Just 81.7 billion won of the 579 billion won in repayment funds to come from operating cash

Claims it will “repay through a rights offering” despite grounds for delisting

ARS consultation period extended for the sixth time

JR Global REITs has put forward a revised proposal that brings forward the timing of debt repayment. However, with a shareholders' coalition filing an objection with the court and bondholders divided over the proposal, negotiations under the Autonomous Restructuring Support (ARS) program are expected to face difficulties.


According to investment banking (IB) industry sources on October 15, the Seoul Bankruptcy Court extended the period for ARS negotiations involving JR Global REITs by one month, until November 13. The court has deferred its decision on whether to commence proceedings to allow the debtor and creditors to negotiate voluntarily. This is the sixth extension since the company filed for rehabilitation in April.


Of the KRW 579 billion in repayment funds set out in the revised proposal announced by JR Global REITs on October 12, only KRW 81.7 billion, or 14%, is expected to come from rental income. The company plans to raise the rest through refinancing, asset sales and a paid-in capital increase, but investors have voiced concerns because none of these plans has been finalized.

Belgium Finance Tower. JR Global REITs website.

Belgium Finance Tower. JR Global REITs website.

View original image

However, creditors hold the key to finalizing the repayment plan. Changes to the terms of publicly offered bonds require approval at a bondholders' meeting and court authorization, while shareholders may submit their views but have no voting rights.


Before filing for rehabilitation, the company withdrew a KRW 120 billion paid-in capital increase. Last month, it lost a lawsuit in the UK and then received a disclaimer of opinion from its auditor. Despite the repeated collapse of assumptions it had relied on to persuade investors, the company has once again built its revised proposal on highly uncertain assumptions.

Shareholders' Coalition: "A Structure That Borrows to Repay Debt"

Shortly after the revised proposal was made public, a delegation representing 154 shareholders submitted an opinion to the Seoul Bankruptcy Court, stating, "New borrowing of KRW 192.5 billion and shareholder funds of KRW 168.7 billion together account for 62.4% of the repayment funds." It criticized the proposal as "a structure that borrows to repay debt."


The KRW 70 billion in 0% interest, shareholder-allotted convertible bonds and the KRW 98.7 billion the company plans to raise through a paid-in capital increase or private placement bonds together amount to 72% of the market capitalization immediately before trading was suspended, which was approximately KRW 233.3 billion. Another concern is that the company has already become subject to delisting due to the disclaimer of opinion. The company itself stated in its Q&A on the revised proposal that "if the shares are delisted, a paid-in capital increase and the issuance of shareholder-allotted convertible bonds would be virtually impossible." This means that measures that may not be available account for around 30% of the repayment funds.


A JR Global REITs representative responded, "Rather than assuming delisting at this point, we need to do everything possible to maintain our listing. We are working to resolve the grounds for delisting by filing an appeal, submitting an improvement plan and undergoing an audit for the next fiscal year."

[Every REIT for Itself: JR REIT] Bondholders Say "Safeguards First," Shareholders Warn of "REIT's Demise"... Controversy Over Revised Plan View original image

The shareholders' coalition also took issue with a potential conflict of interest involving the asset manager. The company stated in its Q&A that "(if rehabilitation proceedings commence) the receiver may terminate the management agreement with the asset management company and appoint a third party." This means that, from the perspective of JR Investment & Management, the commencement of proceedings could lead directly to the loss of its management contract. A company representative said, "An asset sale is a last resort," but did not say whether the company was willing to forgo the sale fee.

Company: "Assumes Finance Tower Is Worth 1.1 Billion Euros"

Debate is also continuing over the collateral assumptions. The company put forward loan-to-value (LTV) ratios of 57.3% and 63.6% following refinancing, which suggests that it assumed a valuation of approximately 1.1 billion euros. Applying the 920 million euro valuation by the local lender consortium, which the UK High Court deemed valid, would put the LTV at 76.1% at the end of 2029, above the 65% default threshold for the current loan. The company is pursuing refinancing on the assumption that rents will be cut by 20% starting next year and that leases will be extended through 2046. In other words, the calculation assumes that the valuation will rise even as rents are reduced.


A company representative explained, "The proposal is based on a value of around 1.1 billion euros, which had previously been applied to Finance Tower. JLL once undervalued it at 920 million euros, but the UK court also pointed out that the valuation was inadequate." However, on September 8, the UK's High Court Commercial Court dismissed the lawsuit filed by the company, recognizing JLL's valuation as valid and leaving the cash trap in place.


The company assumed a 0% annual interest rate for the private placement bonds. The revised proposal also states that "the debt ratio may temporarily rise due to borrowing and bond issuance," and that the debt-ratio covenant will not apply until the debt has been fully repaid.

[Every REIT for Itself: JR REIT] Bondholders Say "Safeguards First," Shareholders Warn of "REIT's Demise"... Controversy Over Revised Plan View original image

Bondholders: "Safeguards Must Come First"

Publicly offered bondholders have also raised a series of concerns about the revised proposal. Their common demand is for safeguards. They say it would be difficult to agree without protections in case the principal is not fully repaid by the end of 2029. An administrator of a bondholders' online forum wrote that "the current repayment plan is neither fast nor safe enough" and suggested comparing the options of bringing forward the sale of Belgium Finance Tower or proceeding with rehabilitation.


Several steps remain before the repayment plan can be finalized. A separate bondholders' meeting must be held for each tranche of publicly offered bonds. Under the Commercial Act, a proposal passes only if it receives at least two-thirds of the voting rights held by bondholders present and at least one-third of the total voting rights. Institutional creditors are not covered by the meetings, so their consent must be obtained through individual negotiations. The company said it was preparing for a board resolution and expected the meetings to take place in November. If the proposal is not approved and authorized by the court in time, the ARS negotiation period could be extended again.



In its opinion, the shareholders' coalition stressed, "We are not opposed to creditors making legitimate recoveries." It added, "Driving the REIT itself toward extinction in order to speed up creditors' recovery is not the kind of rehabilitation envisioned by the Debtor Rehabilitation and Bankruptcy Act."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing