"Memory Price Growth Slowing"... Third-Quarter Earnings Peak
"Semiconductor Exports Rose, but... Shipment Volume Fell"
"China's Catch-Up and AI Investment Payback"... Equipment Stocks in Focus

Experts have argued that it is difficult to be optimistic about the semiconductor industry despite improving earnings at Samsung Electronics and SK hynix. Memory price increases have driven earnings growth, but analysts say the current boom may be temporary, fueled by supply shortages resulting from production cuts. The expert put the fair share price at 70,000 won for Samsung Electronics and 200,000 won for SK hynix, and said investors should watch for the possibility that memory prices will start to fall.


On the 15th, as the KOSPI and KOSDAQ indexes plunged more than 8%, triggering consecutive circuit breakers, the KOSPI and KOSDAQ indexes and the won-dollar exchange rate are displayed on an electronic board in the dealing room at Hana Bank's headquarters in Jung-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

On the 15th, as the KOSPI and KOSDAQ indexes plunged more than 8%, triggering consecutive circuit breakers, the KOSPI and KOSDAQ indexes and the won-dollar exchange rate are displayed on an electronic board in the dealing room at Hana Bank's headquarters in Jung-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

View original image


"Samsung Electronics at 70,000 won, SK hynix at 200,000 won"... Warning of a Peak in the Memory Market

A recent short-form video from the economic program "Money Show," released by SBS Biz under the title "Fair Share Prices for the Two Semiconductor Leaders? 'Samsung Electronics at 70,000 won, SK hynix at 200,000 won,'" featured Industry Analyst Lee Juwan's analysis of the share prices of Samsung Electronics and SK hynix and the memory market.


The analyst, who appeared on the program, argued that it is uncertain whether the two companies' improving earnings will lead to sustainable growth. He explained that higher profits resulting from rising memory prices do not necessarily indicate a structural improvement in the industry, and that earnings could weaken if prices fall in the future.


He put the fair share prices of Samsung Electronics and SK hynix at 70,000 won and 200,000 won, respectively. His analysis was that the two companies had cut production, creating a supply shortage, and that the resulting rise in memory prices had been reflected in their earnings and share prices. However, he said this trend would be difficult to sustain. The prices were the guest's personal estimates on the program and do not represent current share prices or official price targets set by securities firms.


"The Third Quarter May Have Been the Peak"... Micron's Results in Focus

The analyst looked for signs that the memory market may have peaked in the earnings report and future profitability outlook of U.S. memory chipmaker Micron. Based on Micron's projected profit margins, he said the industry may have passed its peak and entered a downturn. He also argued that Samsung Electronics and SK hynix may have reached their earnings peaks in the third quarter of this year.


He forecast that memory prices are likely to start falling in the fourth quarter. In his view, the pace of memory price increases is slowing even as domestic companies cut production.


Related file photo. The Asia Business Daily DB.

Related file photo. The Asia Business Daily DB.

View original image

The program also noted that Samsung Electronics had not yet released provisional results by business segment at the time. The analyst explained that total revenue and operating profit alone do not make it possible to determine whether improved profitability came from the semiconductor business or was influenced by other segments, such as mobile.


"Look at the Price Effect, Not Just Export Value"... Capacity Utilization Also a Key Indicator

The program also noted that South Korea's semiconductor exports exceeded $60 billion this past September. However, the analyst argued that growth in export value alone should not be used to assess whether the semiconductor industry is actually growing. When memory prices rise, export value can increase even if the volume of exports does not.


He said that, according to his own analytical model, if memory prices were assumed to be the same as a year earlier, export-related indicators for DRAM and NAND flash had fallen by 40% and 60%, respectively, on a cumulative basis through August this year.


Capacity utilization in semiconductor manufacturing was also cited as a key indicator. The analyst said that an analysis of relevant data from this past August showed utilization at about 78% to 81%, depending on the calculation method. He cited this as evidence that domestic semiconductor companies were cutting production. However, the program did not provide the specific formula or scope used to calculate the figures.


Supply Adjustments Cited as a Key Variable in the Memory Market

The analyst argued that, when assessing turning points in the memory market, changes in supply should be watched more closely than demand forecasts. He explained that memory demand has grown over the long term, but companies' investment levels and the timing at which existing facilities begin to deliver actual output determine whether supply is tight or excessive, which in turn affects prices and profitability.


He interpreted production cuts by Samsung Electronics and SK hynix as measures to prevent prices from falling amid weak demand. By contrast, he said Micron had already ended the production cuts it had implemented to adjust inventory in the past. In his analysis, these differences in production adjustments also affected each company's market share and profitability.


He suggested that Big Tech companies may have entered into long-term supply contracts to secure the volumes they need before memory prices rise further.


AI Investment Returns and China's Catch-Up Also Pose Risks

Some have also argued that the growth potential of the AI industry should be considered separately from the memory market. The analyst said that although AI technology and services are spreading, it remains uncertain whether final demand, with users actually paying for these services, has developed enough to support the scale of investment.


He described the data center investment cycle as consisting of about three years of investment spending followed by about three years of investment recovery. Based on this analysis, he forecast that the ability to recoup investments could come under serious scrutiny starting next year. He argued that if AI companies fail to generate sufficient profits, expectations for growth in related industries could also be revised downward.


However, he stressed that concerns about AI investment should be considered separately from the memory market. In his analysis, even if AI-related demand increases, changes in memory prices and company earnings are more heavily influenced by shifts in supply.


CXMT file photo. Reuters-Yonhap News

CXMT file photo. Reuters-Yonhap News

View original image

The growing competition from Chinese semiconductor companies was also cited as a key variable. The analyst claimed that Chinese companies' market share had exceeded 10% and said China's semiconductor industry had already entered a stage of competition with South Korean companies.


He particularly emphasized that China is a major market for South Korean semiconductor companies. His analysis was that Chinese companies could put pressure on South Korean companies' revenue and competitiveness simply by expanding their market share in China.


He explained that semiconductor equipment companies' earnings tend to lag those of manufacturers by about one year. Based on his analysis of earnings trends over roughly the past 10 years, he said he had found that semiconductor manufacturers' and equipment companies' earnings cycles followed similar patterns, with equipment companies tending to move about one year later.



He explained that semiconductor materials companies are closely tied to production volumes, while equipment companies are linked to manufacturers' capital expenditure. Accordingly, he forecast that if semiconductor manufacturers' earnings peak this year, equipment companies' earnings could improve further next year.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing