Written by Kim Deokho, a professor at Sungkyunkwan University

Why Do Labor-Management, Intra-Labor, and Labor-Government Conflicts Keep Recurring? 'Labor Conflicts: Atlas Is Wronged' View original image

Generations clash over extending the retirement age, while the interests of subcontractors and prime contractors collide. Platform workers call for protection, and companies complain about the costs. Beyond labor-management disputes, conflicts between workers and between labor and government are making the battleground over labor increasingly complex.


Why do labor conflicts keep recurring? In his new book, Labor Conflicts: Atlas Is Wronged, Kim Deokho, an industry-academic professor at Sungkyunkwan University, looks beyond the surface of these conflicts to the structure of the labor market beneath them. He argues that conflicts are widespread throughout the labor market that are difficult to explain simply as different groups asserting their respective rights.


Atlas, in the book's title, is a metaphor for explaining this structure. In Greek mythology, Atlas was defeated in a war against the gods and punished by being made to hold up the sky. The people the author focuses on are subcontracted and non-regular workers, as well as platform workers and workers in special employment. They perform work essential to the functioning of the labor market, yet they often bear a disproportionate share of the risks and costs involved while remaining outside the reach of institutional protections.


The problem is that the burdens they shoulder do not stem from their personal choices or failings. Boundaries created within the labor market—between large and small or medium-sized companies, prime contractors and subcontractors, and regular and non-regular workers—as well as the systems that determine wages and employment, also shape how risks and costs are distributed. The author says that understanding labor conflicts requires looking beyond individual labor disputes to examine these underlying structures.


The idea of "fairness" can also fuel conflict. The standard of fairness varies depending on whose perspective is taken, even when the policy in question is the same. Extending the retirement age is a case in point. For older workers, it is about protecting their income and jobs. But for young people seeking to enter the labor market, it may mean fewer opportunities for new hires. Both sides can claim their demands are fair, yet a solution for one side may seem unfair to the other.



Ultimately, the author argues, labor conflicts cannot be resolved by approaching them solely as a question of "who is right." If one side's demands are simply imposed, conflict with the other side is bound to resurface. The author believes that conflicts need to be managed, not eliminated. Rather than trying to do away with conflict itself, it is important to establish mechanisms that bring competing interests to light before tensions escalate and allow the parties involved to negotiate and find common ground.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing