Lack of Sectors at the Upper End of the AI Value Chain
South Korean Market Has No Sectors to Rotate Into
Risk of Being Left Behind in the First Half of Next Year

While the U.S. stock market has continued to climb amid a high-interest-rate environment, the KOSPI has remained range-bound. Some analysts say this reflects the widening gap between the U.S. and South Korea in the structure of their AI value chains, as the AI theme shifts from infrastructure investment to monetization.


On the 12th, the KOSPI and KOSDAQ indexes are displayed on an electronic board in the dealing room at Hana Bank's headquarters in Jung-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency.

On the 12th, the KOSPI and KOSDAQ indexes are displayed on an electronic board in the dealing room at Hana Bank's headquarters in Jung-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency.

View original image

According to iM Securities on October 12, the United States has leading publicly traded companies across five upper-tier segments of the AI value chain: ▲ applications (Palantir and ServiceNow) ▲ cybersecurity (CrowdStrike and Palo Alto Networks) ▲ cloud platforms (M7) ▲ semiconductor design (NVIDIA, Broadcom, and Marvell) ▲ electronic design automation (EDA) for semiconductors (Synopsys and Cadence). In contrast, South Korea's industry is concentrated in manufacturing, including foundries (contract semiconductor manufacturing), memory, and equipment.


U.S. companies in these upper-tier segments have less exposure to inventory and capital equipment costs, and benefit from high customer retention and subscription-based revenue models. As a result, they are not directly affected when memory prices fall. Marvell, for example, is a fabless semiconductor design company that outsources production to foundries, and data centers account for 79% of its revenue. In the EDA market, Synopsys, Cadence, and Siemens together hold 70% to 80% of the global market. Subscription-based recurring revenue accounts for 80% to 85% of these companies' sales, and customer retention rates are close to 100%.


Wall Street Soars, KOSPI Stays Trapped... U.S. Has Big Tech and Chip Design, Korea Only Memory in English View original image

In contrast, South Korea's semiconductor industry is centered on memory-focused integrated device manufacturers (IDMs), which bear the costs of capital investment and inventory directly. As a result, oversupply leads to lower average selling prices (ASPs) and inventory write-downs, both of which directly erode earnings. Even when companies benefit from the same AI boom, those higher up the value chain can expand their margins, while those lower down face the structural constraint of exposure to price cycles. The KOSPI's heavy concentration in semiconductors is another issue. Samsung Electronics and SK hynix together account for more than half of the KOSPI's market capitalization, while semiconductors make up only about 18% of the S&P 500.


With upper-tier sectors underrepresented, South Korea's stock market often lacks sectors and companies that can benefit when sector rotation takes place in the U.S. market. Even when U.S. capital shifts from beneficiaries of infrastructure investment to AI application and cloud companies, U.S. indexes can continue to rise through sector rotation within the indexes. In South Korea, however, there are no upper-tier sectors for capital to rotate into, so money flows out of the stock market. In other words, sector rotation in the United States takes place within the index, while in South Korea it involves capital leaving the index.


Foreign investor flows also suggest that this sector rotation may already be underway. The continued absence of foreign investors may be interpreted as a process of reallocating capital from AI infrastructure to other sectors. In this process, South Korean stocks are inevitably used as a source of funds; when foreign investors decide to reduce their exposure to AI infrastructure, they also directly reduce their exposure to the South Korean stock market.


The slowdown in investment growth is another source of concern. Infrastructure companies' share prices respond to the growth rate of capital expenditure, not to the absolute amount spent. Even if big tech companies continue to increase their investment in absolute terms, the moment the growth rate begins to slow, companies lower down the value chain are the first to reach their share-price peaks. Quarterly capital expenditure growth among hyperscalers is expected to peak in the third quarter of 2026.


Ultimately, South Korea remains an intermediate-goods supplier in the AI cycle, leaving it increasingly vulnerable as the AI market moves into monetization and application. Some sectors, including power equipment and substrates, are benefiting from investment in physical AI infrastructure. However, their share of the market is small compared with Samsung Electronics and SK hynix, making them insufficient to offset concerns that the broader stock market will be left behind.


Wall Street Soars, KOSPI Stays Trapped... U.S. Has Big Tech and Chip Design, Korea Only Memory in English View original image

Analysts say the sustainability of earnings at South Korean semiconductor companies will be key to a stock market rebound amid the shift toward AI monetization and a high-interest-rate new normal. "As AI moves into the application phase in the first half of 2027, concerns that the South Korean stock market will be left behind could peak while application-layer sectors such as software and cybersecurity benefit, because South Korea lacks exposure to these sectors," said Kim Junyoung, an analyst at iM Securities. "However, if a surge in token consumption as AI applications expand leads to another shortage of inference capacity, we can expect a virtuous cycle in which memory and AI infrastructure benefit again in the second half of the year." He added, "A strategy of reducing concentration in memory, taking a defensive position focused on high-bandwidth memory (HBM) and power infrastructure in preparation for weak relative performance in the first half, and then preparing for a rebound in the second half would be effective."



"Because the high-interest-rate environment is unlikely to ease easily, opportunities should be sought within AI infrastructure, where growth outpaces costs," said Hwang Suuk, an analyst at Meritz Securities. "The fundamental reason South Korean semiconductor stocks have underperformed despite the global big tech rally is the lack of earnings momentum. For the index to rebound, the key will be whether market forecasts take shape that earnings can grow for three consecutive years through 2028."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing