Immigration inspection pushed through without a warrant; evidence ruled inadmissible

The Supreme Court has ruled that government officials cannot question foreign nationals at a massage parlor suspected of employing people who are staying in the country illegally if the manager refuses to let them in.

The Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

The Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to legal circles on Oct. 13, the Supreme Court's Second Division, with Justice Eom Sang-pil presiding, recently upheld an appellate ruling acquitting the owner of a massage parlor, identified as A, who had been indicted on charges of violating the Immigration Control Act. The acquittal was based on evidence obtained unlawfully.


A was indicted the following year on charges of employing three Thai nationals who lacked visas permitting them to work at a massage parlor in Mokpo, South Jeolla Province, from July to August 2023.


In August 2023, the Gwangju Immigration Office received tips about illegal stays, unauthorized employment and prostitution, and sent nine staff members to conduct an inspection at the establishment.


A protested, saying, "Are you just going to come in and search the place like this without asking for our consent or permission?" The staff members, however, knocked on the doors and checked the foreign nationals' immigration and work status.


The Gwangju Immigration Office later summoned A and the foreign employees for questioning one by one, then filed a complaint against A with investigative authorities based on the findings.

Supreme Court: "Crackdowns on Undocumented Foreigners Without a Manager's Consent Are Illegal" View original image

The lower court found A guilty and sentenced A to four months in prison, suspended for two years. It ruled that the inspection was lawful, noting that the massage parlor's lobby was open to the public and that the officials had knocked on the doors and asked only the foreign nationals to come out, without entering the rooms themselves.


The appellate court, however, accepted A's argument that immigration officials had conducted an unlawful investigation and acquitted A. It said, "For immigration officials to enter a third party's residence or business premises where the general public is not permitted free access and question foreign nationals under Article 81, Paragraph 1 of the Immigration Control Act, they must first obtain consent from the person with the right to occupy the premises or the manager."


The court ruled that having the foreign nationals come out despite A's clear refusal was effectively a search and constituted unlawful official conduct carried out without a warrant.



The Supreme Court upheld the appellate court's decision. The panel rejected the prosecution's appeal, saying, "The lower court made no error affecting the judgment by misconstruing the law concerning investigative procedures under the Immigration Control Act, illegally obtained evidence or the admissibility of evidence."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing