Russia's Suspected Plague Leak Is Beginning to Resemble the COVID-19 Outbreak

Conflicting Accounts of the Incident Even Within Russia
Russia Unmoved Despite WHO's Requests for More Information



■ Program: The Asia Business Daily's "So Jongseop's Current Affairs Show"

■ Host: So Jongseop, political specialist

■ Producer: Ma Yena

■ Guest: Reporter Lee Hyunwoo


The international community is on edge after reports emerged that a 28-year-old female researcher at a plague-control research institute in Siberia, Russia, died just over a week after breaking a test tube containing a pathogen. Suspicions about what happened are growing as accounts from Russia's central and regional governments conflict. International health authorities are also increasingly concerned that the incident could lead to a major pandemic like the COVID-19 crisis, as the Russian government has yet to disclose the full facts.


A micrograph of the plague bacterium (Yersinia pestis) found in tissue collected during plague research in San Francisco in 1965. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

A micrograph of the plague bacterium (Yersinia pestis) found in tissue collected during plague research in San Francisco in 1965. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

View original image

Russian Health Authorities and Regional Government Offer Conflicting Accounts of How Plague May Have Leaked


Russian media reports say the accident occurred on September 25 at a plague-control research institute in Irkutsk Oblast, Siberia. The researcher was admitted to a hospital four days later, on September 29, with severe pneumonia symptoms, and died between October 1 and 2. Russian authorities are currently investigating the exact route of infection and the identity of the pathogen in the broken test tube. Accordingly, the incident's classification has changed from a "leak incident" to a "suspected leak incident."

AFP-Yonhap News

AFP-Yonhap News

View original image

The central issue is that government agencies have given different accounts of how the researcher became infected. Central health authorities first raised the possibility that a test tube had broken at the research institute, while the government of Irkutsk Oblast, where the institute is located, suggested another possibility. The researcher had traveled on a business trip to the Republic of Buryatia, which borders Mongolia, before the accident, and may have contracted plague there.


The area around Buryatia is known for occasional outbreaks of plague transmitted by rodents, given its proximity to Mongolia and Central Asia. Cases have been reported in particular among Indigenous people who hunt rodents. If the Irkutsk Oblast government's account is correct, the researcher became infected at her destination, then developed the disease after an incubation period.


However, the Buryatia government immediately denied the claim. It said that not a single case of plague had occurred in its jurisdiction around the time of the incident. Buryatia officials said, in effect, "There have been some cases of COVID-19 and flu, but no matter how hard we look, there are no plague cases." With regional governments appearing to shift responsibility onto one another, Russia's central health authorities are reportedly also in some confusion. Voices in Russia and abroad say it is difficult to tell whether the government will transparently disclose the facts and take action or focus on covering up the incident.

A Researcher Died After a Test Tube Broke? Suspicions Continue to Grow

AFP-Yonhap News

AFP-Yonhap News

View original image

"Why did she die of a treatable disease?"... Even suspicions of a biological weapon. Scientists say it is rare for a single broken test tube to trigger a large-scale outbreak, as depicted in movies. Most pathogens handled in laboratories are for research purposes and are not often used in a fully active state. In addition, many pathogens have sharply reduced survival rates once they leave a test tube.


The research environment is another factor. Researchers handling high-risk pathogens wear protective suits, and if an accident occurs, they immediately discard the suits and follow disinfection procedures. This is why the explanation that the researcher became infected and died simply because a test tube broke is not easy to accept.


The death itself raises an even bigger question. Plague is a deadly disease that swept through the population of medieval Europe, but today it can be treated with antibiotics. Medical experts say it is rare for a young patient in their 20s to die if treated early in the course of the illness. This has prompted questions about why the researcher died, given that she would presumably have received treatment if pneumonia symptoms appeared immediately after the test tube broke.


This has even led to suspicions that the pathogen in the broken test tube was not an ordinary plague bacterium, but a biological weapon Russia had been developing in secret. The international community is most concerned about whether the researcher contracted the disease naturally at her travel destination or whether an accident occurred during weapons development.


The U.S. health authorities and the World Health Organization (WHO) are paying particular attention to the incident because it has many parallels with the early stages of the COVID-19 crisis. The central and regional governments are giving conflicting accounts, and accurate information is not being disclosed in a timely manner. There are concerns that, as during the COVID-19 crisis, a regional government might try to conceal or downplay the incident, potentially allowing it to become a global pandemic.


In the early stages of the COVID-19 outbreak in 2019, authorities in Wuhan, China, reportedly underreported cases of pneumonia of unknown cause. It later emerged that a substantial number of cases had appeared much earlier, and criticism followed that local authorities had failed to report them in a timely manner. At the time, large-scale local political events and mass gatherings attended by tens of thousands of people were held in Wuhan without public health measures. Some analyses have suggested that attendees dispersed to various locations, accelerating the spread.

"It's Different from Wuhan," but... The Variable Is the Front Line in Ukraine

Fortunately, the WHO and the scientific community believe that the likelihood of the incident escalating into a worst-case scenario like COVID-19 is low. The main reason is the geography. The site of the accident is in the heart of Siberia, with no major cities nearby. Seasonal conditions also support this assessment: summer has ended and cold weather is setting in, so analysts say the pathogen is likely to die before it can spread beyond the region, even if it escapes into the environment.


The differences from Wuhan are also clear. When COVID-19 broke out, Wuhan was a major city with a population of more than 10 million. It was a transportation and industrial hub where several expressways converged, with an international airport and a port, as well as a concentration of global automakers. That is why the virus was able to spread around the world so quickly after authorities missed the window for an early response. Inland Siberia is far removed from these conditions.


The concerning variable, however, is the war in Ukraine. Russia is conscripting troops from across Siberia and the Far East and sending them to the front. Some warn that if an infected person is conscripted and deployed to the Ukrainian front, it could lead to a cluster of infections within the Russian military.


The worst-case scenario could unfold after that. No matter how strictly Europe blocks Russians from entering, it would be difficult to completely stop the movement of smugglers, intelligence operatives, and others. There are concerns that the pathogen could enter Europe in this way and then spread around the world.


In light of these risks, international health authorities are urging Russia to conclude its investigation as soon as possible and disclose the full details of the incident. Key questions include what pathogen was in the broken test tube, the exact cause of the researcher's death, and how thoroughly the possibility that she contracted the disease at her travel destination has been investigated. It remains unclear, however, whether Russia will comply. Many observers believe that Russia is unlikely to voluntarily disclose information about a sensitive research facility while its confrontation with the West over the war in Ukraine continues.



The more uncertain the facts remain, the more speculation grows, and anxiety is bound to rise given that the matter involves a pathogen. The lesson of COVID-19 is that transparently disclosing information at the outset is the surest way to prevent the spread of an outbreak. Ultimately, the key to easing the international community's concerns lies in Russia's hands.

"Eerily Similar to the COVID-19 Crisis"... Mysterious Death at Russian Research Institute Revives 'Pandemic Nightmare' [Current Affairs Show] View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing