[Exclusive] Land Ministry pushes ahead with candidate sites in price-ceiling areas despite Seoul's objections
Three sites selected despite Seoul's request for careful review
Exemption from price ceiling raises concerns over high sale prices and fairness
No separate price cap criteria... Ministry says, "Consultations planned"
The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport included areas subject to the price ceiling system, including Seocho and Songpa, among the new candidate sites for Seoul’s Urban Public Housing Complex Project, despite objections from the Seoul Metropolitan Government. The project is a follow-up measure to the government’s plan to accelerate housing supply. Eleven sites in Seoul were recently selected as candidates, with 18,000 homes planned. However, because the project is not subject to the price ceiling system, some areas could see high sale prices, potentially raising concerns about fairness with private-sector redevelopment projects. Critics say the government may have gone too far by including even the Gangnam area, which is subject to the price ceiling system, as it makes housing supply a top priority.
According to the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport and the Seoul Metropolitan Government on October 15, the city sent the ministry an official letter last month, before it announced the new candidate sites for the Urban Public Housing Complex Project, stating that “areas subject to the price ceiling system that are inconsistent with the purpose of the project require careful consideration when selecting candidate sites.” Although the minister of Land, Infrastructure and Transport has the authority to select candidate sites and designate project districts, the Seoul Metropolitan Government has the authority to approve project plans. The ministry therefore sought the local government’s views before selecting the sites.
However, the ministry subsequently selected three project sites in areas subject to the price ceiling system: north of Hyochang Park Station in Yongsan-gu, east of Isu Station in Seocho-gu, and near Olympic Park in Songpa-gu. A ministry official said, “The sites were selected after taking into account the public-sale nature of the project, site conditions and project feasibility,” adding, “Being exempt from the price ceiling system does not mean that excessively high sale prices will be charged.”
The Urban Public Housing Complex Project is a government-led development initiative targeting areas such as station districts, semi-industrial areas and aging low-rise residential neighborhoods, where private-sector redevelopment is difficult. The government previously invited proposals for sites in Seoul, receiving proposals from residents for 44 locations, and selected 11 as candidate sites following expert review. In four districts, including the three Gangnam districts and Yongsan-gu, sale prices are capped at the combined value of appraised land and construction costs set by the government. However, housing supplied through the Urban Public Housing Complex Project is exempt from the price ceiling system. The government abolished its application to the project in 2023 to promote its viability.
Political circles and industry observers say Seocho and Songpa may have been included despite being subject to the price ceiling system because of the symbolic value of “housing supply in the Gangnam area.” They say it may have been difficult to exclude these sites solely because they are in areas subject to the price ceiling system, given that residents in the Gangnam area submitted applications just like residents in other candidate areas.
However, concerns have emerged that excluding these sites from the price ceiling system could lead to controversy over high sale prices in the future. The Korea Land and Housing Corporation (LH) sets the prices for homes offered for general sale based on appraisals that take into account prices of nearby apartments and other factors. As a result, prices could be high in areas with expensive homes, such as the Gangnam area and Yongsan-gu.
Concerns have also been raised about fairness with private-sector redevelopment projects. In recent months, price inversions have emerged in the market, with sale prices in Gangnam-area complexes lower than those outside Gangnam because they are subject to the price ceiling system. The top sale price for a 59-square-meter unit at Hautier Banpo in Seocho-gu, which was offered in April, was 2.0461 billion won. That was about 160 million won below the top sale price of 2.2088 billion won for a unit of the same size at La Clarté Xi The Pine in Dongjak-gu, which was offered that same month. Acro de Seocho in Seocho-gu, offered in March, also had a sale price of 1.8649 billion won for a unit of the same size, 343.9 million won less.
If homes supplied through the Urban Public Housing Complex Project are priced in line with nearby newly built apartments, private redevelopment association members could object. Kim Je-gyeong, head of Tumi Real Estate Consulting, said, “In the Geoyeo and Macheon areas of Songpa-gu, estimated contributions by association members in private redevelopment projects currently reach 1 billion won.” He added, “If only the Urban Public Housing Complex Project is exempted from the price ceiling system and its homes for general sale are priced high, association members in private redevelopment areas could push back.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
No specific sale-price ceiling criteria have yet been established for Urban Public Housing Complex Project sites in areas subject to the price ceiling system. An LH official said, “A separate sale-price ceiling has not been established,” adding, “Further discussions with the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport are needed on whether to set a ceiling and whether to establish detailed criteria.”
The ministry said LH and the Seoul Housing and Communities Corporation (SH), the project operators, will discuss appropriate sale prices based on project conditions and feasibility. LH and SH are each expected to carry out projects at the 11 new candidate sites. The Seoul Metropolitan Government has requested that 50% of the project volume be allocated to SH.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.