Sewoon District 4 Ruins Preservation Plan Deferred Again... This Time, "We Will Conduct an On-Site Inspection"
Preservation plan for ruins deferred again... Reconsideration after on-site inspection
World Heritage Impact Assessment lawsuit to begin October 21
Residents: "Infringement of property rights"; Korea Heritage Service: "Assessment required"
Projec
A plan drawn up by Seoul Housing & Communities Corporation (SH), an agency under the Seoul Metropolitan Government, to preserve archaeological remains at Sewoon 4 District has once again failed to pass government review. With a lawsuit challenging the government's order to conduct a World Heritage Impact Assessment also scheduled to begin this month, the conflict between the government and the Seoul Metropolitan Government over redevelopment of Sewoon 4 District in front of Jongmyo Shrine is expected to intensify.
According to the urban redevelopment industry on October 13, the National Heritage Committee, an advisory body to the Korea Heritage Service, recently reconsidered SH's "Plan to Preserve Archaeological Remains at the Site of the Sewoon 4 District Urban Environment Improvement Project" and again decided to defer its review.
The National Heritage Committee deferred its review of SH's submission in August. At the time, the committee concluded that the plan should be reviewed again after changes to the project implementation plan had been finalized. SH objected, requesting that the committee disclose the specific reasons and criteria behind its decision and resume the review.
However, it has been confirmed that, in its recent reconsideration, the committee decided to conduct an on-site inspection. The committee informed SH that "after a detailed review of the preservation plan proposed by the project operator, an on-site inspection of certain aspects, including the location and method of preservation, is necessary before the plan can be reconsidered."
The committee also effectively rejected a "conditional approval" approach under which SH could proceed with its proposed project while the adequacy of the preservation plan was reviewed. SH had sought to proceed with development while protecting the cultural heritage, thereby securing procedures to address future changes and minimizing project delays caused by prolonged litigation. The committee did not disclose the specific scope or schedule of the on-site inspection.
The review covers a Joseon-era village gate and related archaeological features identified in the excavation, as well as a drainage channel on the northern side of the site. SH planned to relocate the gate to an open space on the eastern side above ground and move earlier-period remains and the drainage channel. The plan had received residents' consent and also included a proposal to expand the existing space for displaying excavation materials and install it on basement level 1. SH said, "A preservation plan for the same archaeological site was reviewed by the Cultural Heritage Committee in January 2024, and SH incorporated the requirements set out at the time and supplemented the preservation plan."
The problem is that the rift between the two sides is widening. The administrative lawsuit filed by SH in response to the Korea Heritage Service's order to conduct a World Heritage Impact Assessment is set to begin on October 21. The Korea Heritage Service ordered SH to "conduct a World Heritage Impact Assessment in accordance with the Special Act on the Preservation, Management and Utilization of World Heritage, and revise or adjust the project implementation plan to reflect the results." SH filed suit, arguing that "the Korea Heritage Service issued an enforcement order regarding a project being lawfully pursued."
The project implementation plan approval for the Sewoon 4 District redevelopment, for which the public notice has already been issued, is also undergoing a review of its legal and administrative validity. Jongno District, the local government with jurisdiction, issued the public notice approving the project implementation plan shortly before the former district head, a member of the People Power Party, left office. The incumbent district head, a member of the Democratic Party of Korea, has questioned the approval.
SH argues that the legality of the project cannot be challenged on the basis of the possibility of a future cancellation that remains uncertain. Residents are also opposing the Korea Heritage Service's demand for a World Heritage Impact Assessment, calling it "an illegal act of obstructing permits and approvals with no legal basis."
The Korea Heritage Service has taken a firm position. Korea Heritage Service Administrator Heo Min told the National Assembly last week, "The Sewoon district is surrounded by buildings, and it would be contradictory to allow buildings of the same height to rise there. The assessment must be conducted in light of the heritage's value as a World Heritage site." The Seoul Metropolitan Government, by contrast, maintains that the participation of residents, including landowners who are the project proponents, must be a prerequisite for a World Heritage Impact Assessment. Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon stressed, "The site is 180 meters from Jongmyo's outer gate, so it would not be subject to the assessment even if it were designated as a 100-meter heritage buffer zone."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Police are investigating drilling work SH carried out to prepare architectural designs for the project site. In March, the Korea Heritage Service filed a complaint with police, alleging that SH violated the Buried Cultural Heritage Protection Act by drilling to a maximum depth of approximately 38 meters at the Sewoon 4 District site without authorization.
Drilling at the buried cultural heritage excavation site in Seoul's Sewoon 4 District. The Asia Business Daily
View original image© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.