Constitutional Court Secretary General Weighs In on Supreme Court Appointment Dispute
"A Duty of Respect and Cooperation Among Institutions Must Be in Place"

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Son Inhyeok, secretary general of the Constitutional Court, said on October 13, "When the president sends a motion seeking the National Assembly's consent to appoint a Supreme Court justice, it is naturally asking for consent on the premise that the appointment will be made."


At a parliamentary audit of the Constitutional Court held at the National Assembly in Yeouido, Seoul, on the morning of October 13, Assemblyman Kim Dong-a of the Democratic Party of Korea asked, "The moment the president sends a motion for consent to the National Assembly, isn't that a request made on the premise that consent will be given?" Son replied, "It is natural to interpret it that way." He added, "Asking whether the National Assembly consents is itself an exercise of its right to consent to the appointment, so it can naturally be understood as asking for consent on the premise that the appointment will be made."


However, when asked whether a request from the president for a renewed recommendation would obligate the chief justice of the Supreme Court to make one, Son was guarded in his response, saying, "This is the most important and central issue, so it is difficult for me to comment here."


Son said, "For each institution to properly exercise its authority to recommend and appoint, there must first be respect for and a duty to cooperate with the other institutions." He added, "If the chief justice of the Supreme Court's power to recommend, the National Assembly's right to consent, and the president's power to appoint are exercised with mutual respect and cooperation, the constitutional impasse can certainly be resolved."


When Assemblyman Park Kyuntaek of the same party said that Chief Justice Cho's refusal to make a renewed recommendation denied the provisions of the Constitution, Son replied, "This is a matter of how Article 104, Paragraph 2 of the Constitution should be interpreted." He added, "As a jurisdictional dispute case has been filed, I do not think it would be appropriate to express my personal opinion or the opinion of a public institution here."


In September, the People Power Party filed a jurisdictional dispute case with the Constitutional Court, arguing that "President Lee Jae-myung's decision not to submit a motion seeking consent to appoint Son Bong-gi, a presiding judge at the Daegu District Court, and instead request a renewed recommendation infringed on the National Assembly's powers, including its authority to deliberate and vote on motions seeking consent to appoint Supreme Court justices and its right to consent to their appointments." In response to a question from Assemblyman Kim Hangyu of the Democratic Party of Korea about the status of the case, Son said, "The case has been received, and we are discussing how to proceed."



Assemblywoman Park Eun-jung of the Rebuilding Korea Party asked about the Supreme Court's concern that introducing a system allowing constitutional complaints against court rulings would lead to "litigation hell," saying, "That concern has effectively proved unfounded." Son replied, "I think some of those risks could emerge if the system is operated improperly." He added, "Taking such considerations into account, we are operating the system for constitutional complaints against court rulings very cautiously."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing