing it, the museum and Yoo apologized for the inadequate verification but did not reveal that the director was the owner. The fact came to light through documents submitted to the National Assembly more than two months later.


During the parliamentary audit, Yoo explained that at first he had hesitated to say that he had exhibited a work from his personal collection because it might have seemed like bragging. After it was identified as a work by a pro-Japanese collaborator, he said, he was embarrassed to admit his mistake as an art historian. He acknowledged that failing to disclose his ownership was “a serious error and an oversight.”


Questions were also raised about the boundary between personal collections and public exhibitions. An “embroidered table cover” owned by Yoo was also included in the same special exhibition. At the parliamentary audit, lawmakers also pointed out that the museum had been slow to post online information about two works, including a stone tiger statue, donated to the museum by Yoo’s spouse. The museum explained that it had taken time to photograph the works in high resolution because the heavy objects were difficult to move to the photography studio.


Controversy also arose because an exhibition on Gyeomjae Jeong Seon at the National Museum of Korea in February coincided with the publication of a personal book by Yoo. Critics said that Yoo’s decision to sign copies of his book after giving a lecture related to the exhibition blurred the line between exhibitions at a public institution and personal writing. The museum explained that it had independently organized the event to mark the 350th anniversary of Jeong Seon’s birth and the reopening of its calligraphy and painting gallery, and that it was unrelated to the book’s publication.


Yoo is a leading art historian who has made Korea’s cultural heritage accessible to the public by presenting it through engaging stories. After making his debut as an art critic in the Dong-A Ilbo’s annual literary contest in 1981, he taught art history at Yeungnam University, Myongji University, and other institutions. Published in 1993, his “My Exploration of Cultural Heritage” series sparked a boom in heritage tours and expanded cultural heritage from a subject of expert research into an area of popular interest.


In September 2004, he took office as head of the Cultural Heritage Administration under the Roh Moo-hyun administration and led the management of cultural heritage. However, he faced controversy several times during his tenure. It emerged that his name had been inscribed inside the bell at Naksansa Temple, which was destroyed in a wildfire and later restored. In 2007, the Cultural Heritage Administration came under fire for purchasing five of his books with government funds and distributing them for promotional purposes. Yoo said he had not personally ordered the purchases and donated the related proceeds.


In 2008, after a fire destroyed the national treasure Sungnyemun Gate, he submitted his resignation, taking responsibility as head of the Cultural Heritage Administration for its management and oversight. He also faced criticism over a trip seen as a vacation after it emerged that he had been traveling in Europe with his spouse at the time. With his announcement that he intends to resign, he will become the head of a national cultural heritage institution for the second time without completing his term.


Yoo Hongjun Resigns in Disgrace After 15 Months as Museum Nears 7 Million Visitors Over 'Self-Submitted' Work View original image

Serving as director of the National Museum of Korea had long been an ambition of Yoo’s. In 2003, he applied for the open recruitment for the director’s position but withdrew his application amid controversy, including speculation that the appointment had already been decided. More than 20 years later, he took the position. When he assumed office last July, he outlined plans to introduce cultural heritage to a broader public and present the history and value of Korean art to the world.


In particular, he emphasized plans to reimagine and present the “Five Thousand Years of Korean Art” exhibition, which introduced the excellence of traditional Korean culture to overseas audiences in the 1970s and 1980s. The aim was to highlight Korea’s cultural heritage as the roots of K-culture and expand the museum’s international role.


The National Museum of Korea’s popularity with the public also grew rapidly. Last year, it welcomed 6,507,483 visitors, an increase of about 72% from the previous year, ranking third in visitor numbers among the world’s major museums. More than 3.79 million people visited in the first half of this year alone, and cumulative attendance surpassed 6 million as of the 19th. During the parliamentary audit, Yoo forecast that annual attendance would exceed 7 million this year.


These achievements resulted from a combination of factors, including the global popularity of K-culture, the long-standing efforts of museum staff, and the growth of exhibition and cultural merchandise programs. Yoo also helped broaden public interest in the museum through active outreach and lectures.


However, some say that the strength of an art historian who has made cultural heritage easy for the public to understand proved to be a limitation when it came to verifying exhibitions at a national museum. The point is that an expert’s personal conviction about a work must be distinguished from the academic judgment officially issued by a national institution. A key challenge remains ensuring that curatorial staff can conduct independent reviews and voice dissenting views, even when they differ from the director’s judgment.



In his resignation statement today, Yoo said, “I hope this incident does not diminish the significance of the ‘Our Table’ special exhibition, which the museum’s research staff prepared with dedication over a long period.” He apologized again to staff and the public.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing