Lawsuit filed five years and one month after covering the costs
“No deadline or basis... Payment notice not recognized”

A first-instance court has ruled that Choi Seo-won, formerly known as Choi Soon-sil, who is serving a prison sentence after being identified as the “shadow power” behind the state affairs scandal during the Park Geun-hye administration, does not have to pay hospital bills that a detention center covered on her behalf.

Choi Soon-sil. The Asia Business Daily DB

Choi Soon-sil. The Asia Business Daily DB

View original image

On October 15, Kim Doyo, presiding judge of the Seoul Central District Court’s 210th Civil Division, dismissed the government’s claim in a lawsuit seeking reimbursement from Choi.


The case turned on two issues: whether Choi was obligated to pay for outside medical treatment herself, and whether the statute of limitations on the claim had expired. Under the National Finance Act, the statute of limitations for the state’s monetary claims is five years.


Choi had slipped in the bathhouse at the detention center and undergone shoulder surgery sometime between May and July 2020. On October 23 that year, after Choi failed to pay the hospital bills, citing financial difficulties and other reasons, the detention center paid approximately 39.27 million won for treatment at an outside medical facility on her behalf.


On October 28 of the same year, the Seoul Eastern Detention Center notified Choi that she had to pay the medical expenses, but no significant follow-up action was taken for nearly five years.


In November 2025, correctional authorities learned that the authorities had paid Choi’s medical expenses on her behalf and directed the detention center to file a reimbursement lawsuit. The detention center filed suit on November 25, about five years and one month after it had covered the surgery costs.


The court said, “The detention center warden authorized outside medical treatment on the condition that [Choi] pay her own expenses,” and found that Choi was obligated to pay the medical expenses and damages for delay. However, it rejected the plaintiff’s argument that the statute of limitations on the claim had not expired.


The court found that, under the National Finance Act, a payment notice must be accompanied by a payment order stating the deadline, place, and basis for calculating the amount. It concluded that the evidence submitted by the plaintiff was insufficient to show that a payment notice meeting these requirements had been issued.


The court also ruled that the plaintiff’s notice demanding payment could not be treated as a payment notice. “The title did not include the words ‘payment notice’ at all,” the court said, adding that it was “difficult to regard it as a notice prepared by an authorized official.”



The court also expressed concern that broadly recognizing payment notices could result in private claims held by the state receiving unfair preferential treatment. The government, which lost at trial, plans to review whether to appeal after consulting with relevant ministries and agencies.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing