Underprepared SCIA launches amid concerns
Appointment delayed amid controversy over SCIA chief nominee's political leanings
Yun Ho-jung orders inspection of Lim Eun-jeong, chief of the Gwangju Regional SCIA
Careful institutional safeguards needed

Choi Seokjin, Law&Biz Specialist

Choi Seokjin, Law&Biz Specialist

View original image

On October 2, the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency (SCIA) finally opened its doors. Prosecutors' offices nationwide, stripped of their investigative functions, changed their nameplates to the Prosecution Service. The "prosecution reform" launched under the Moon Jae-in administration with the promise of "reining in the prosecution service, which has wielded unchecked power with investigation and prosecution authority in both hands," has ultimately ended with the abolition of the prosecution service.


But why, now that the prosecution service - which seemed to be the source of all the problems - is gone and a new investigative agency has been established, are concerns outweighing expectations?


First, the public cannot help but feel uneasy as the agency hurriedly opens its doors without a chief and with less than 70% of its authorized staff in place. The types of crimes it can investigate differ from those previously handled by the prosecution service, yet even among legal professionals, few know which crimes fall under the police's jurisdiction and which are handled by the SCIA.


The number of prosecutors who applied to join the SCIA also fell far short of expectations. In particular, many so-called ace prosecutors, whose investigative abilities had been recognized in their respective fields, chose to remain with the Prosecution Service. There are concerns that criminals may be the only ones to benefit if the prosecution service's investigative expertise, built up over 78 years, is not properly transferred to the SCIA. In any case, these problems may be resolved over time, and we can say that a temporary gap in investigations is a price worth paying to improve the system.


The biggest concern is whether the SCIA can maintain its independence from political power.


The Prosecutors' Office was an agency under the Ministry of Justice, but over many years it developed a degree of institutional independence through established practices. That is why then-Prosecutor General Yoon Seokyoul could point out the improper investigative directives of then-Justice Minister Choo Mi-ae during a parliamentary audit in 2020 and say, "The prosecutor general is not the minister's subordinate."


But look at what is happening now over the appointment of the first SCIA chief. Kim Jiyong, the nominee for the post, was recommended through the procedures set out in the SCIA Act, underwent additional vetting, and had President Lee Jaemyung approve the request for a confirmation hearing. Yet hardliners within the Democratic Party, including Gyeonggi Province Governor Choo Mi-ae and lawmaker Kim Yong-min, continued to oppose him, prompting even Democratic Party leader Kim Minseok to issue a warning. On October 11, Lim Eunjung, chief of the Gwangju Regional SCIA, who had publicly criticized Kim and called for his nomination to be withdrawn, was made the SCIA's first subject of an internal inspection after Interior and Safety Minister Yoon Hojeong said, "She seems to have mistaken the SCIA for a political organization rather than an investigative agency."


I simply cannot understand how people who fiercely criticized Supreme Court Chief Justice Cho Heedae over the recommendation of candidates for Supreme Court justice, insisting that the president's appointment authority must be respected, can now disregard the president's authority to appoint the SCIA chief. No wonder President Lee said, "You must not use the pretext of prosecution reform to let personal motives dictate personnel decisions or specific investigative and prosecutorial work."


On the surface, the debate is over whether Kim can be classified as one of "Yoon Seokyoul's people." But the conflict seems ultimately to stem from differing views on whether he is truly on their side and can be trusted to exercise investigative authority appropriately when needed, and to show restraint at other times.


The day before the SCIA opened, lawyer Jeon Jongmin, who had represented Cho Kuk, head of the Innovation Policy Research Institute at the Cho Kuk Innovation Party, and lawmakers Choi Kangwook and Lee Seongyoon, was appointed deputy chief of the agency's headquarters and became acting chief of the SCIA. The Democratic Party is also pushing a plan to exclude the president and lawmakers from the Corruption Investigation Office for High-ranking Officials' (CIO) jurisdiction and have the SCIA investigate them, under the pretext of strengthening the CIO.


Jeon Jongmin, acting chief of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency (from left); Kim Jongcheol, acting chief of the National Police Agency; and Lee Jeonghyeon, acting chief of the Prosecution Service, salute the national flag as they attend a Cabinet meeting at the Blue House on the 6th. Yonhap News Agency.

Jeon Jongmin, acting chief of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency (from left); Kim Jongcheol, acting chief of the National Police Agency; and Lee Jeonghyeon, acting chief of the Prosecution Service, salute the national flag as they attend a Cabinet meeting at the Blue House on the 6th. Yonhap News Agency.

View original image

Another cause for concern is the plan to have the acting chiefs of the SCIA, the National Police Agency, and the Prosecution Service attend Cabinet meetings at the Blue House together, apparently to make the attendance of the heads of these investigative and prosecutorial agencies a regular practice.


In retrospect, the problem was not the prosecution service's immense powers, but the people who used it as a means to seize or retain power. This is clear from the case of former President Yoon, who, after investigating the Park Geun-hye administration's government-rigging scandal, received his appointment letter to cheers of "our Prosecutor General Yoon," only to become the ruling camp's "public enemy" overnight after launching an investigation into the Cho Kuk family, whose convictions were later upheld by the Supreme Court.



If the system is not carefully strengthened to ensure political neutrality and independence before the SCIA begins full-scale investigations, the situation could become far more serious than feared. As former Prosecutor General Moon Mooil once put it, as long as there is a hand shaking the suit, changing it to another outfit will do nothing to stop the shaking.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing