KEF Survey of 62 Companies’ Views
Occupational Safety and Health Act Compliance Cited as Grounds for Employer Status
Concern Over Excessive Bargaining Demands by Subcontractor Unions
Exclude Management Decisions from Scope of Labor Disputes

Fewer than three in 10 companies believe that Labor Relations Commission rulings on principal contractor-subcontractor cases since the amended Trade Union Act, also known as the Yellow Envelope Act, took effect are consistent with the law and government guidelines.


Survey of Corporate Perceptions on Labor Commission Rulings and Negotiations Between Prime Contractors and Subcontractors. Korea Enterprises Federation

Survey of Corporate Perceptions on Labor Commission Rulings and Negotiations Between Prime Contractors and Subcontractors. Korea Enterprises Federation

View original image

The Korea Enterprises Federation (KEF) announced on the 14th the results of a survey conducted by Southern Post titled “Survey on Companies’ Perceptions of Labor Relations Commission Rulings and Negotiations Between Principal Contractors and Subcontractors.” The survey covered 62 companies that had received Labor Relations Commission rulings on principal contractor-subcontractor cases since the Yellow Envelope Act took effect.


According to the survey, only 27.4% of companies said the Labor Relations Commission’s decisions on whether principal contractors qualify as employers were being made in accordance with the law and the Ministry of Employment and Labor’s interpretive guidelines (24.2% said “mostly so” and 3.2% “very much so”). By contrast, 40.3% said the decisions were not being made in accordance with the law and guidelines.


Among companies that said the rulings were inconsistent with the law and guidelines, the most frequently cited reason (multiple responses allowed) was that “compliance with obligations under public laws, such as the Occupational Safety and Health Act, is being used as grounds for recognizing employer status” (52.0%). This reflects frustration with the paradoxical situation in which fulfilling legal safety obligations is instead used to expand principal contractors’ employer responsibilities. In addition, 48.0% pointed to “recognition of employer status on matters unrelated to working conditions.”


Companies also expressed serious concern about potential problems arising in actual bargaining and mediation with subcontractor unions. The most frequently cited concern about bargaining with subcontractor unions (multiple responses allowed) was “excessive union demands that include issues for which employer status has not been recognized” (66.1%). Another 43.5% cited “demands for bargaining with principal contractors over matters, such as wages and union activities, that should be negotiated with subcontractors.”


Regarding the Labor Relations Commission’s mediation procedures for principal contractor-subcontractor disputes, 59.7% of respondents (multiple responses allowed) identified “proceeding with mediation after adding issues for which employer status has not been recognized” as their greatest concern. Many also cited the burden of “initiating mediation procedures while a dispute over the principal contractor’s employer status is still ongoing” (48.4%).


As the top priority for supplementary legislation to reduce future labor market disruptions (multiple responses allowed), 67.7% cited “clarifying the criteria for determining whether principal contractors qualify as employers.” This was followed by “excluding high-level corporate management decisions from the scope of labor disputes,” cited by 54.8%.



Lee Dong-geun, full-time vice chairman of the KEF, said, “Uncertainty surrounding Labor Relations Commission rulings has continued since the amended Trade Union Act took effect.” He stressed, “To reduce such disruption at industrial sites and ensure predictability, the government must enact supplementary legislation and ensure that principal contractors’ employer status is determined fairly and rigorously in accordance with statutory provisions and administrative guidelines.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing