Woman in Her 20s, a Cafe Employee, Bitten by Customer's Dog
"Upper-Lip Scar Affects Career and Personal Relationships"

A court has ruled that an insurer representing a dog owner must pay more than 63 million won to a woman in her 20s who was bitten in the face while trying to give someone else’s dog a treat.


According to legal sources on October 9, Judge Kim Yunjin of the Seoul Central District Court’s Civil Division 87 (single-judge) ruled partially in favor of the plaintiff in a lawsuit filed by a woman identified as A against the dog owner’s insurer, seeking 100 million won in insurance compensation. The court ordered the insurer to pay her 63,213,111 won, plus interest for delayed payment.

Bitten in Face While Giving Someone Else's Dog a Treat... Court: "63 Million Won in Damages" View original image

The accident occurred at a cafe in Seoul in July 2023. A was bitten in the face while trying to give a treat to a male Jindo mix that had come to the cafe where she worked with its owner. At first, A offered the dog a treat by hand. She then held a treat in her mouth and leaned her face toward the dog to feed it, and the dog bit her on the lip.


At the time of the accident, the owner had the dog on a leash and was holding it, but did not stop A from moving her face close to the dog. The dog had also bitten a neighbor on the buttocks about three months before the accident.


A was left with a scar on her upper left lip and an injury to the bridge of her nose. Damage to the muscles around her mouth and a loss of skin caused her lips to become uneven in length and asymmetrical. A subsequently sued the dog owner’s insurer, seeking 100 million won in insurance compensation.


The court found the dog owner liable for damages. Judge Kim said, “Even a dog that is usually gentle may suddenly become aggressive,” and noted that the owner should have held the leash short to keep the dog at a certain distance from the woman or warned her that moving her face close to the dog was dangerous. The judge also found it difficult to conclude that the dog had no aggressive tendencies, given that it had previously bitten a neighbor.


The court found that the aftereffects of A’s injuries could also affect her professional activities.


“The scar on her upper left lip is very noticeable and is in an area that draws attention when she faces other people,” Judge Kim said. “It is significant enough to affect her ability to remain employed, seek work and maintain interpersonal relationships.” The court therefore recognized a permanent loss of earning capacity of 12%.


However, the court also found A partly responsible for the accident. “Holding a treat in one’s mouth and leaning one’s face toward a dog is not a typical way to feed a pet,” Judge Kim said, adding that “this behavior appears to have provoked the dog.” Taking into account that the owner had the dog on a leash and pulled it back immediately after the accident to prevent further injury, the court limited the owner’s liability for damages to 50%.



The defendant insurer has appealed the ruling, and the appeal is currently underway.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing