[Exclusive] "You Said It Was Worth 3 Trillion Won"... ABLY, SC Securities Clash Over Advisory Fee for Alibaba Investment
Advisory fee lawsuit sparked by price gap between new and existing shares
SC Securities appeals after ABLY wins at first instance
ABLY Corporation, the fashion platform that announced it had secured an investment from China's Alibaba Group at a valuation of 3 trillion won, is reportedly in a dispute over fees with Standard Chartered Securities Korea, which advised it on the fundraising. Standard Chartered Securities Korea argued that the company's valuation should be based solely on the price of newly issued shares, while ABLY maintains that the valuation used to calculate the fee should also reflect the price of existing shares, putting it at about 740 billion won.
According to this newspaper's reporting on October 21, the Seoul Central District Court's Civil Division 20, presided over by Judge Kim Mincheol, recently ruled against Standard Chartered Securities Korea in a lawsuit it filed against ABLY seeking 4.95 billion won in contractual payments.
Fees vary with company valuation...Per-share prices differed fivefold
The two sides signed an investment advisory agreement in September 2023. Standard Chartered Securities Korea, a subsidiary of Standard Chartered Bank Korea, specializes in securities underwriting for bond issuance and mergers and acquisitions (M&A) advisory services. The advisory fee had two components: 1% of the newly raised funds, plus a separate fee determined by the company's post-investment valuation. The fee was set at 950 million won if the valuation was below 1 trillion won, and 5.45 billion won if it was 2 trillion won or more.
A Singaporean entity affiliated with Alibaba Group subsequently invested. It bought about 20 billion won worth of newly issued shares from ABLY, as well as about 68.5 billion won worth of existing shares held by current shareholders. Proceeds from the new shares went to the company, while proceeds from the existing shares went to the shareholders who sold them. The sellers of the existing shares included investment partnerships managed by NH Investment & Securities and Kolon Investment.
The dispute centered on the per-share price. Existing shares were priced at about 3.65 million won, while new shares were priced at about 18.26 million won, five times as much. Valuing all the shares at the price of the new shares puts the company's post-investment valuation at about 3.02 trillion won. By contrast, calculating the valuation based on the prices of both transactions brings it down to about 737.5 billion won.
Standard Chartered Securities Korea argued that "the advisory agreement covered a transaction involving the issuance of new shares to bring fresh capital into the company," and that "the fee should be calculated based on the price of the new shares." ABLY's representative countered that "the investment involved a combined purchase of new and existing shares" and that "the price of the existing shares should also be taken into account."
When Standard Chartered Securities Korea claimed about 6.215 billion won, including fees and value-added tax, ABLY paid only about 1.265 billion won. In the lawsuit Standard Chartered Securities Korea filed to seek payment of the difference, the issue at trial was not the fee equal to 1% of the newly raised funds, but the fee that varied according to the company's valuation.
First-instance court examines contract and negotiations: "Existing-share transaction must also be reflected"
The first-instance court ruled in ABLY's favor. Although the agreement set the basis for calculating the fee as the "post-investment company valuation," it did not specify the calculation method. The court therefore found that it should consider both the circumstances in which the agreement was made and the actual investment structure.
The court focused on the fact that Standard Chartered Securities Korea had proposed an investment structure combining the issuance of new shares with the sale of existing shares from the outset. The agreement also contained no provision stating that the valuation should be based only on the price of new shares or that the price of existing shares should be excluded.
The negotiations also treated the new and existing shares as a package. When ABLY asked Alibaba to raise the valuation based on the price of the new shares from 2 trillion won to 3 trillion won, the parties discussed offering a larger discount on the existing shares. Buying the new shares at a higher price while acquiring the existing shares at a lower price would allow Alibaba to maintain its average purchase price per share. The arrangement appears to have been intended to secure recognition of a higher company valuation publicly while keeping the investor's actual purchase cost unchanged.
The two transactions were also contractually linked. The terms stipulated that neither the purchase of new shares nor the purchase of existing shares could be completed on its own. The court found that, given the transactions were negotiated and carried out together, it would be difficult to calculate the advisory fee using only the higher price of the new shares.
The court ruled that "calculating the company-valuation advisory fee based on a blended valuation that appropriately reflects the full amounts of both the new-share issuance and the existing-share sale is consistent with the parties' true intent as expressed in the advisory agreement at issue." Accordingly, it found that ABLY was not required to pay any additional advisory fees beyond the amount it had already paid.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Standard Chartered Securities Korea has appealed, and the two sides will contest the matter again in the second instance.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.