"An Enforcement Decree is a norm used to enforce a law... it cannot replace the law"

"The first and second courts treated the change to the Enforcement Decree alone as reflecting the legislature's intent. But when a law and its Enforcement Decree conflict, the legislature is the National Assembly, which makes laws, not the executive branch, which issues Enforcement Decrees."


Kim Seonghwan, a partner attorney on the tax team at Lee & Ko, explained this as the key argument that led the Supreme Court to overturn the outcome in the “loyalty points value-added tax” case, which the plaintiffs had lost in both the first and second courts. In an interview with The Asia Business Daily on October 14, he said the Supreme Court's full bench had recently ruled unanimously that levying value-added tax under an Enforcement Decree provision for a taxable period before a statutory basis for delegation had been established violated the principle of taxation by law and was therefore unlawful.

From left, Kim Seonghwan and Park Juhyeon, partner attorneys on Lee & Ko’s tax team, and attorney Bae Songho pose during a meeting with The Asia Business Daily at Lee & Ko in Jung-gu, Seoul. Photo by Kim Hyunmin.

From left, Kim Seonghwan and Park Juhyeon, partner attorneys on Lee & Ko’s tax team, and attorney Bae Songho pose during a meeting with The Asia Business Daily at Lee & Ko in Jung-gu, Seoul. Photo by Kim Hyunmin.

View original image

In a full-bench ruling in August 2016, the Supreme Court held that the amount discounted when customers paid with accumulated points was a “discount,” which is excluded from the VAT tax base. For example, if an item priced at 1,000 won is sold for 900 won, the tax base is 900 won, and only 90 won in VAT is charged. But less than six months later, in February 2017, the government amended the Enforcement Decree to include in the taxable supply value the portion of payments made with partner-company points that was reimbursed by the partner company. The relevant statutory provision, however, contained no reference to mileage points. Mileage points were expressly addressed in the law only after it was amended in December that year.


The plaintiff was a company that had operated and managed an online shopping mall established by a partner company. After its request for a reassessment of taxes for 2017 was rejected, it filed a lawsuit but lost in both the first and second courts. Lee & Ko joined the case at the second-court stage, alongside the plaintiff's existing counsel, because it was the furthest advanced among cases involving the same issue. At the time, the first and second courts ruled, in effect, that the company should simply comply because the Enforcement Decree had been amended.


Before the Supreme Court, Lee & Ko stressed the flaw in that reasoning. “The interpretation of the law had already been settled, yet they simply changed the Enforcement Decree,” Kim said. “The 2016 full-bench ruling was based on an interpretation of the law, not the Enforcement Decree. Unless the law itself is fundamentally changed, an Enforcement Decree cannot contradict it.” Partner attorney Park Juhyeon said, “We stressed that the law contains no provision treating mileage points as part of the supply value, and questioned whether a discount that consumers clearly understand as a price reduction could be treated as payment of consideration with monetary value.”


The Supreme Court ultimately overturned and remanded the lower-court ruling, accepting Lee & Ko's argument that the Enforcement Decree provision was invalid. It found that the provision conflicted with the statutory provision excluding discounts from the supply value and expanded the supply value beyond the scope of the delegation. The court also said that the National Assembly must provide for the inclusion of mileage points in the tax base through legislation.


“An Enforcement Decree is a rule for implementing a law; it cannot replace the law,” Kim said. “The Supreme Court put a stop to the practice of setting matters that should be legislated independently in an Enforcement Decree, rather than in a law or under an explicit delegation of authority by law.”



Kim added, “These days, tax disputes arise less because someone is openly trying to do something wrong and more because of differences of opinion over how specific provisions of tax law should be interpreted. As tax laws change at least once a year, it is important for companies to proactively review areas that could pose problems and communicate with experts.”

[The Blueprint for Victory] Lee & Ko Overturns 'VAT on Points' Case at Supreme Court View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing