A warning has been issued that the artificial intelligence (AI) investment boom could follow the path of past railroad construction booms and the dot-com bubble. The concern is that even if massive infrastructure investment drives technological progress, investors may still earn returns that fall short of expectations.

Reuters-Yonhap News

Reuters-Yonhap News

View original image

The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) reported on Oct. 18, local time, in a column titled “The AI Stock Market Wobble Is a Reminder: This Time Isn't Different” that increased investment in AI infrastructure could undermine the sustainability of the enormous profits earned by related companies.


◆Railroads and the internet also left investors disappointed... The AI investment boom is no different=Columnist James Mackintosh said, “AI-related stocks have taken a major hit in recent days as high inflation has raised financing costs and debt-dependent data center investments face the risk of being scaled back.” However, he noted, “The greater risk, instead, is that data center construction continues without slowing down.” In other words, a scenario in which massive investment continues and leads to overinvestment may be more dangerous than a slowdown in AI investment.


He also said it was uncertain whether increased investment in AI infrastructure could avoid the problems seen during past waves of large-scale investment in railroad construction and the internet industry. From the British canal-building boom of the 1790s and the British railway bubble of the 1840s to the U.S. railroad investment boom of the 1880s and the dot-com bubble of the late 1990s, most large-scale investment projects generated social and economic benefits that met or exceeded expectations. However, it took longer than expected for the economic effects of technological innovation to materialize. Returns also fell short of expectations. As competition intensified, the benefits of new technologies often went to the consumers and other companies using them rather than to the companies that invested in them.


The WSJ also reported the views of AI investment skeptics, who said that a bubble may have formed in the earnings of AI-related companies themselves. This bubble may have aspects similar to those seen just before the 2007 global financial crisis. At the time, a bubble in bank stocks went largely unnoticed as the book value of banks was inflated above its actual level. The prices of AI-related stocks are also currently overvalued, and temporarily surging corporate earnings may be masking this, the skeptics said.


"Will the AI Investment Boom Follow the Railway and Dot-Com Bubble Path?" Foreign Media Issue Repeated Warnings View original image

◆U.S. data center construction projects repeatedly hit snags... “Sustainable returns are needed”=Stijn Van Nieuwerburgh, a professor at Columbia Business School, estimated in a recent report by the Brookings Institution that U.S. investment in AI would reach $9 trillion by 2032. Annual investment would amount to 3.2% of gross domestic product (GDP).


Meanwhile, some analysts say that repeated setbacks to data center construction projects in the United States are causing cracks in the AI infrastructure investment boom. The Financial Times (FT), citing data from regulatory intelligence firm RegData, reported that at least 47 large-scale data center projects had been delayed, withdrawn, or blocked so far this year. The FT said data center construction projects reliant on large amounts of borrowing were facing difficulties due to construction delays, local opposition, and worsening investor sentiment. It added that the data center investment boom, which has emerged as a key driver of U.S. economic growth, was being put to the test.



The WSJ noted that for investors to achieve returns, AI businesses need to generate sustainable profits that go beyond temporary gains related to capital expenditures. The key question, it said, is whether AI technology can boost productivity enough to create value that makes customers willing to pay the full cost of developing and using the technology.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing