Third-quarter earnings expected to soften... all five major companies forecast to miss consensus
"Earnings concerns already priced in... watch for major orders from year-end through 2027"

Expectations surrounding defense stocks have cooled. With third-quarter results this year expected to fall short of market expectations, target prices for major defense stocks, including Hanwha Aerospace and Hyundai Rotem, have been cut across the board. However, analysts say current share prices already reflect concerns about earnings, and investors should pay attention to the concentration of major order events from the end of this year through next year.


ChatGPT Image

ChatGPT Image

View original image

According to Eugene Investment & Securities, the third-quarter results this year of five major domestic defense companies are broadly expected to fall short of market expectations. Operating profits at Hanwha Aerospace, LIG Defense & Aerospace (LIG D&A), Hyundai Rotem, Korea Aerospace Industries (KAI), and Hanwha Systems are all forecast to come in below analysts' consensus estimates.


This is due to a decline in the won-dollar exchange rate compared with the end of the first half, which reduced export profitability, as well as delays in the recognition of revenue from some export shipments. Concentrated development spending in the second half is also weighing on results.


Accordingly, Eugene Investment & Securities lowered its target prices for all five companies. It cut Hanwha Aerospace's target price from 1.86 million won to 1.66 million won, LIG D&A's from 1.2 million won to 1 million won, Hyundai Rotem's from 316,000 won to 220,000 won, KAI's from 159,000 won to 146,000 won, and Hanwha Systems' from 140,000 won to 100,000 won. Yang Seung-yoon, a researcher at Eugene Investment & Securities, explained, "We have reflected changes in earnings and applied valuation multiples for the defense stocks we cover."


By company, Hanwha Aerospace's third-quarter revenue is estimated at 7.0299 trillion won, with operating profit of 974.3 billion won. These figures represent increases of 8% and 16%, respectively, from the same period last year, but operating profit is expected to fall significantly short of the market estimate of 1.2132 trillion won. This is largely because some revenue recognition has been delayed, as deliveries of the second batch of K-9 self-propelled howitzers to Poland are concentrated next year.


LIG D&A is forecast to post revenue of 1.2223 trillion won and operating profit of 87.5 billion won. Revenue is expected to rise 16%, while operating profit is projected to decline 2%, falling short of the market estimate of 107.2 billion won. Annual research and development expenses are expected to reach 250 billion to 350 billion won, while cumulative spending in the first half was only in the 60-billion-won range, suggesting that the cost burden has increased in the second half. Key factors include the preliminary development of weapon systems and export-related development expenses.


Hyundai Rotem is estimated to post revenue of 1.8849 trillion won and operating profit of 268.6 billion won for the same period. Revenue is expected to rise 16%, while operating profit is projected to fall 3%. Although the figure is slightly below the market estimate of 276.4 billion won, it is broadly in line with expectations.


KAI is estimated to post revenue of 1.1953 trillion won and operating profit of 77 billion won. These represent increases of 70% and 28%, respectively, from the same period a year earlier, but operating profit is expected to fall short of the market estimate of 81.7 billion won. Hanwha Systems is estimated to post revenue of 1.0604 trillion won, up 31%, and operating profit of 51.3 billion won, up 128%. Its operating profit is also expected to fall short of the market estimate of 60.6 billion won. In addition to the development cost burden in the second half, the depletion of Poland-bound component orders is expected to affect results.


Despite lowering target prices to reflect weak results, analysts maintained their "Buy" ratings on all five companies. What they are focusing on is not third-quarter results, but the next order cycle. As domestic defense companies' earnings have entered a period of stagnation following large-scale orders in 2022, analysts say new contracts will be the variable that determines the direction of share prices going forward. Researcher Yang emphasized, "The recent decline in defense stocks has already priced in concerns about third-quarter results," adding, "Ultimately, new orders will determine the direction of share prices. Major order events are concentrated from the end of this year through next year."


The most closely watched development is defense cooperation with the United Arab Emirates (UAE). Eugene Investment & Securities highlighted the possibility that contracts related to defense cooperation worth about $35 billion could take concrete shape during the UAE president's state visit to Korea. However, it said that, given the market's already high expectations, it will be important to confirm the actual contract terms and value. The report listed K-9 self-propelled howitzers, Chunmoo, medium- and long-range surface-to-air guided weapons, counter-drone and short-range air defense systems, KF-21 fighter jets, and frigates as potential UAE projects. These are estimates based on assumptions about procurement volumes and project costs, and should be considered separately from the value of confirmed contracts.


In Europe, Poland's third contract for K2 tanks is a key variable. Eugene Investment & Securities highlighted the possibility that Hyundai Rotem could secure a third order from Poland in the first half of next year. Discussions on industrial cooperation with Romania are also ongoing, while a year-end summit-level meeting could help advance Peru's procurement of land-based weapon systems. LIG D&A is expected to see exports to Saudi Arabia next year and to Iraq in 2028 contribute to its results. Hanwha Aerospace is also seen as having a pipeline of major orders for air defense and ground weapons in the Middle East.



Researcher Yang said, "We believe this is the time to look beyond the weak third-quarter results as short-term noise and focus on next year, when orders are expected to be concentrated," adding, "The recent share-price decline has also significantly eased valuation concerns."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing