Debate Over 'Pro-Yoon' and 'Politically Aligned Appointment' Instead of Vetting SCIA Chief's Qualifications
Politicians Demanding Neutrality Must Apply the Same Standard to Their Own Side

[Reporter's Notebook] While Demanding Neutrality, the Hearing Asks, "Whose Side Are You On?" View original image

"This is not a politically aligned appointment by President Lee Jae-myung, is that right?" "Yes, that's right."


That was an exchange at the October 14 confirmation hearing for Kim Jiyong, the nominee to become the first chief of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency (SCIA). Questions that had initially focused on whether he was pro-Yoon went on to ask whether he was a politically aligned appointment by the current administration. At a hearing meant to determine whether he was qualified to lead a new investigative agency, the nominee instead had to repeatedly explain his own political position.


Lawmakers from the ruling party brought up his opposition to disciplinary action against former President Yoon Suk Yeol and cases including the alleged abuse of authority by Jeong Jinung and the illegal travel ban imposed on Kim Hakui. Of course, it is necessary to scrutinize the appropriateness of the past investigations and prosecutions in which the nominee was involved. It is important to examine whether his decisions at the time had a legal basis and whether he upheld principles despite external pressure. It is also worth checking whether his explanation that he opposed the prosecution is consistent with what he actually did. That is what confirmation hearings are for.


But scrutinizing the handling of cases is different from sorting people into political allies and opponents. The fact that he opposed disciplinary action against former President Yoon does not, by itself, prove that future investigations will be biased. Nor does the fact that the current administration nominated him justify doubting his political independence. What needs to be examined is the basis for his decisions at the time and how he handled the cases. If a political label is applied first and cases are forced into that framework, the same decision can be judged differently depending on whom it benefited. That is precisely the kind of standard that politicians and society have long demanded investigative agencies abandon.


In that respect, asking the nominee to cite cases he handled while resisting pressure from those in power was a necessary question. It asked him to point to actions that would demonstrate his political independence. But what can be established by requiring him to answer "yes" or "no" to whether he is pro-Yoon or a politically aligned appointment? Saying he is neither does not prove his neutrality.


The SCIA was launched on October 2 with the stated aim of ending the politicization of prosecutors' investigations. The reasons for separating investigations from prosecutions and distributing authority were likewise to eliminate the problem of investigative standards changing with each administration. The standards for vetting the head of the new agency should have reflected that purpose. If the fairness of investigations is judged by political ties, there will be less room for the nominee's commitment to law and principle to stand.



Nominee Kim's promise to uphold political neutrality will be tested by how he handles cases in the future. The public will have to see whether he investigates wherever the evidence leads, whether under the current or a past administration, and whether he is willing to stop when there is no evidence of a crime, even if that means facing criticism from politicians. Politicians, too, must uphold the same standard. Neutrality means being able to accept an investigation even when it targets one's own side.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing