[Beopssosigae] Investigative Agency Chiefs Summoned to Cabinet Meetings, 'Political Neutrality' Rendered Meaningless View original image

"I'm on edge, so I deliberately take my seat right on time. Other cabinet members might arrive early and make awkward requests, and it could be troublesome if I were photographed talking with them."


That is what the head of an investigative agency said privately about his experience attending Cabinet meetings chaired by the president at Cheong Wa Dae. He said he even stopped taking medication because of the meetings, which are held every Tuesday and last a grueling three to four hours without a break. The medication could increase urination. Accounts from inside and outside the government suggest that closed-door Cabinet meetings are rigid and strict. One anecdote involved Minister A, who has diabetes, briefly leaving the room in a cold sweat to get an insulin shot. Another described Cabinet member B, who kept speaking past his allotted time in an effort to score points with the president.


These meetings are meant to discuss the administration's affairs, but it is questionable whether the heads of investigative agencies should be part of a forum like this, where they may feel compelled to gauge the president's thinking. Investigative agencies are not institutions that must automatically fall in line with the administration, as other ministries do. At times, they may have to investigate the president, the nation's highest-ranking official, or members of his family and close associates. Their fundamental role is to scrutinize those in power and prevent undue pressure from being brought to bear on legitimate investigations.


President Lee Jaemyung began inviting former acting Prosecutor General Gu Jahyeon to Cabinet meetings in January this year. Then, on October 6, he invited acting Public Prosecution Office Chief Lee Jeonghyeon, acting Serious Crime Investigation Agency Chief Jeon Jongmin, and acting National Police Agency Commissioner General Kim Jongcheol all at once. President Lee told them to "conduct investigations impartially, without regard to political affiliation or whether someone belongs to the ruling or opposition party." On the surface, this sounds like a reasonable, principled admonition. But the problem is not the content of the message; it is the "place" and "format" in which it was delivered.


It was generally understood that the heads of investigative agencies, such as the commissioner general of the National Police Agency and the prosecutor general, who are not Cabinet members, would not regularly attend Cabinet meetings chaired by the president. This principle has been upheld since the launch of the civilian government. It was intended to safeguard the political neutrality of the prosecution, a quasi-judicial institution, and the independence of investigations. The moment an official responsible for investigations is summoned to the heart of government, implicit pressure comes into play. It cannot be ruled out that, after the meeting, the president or senior secretary for civil affairs might summon them separately to issue instructions or make requests concerning specific cases.


During the former Yoon Sukyeol administration, the Democratic Party accused Prosecutor General Sim Uijeong of "clear undue pressure on an investigation" after records emerged showing that Senior Secretary for Civil Affairs Kim Juhyeon had spoken by phone with Sim, who was overseeing an investigation related to First Lady Kim Geonhee. The party even reported Sim to the Corruption Investigation Office for High-ranking Officials. Why has a standard that was so strict over a single phone call become so lenient now? Moreover, the Public Prosecution Office, which has no investigative authority and only decides whether to indict, has an even stronger quasi-judicial role than the former prosecution service. Its independence should be protected as rigorously as that of the courts.



The president should not summon the heads of investigative agencies to a Cabinet meeting to tell them to "conduct investigations impartially, without regard to political affiliation or whether someone belongs to the ruling or opposition party." The first priority is to establish physical and institutional distance so that investigative agencies do not have to watch for the government's reaction. The greater that distance, the better. Letting them work quietly according to the law and principles, without summoning them to Cabinet meetings, is the first step toward genuine investigative independence.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing