Declares paintings authentic at parliamentary audit... "Scholars divided over whether they were made in Goryeo or the Yuan dynasty"
Three Ten Kings paintings bought from a U.S. collector in 2010 face authenticity questions
Professor Jeong Wootaek: "Forgeries made in Japan in the 1950s"... Museum pushes back
Cleveland Museum of Art classifies painting as a 14th-century Goryeo Buddhist work and features it in special exhibition

Yoo Hong-jun, director of the National Museum of Korea, said a Goryeo Buddhist painting in the museum’s collection, “Ten Kings of Hell” (十王圖), was “absolutely not a forgery,” declaring it authentic amid controversy over its authenticity. While acknowledging scholarly disagreement over when and where it was made, he drew a clear distinction, saying there was no question about the authenticity of the work itself. The National Museum of Korea has yet to determine the work’s country of origin or date of production, so debate over the basis for judging it authentic is expected to continue.

Yoo Hong-jun, director of the National Museum of Korea, answers questions from committee members during a parliamentary audit by the Culture, Sports and Tourism Committee at the National Assembly on the 19th. Yonhap News Agency.

Yoo Hong-jun, director of the National Museum of Korea, answers questions from committee members during a parliamentary audit by the Culture, Sports and Tourism Committee at the National Assembly on the 19th. Yonhap News Agency.

View original image

When asked to provide objective verification of the painting during a parliamentary audit by the National Assembly’s Culture, Sports and Tourism Committee on October 19, Yoo called it “authentic” and said it was “absolutely not a forgery.” He said, “The paintings are dispersed not only across the National Museum of Korea, but also the Fogg Museum at Harvard University, the Cleveland Museum of Art in the United States, and institutions in Japan,” adding that “scholars and museums believe they are authentic.”


Regarding the country of origin, he said, “I understand that foreign scholars disagree over whether the work dates to the Goryeo period or the Yuan dynasty.”


The works at the center of the controversy are three paintings from the Ten Kings series that the National Museum of Korea purchased from a U.S. collector in 2010. They depict the Fifth King, Yama; the Eighth King, Equality; and the Tenth King, the King Who Turns the Wheel of Rebirth, showing the kings of the underworld judging the sins of the dead and scenes of punishment in hell.


The series originally consisted of 10 panels. It was once owned by Japanese art collector Harry Packard. After Packard died in 1991, some of the works were put up for auction at Christie’s in 1992. New York art dealer Joseph Carroll, who specialized in Korean art, purchased four of them and sold three to the National Museum of Korea in 2010. The Cleveland Museum of Art in the United States acquired the remaining panel in 2019.


The forgery allegations were raised by Jeong Woo-taek, professor emeritus at Dongguk University and a researcher of Goryeo Buddhist paintings. In his recently published “Masterpieces of Korean Buddhist Painting 6,” Jeong argued that the works may be commercial forgeries made in Japan, citing their painting techniques, support material, pigments, and lettering.


Jeong questioned the composition of the kings and their attendants, the crude brushwork, the quality of the silk and pigments, and signs of damage and restoration that appeared artificial. He suggested that the works may have been copied from a Ten Kings painting in the collection of the Teijōkōmonko in Japan, and estimated that they were made in Japan in the 1950s.


Jeong said he concluded the works were not Goryeo Buddhist paintings after directly examining the Harvard collection in 2010, and that he had viewed and analyzed nine of the 10 panels in the series as of recently. He also pointed out problems with the series at an academic conference hosted by the Dongak Art History Society in 2019.


The National Museum of Korea, by contrast, says all six museums that own works from the series consider them authentic, and that the forgery allegation represents a minority view in academia. Lim Sua, curator of Korean art at the Cleveland Museum of Art, also countered that existing research supports identifying the work as a Goryeo Buddhist painting.


Assessments of the country and date of production differ among institutions, separately from the debate over authenticity. The National Museum of Korea’s publicly available collection information lists the nationality and period of the Fifth King, Yama, as “unknown.” The museum says the work is estimated to date to the late Goryeo period because its use of gold, patterns, and coloring resemble those of Goryeo Buddhist paintings.


The Cleveland Museum of Art's "The Ten Kings of Hell: The Afterlife in Medieval Korea" exhibition. U.S. Office of the Overseas Korean Cultural Heritage Foundation

The Cleveland Museum of Art's "The Ten Kings of Hell: The Afterlife in Medieval Korea" exhibition. U.S. Office of the Overseas Korean Cultural Heritage Foundation

View original image

The Cleveland Museum of Art, meanwhile, identifies its Fourth King, Oguan, as a Goryeo-period work from the late 14th century. Reports have also said that the Denver Art Museum in the United States classifies the country of origin of another painting in the same series as uncertain. This shows that the question of whether the works are authentic is distinct from the question of whether they were made in Goryeo or China.


Additional materials documenting the works’ ownership history have recently come to light. In exhibition materials released on October 6, the Cleveland Museum of Art said it had confirmed records by Japanese art historian Wakimoto Rakushiken, alongside the Third King, Songje, in the collection of the Gunma Prefectural Museum of Modern Art in Japan. The records say the Ten Kings series was kept at a Buddhist temple in Nagoya before being sold in the late 19th century because of the temple’s financial difficulties.


The National Museum of Korea and the Cleveland Museum of Art are holding a special exhibition, “Ten Kings of Hell: The Afterlife in Medieval Korea,” at the Cleveland Museum of Art in the United States from October 11 through January 3, 2027. For the first time since the 1960s, all 10 panels of the series, previously dispersed among six institutions in Korea, the United States, Japan, and elsewhere, have been brought together.


The exhibition also provides an opportunity to bring together research on the country and date of production of the Ten Kings paintings. The Cleveland Museum of Art plans to hold an international academic conference in November to discuss research on Ten Kings paintings from Goryeo, China, and Japan.



At the parliamentary audit on October 19, Yoo reaffirmed his position that the paintings are authentic. Scholars remain divided, with some arguing that the works’ materials and ownership history, as well as their style and iconography, should be examined together.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing