[Exclusive] Overseas Financial Accidents Recur at Same Subsidiaries... 94% of Losses Unrecovered
[The Unvarnished Face of K-Banks Beyond Borders] 1
32 Overseas Financial Accidents at Five Major Banks... Cumulative Losses Top KRW 128.6 Billion
Incidents Recurred at the Same Local Subsidiaries of Shinhan, Woori, KB, and Hana
Just 6
Financial accidents, including embezzlement and fraud, have repeatedly occurred at overseas subsidiaries of South Korea's five major commercial banks over the past five years. Not only have incidents recurred at the same subsidiaries, but the recovery rate for losses from closed cases was just 6%. As banks expand overseas, calls are growing for a comprehensive overhaul of internal controls at headquarters and the financial authorities' management and supervisory systems.
According to data on reported overseas financial accidents that the office of Kim Jae-seop, a People Power Party lawmaker, received from the Financial Supervisory Service, a total of 32 financial accidents occurred at overseas subsidiaries and other entities of the five major banks (KB Kookmin, Shinhan, Hana, Woori and NH NongHyup) from 2022 through August 2026. The figure includes incidents involving losses of KRW 1 billion or less. Cumulative losses over the period reached KRW 128.678 billion. Annual losses surged from KRW 696 million in 2022 to KRW 2.569 billion in 2023, before falling to KRW 146 million in 2024. They then soared to KRW 124.944 billion last year, the highest level during the period covered by the data. A further six incidents were reported through August this year, with losses totaling KRW 323 million.
Among the banks, Woori Bank had the highest cumulative losses. Since 2022, its cumulative losses have reached KRW 115.29 billion, accounting for about 90% of the total. In particular, losses amounted to KRW 112.833 billion last year alone, partly due to a major incident at its local subsidiary in Indonesia. A significant number of overseas financial accidents occurred in Southeast Asia. By country, Indonesia and Cambodia had the most incidents, with nine each. Vietnam, India and Myanmar followed with three each, while China had two. The United States, the Philippines and Canada each reported one incident.
The problem is that financial accidents have recurred at the same overseas subsidiaries. After an embezzlement incident at Shinhan Bank Indonesia in 2022, a fraud incident occurred there the following year, in 2023. The recovery rate for losses from both incidents was 0%. Another embezzlement incident occurred in 2024, marking three consecutive years of financial accidents at the same subsidiary. In other words, the bank failed to prevent another incident even though it had not recovered the losses from the earlier cases.
Shinhan Cambodia Bank also saw another fraud incident last year, involving KRW 3.784 billion, following embezzlement and fraud incidents in 2022. At Woori Saodara Bank, fraud involving KRW 107.6 billion and occupational breach of trust involving KRW 5.226 billion occurred one after the other last year, followed by a reported embezzlement incident involving KRW 80 million this year. KBI, Kookmin Bank's Indonesian subsidiary, had two embezzlement incidents this year following an occupational breach of trust incident last year. Fraud incidents were also reported at Hana Bank (China) Co., Ltd. in consecutive years, last year and this year.
Recurring overseas financial accidents are attributed to a combination of factors, including limits on financial authorities' supervisory powers under local regulations, relatively lax internal controls at bank headquarters, and inadequate oversight of local employees. Critics say that because management and supervision of overseas subsidiaries have not functioned effectively, systems to prevent repeat incidents have not been properly established even after accidents occur.
Banks say that differences in local legal systems and financial environments, as well as an increase in local hiring amid the rapid growth of overseas businesses, make it difficult to respond to incidents and recover losses. An official at a commercial bank said, "There are limits to predicting and preventing every possibility in advance when external business counterparties engage in deliberate fraud."
Of course, it is practically difficult for banks to prevent every instance of fraud in advance, including schemes carefully orchestrated by local employees and outsiders working together. But when incidents recur at the same subsidiary, it is necessary to check whether effective measures to prevent recurrence were taken after the previous incidents.
Assemblyman Kim said, "The recurrence of financial accidents at the same overseas branches raises questions about whether improvements to internal controls and measures to prevent recurrence were properly implemented after the incidents." He added, "Banks must thoroughly review the management of branches with repeated incidents and determine where responsibility lies, while financial authorities should verify whether corrective measures are working properly on the ground after an incident and establish effective measures to prevent recurrence."
Experts stress that banks should strengthen ongoing inspections at headquarters, while financial authorities should also exercise stricter supervision over the internal control systems at headquarters responsible for overseeing overseas branches.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Chae Sang-mi, a professor in the Department of Business Administration at Ewha Womans University, said, "Structurally, overseas business divisions at headquarters have focused on performance-based management centered on key performance indicators (KPIs), treating risk management and internal controls as secondary concerns or handling them leniently." She added, "The authorities should strictly inspect local management practices and governance at the global business divisions of bank headquarters."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.