Could 'Upfront Support' for National Pension Credits Save Tens of Trillions? "We Need to Seek Ways to Ensure Fiscal Stability and Ease the Burden on Future Generations"
A shift to 'upfront support' could save tens of trillions of won over the long term
Short-term spending would surge after reform... Deficit bond issuance would also add to the burden
The National Pension credit system provides retroactive support by adding credit periods to a subscriber’s contribution history and paying an increased pension benefit when they begin receiving an old-age pension 30 to 40 years later, rather than when they make social contributions such as giving birth or completing military service. While this approach has the advantage of requiring little government spending upfront, it acts as a ticking time bomb, with expenditures ballooning over time. The fiscal shock will be concentrated in the future, when beneficiaries reach retirement age, and the National Pension System is structured so that total benefits exceed total contributions.
A shift to 'upfront support' would clearly reduce long-term costs, but sharply increase short-term spending
An alternative that has gained attention in response to these problems is upfront support, under which the government pays the contributions on a person’s behalf as soon as they give birth or complete military service. Two years ago, the National Pension Research Institute found that changing the timing of credit allocation to when the qualifying event occurs and paying contributions on the person’s behalf could reduce credit spending by approximately 87.8 trillion won through 2093. The analysis concluded that paying current contributions, which are relatively small compared with future benefits, is far more advantageous from a long-term fiscal perspective. Because the study was based on the system as it stood in 2024, before the expansion and reform of credits, the actual savings are expected to be even greater.
Upfront support would also strengthen women’s pension entitlements and make the policy’s benefits more tangible. Under the current system, credit periods are added when a person becomes eligible for an old-age pension. They must first clear the eligibility “thresholds” of reaching pension age and meeting the minimum contribution period of 10 years. This means that people who have not completed the required contribution period, for example because of career interruptions, may not be able to fully benefit from childbirth credits. According to data provided by the National Pension Service to the office of Rep. So Byung-hoon of the Democratic Party of Korea, women accounted for just 385, or 3.2%, of the 12,052 people who had received childbirth credits as of June. In many cases, the credits are added to a husband’s record because he has met the 10-year contribution requirement for pension eligibility. If contributions were supported at the time of childbirth, a person’s contribution period would increase immediately. Those with no history of National Pension coverage would also have the opportunity to make retroactive contributions, making it easier to secure pension eligibility in the future.
Subtle differences between the health and welfare and budget ministries... 'Different expectations'
The Ministry of Health and Welfare strongly supports the need to shift to upfront support and has been reviewing related reforms since last year. The Ministry of Planning and Budget, however, has maintained a cautious stance, revealing subtle differences between the ministries. While the change could reduce costs over the long term, it would sharply increase short-term spending because the government would have to allocate hundreds of billions of won in tax revenue from the budget for the year in which the system is reformed. The cost of military service credits is currently covered entirely by the national treasury, while childbirth credit costs are funded 30% by the national treasury and 70% by the National Pension Fund. Kang Younggyu, head of the Future Strategy Planning Office at the Ministry of Planning and Budget, recently told the National Assembly that “we believe we should be cautious about committing public funds to credits in advance,” adding, “If additional government bonds are issued to fund the credits, the burden will ultimately fall on future generations.” Minister of Planning and Budget Park Honggeun also made clear in his written responses ahead of his confirmation hearing that he opposed switching to upfront support, citing the government’s fiscal capacity.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Experts say structural reforms to the credit system are needed to move beyond “taking credit now while deferring the costs to the future.” Won Jonghyun, former vice president of the National Pension Research Institute, said, “The current system of retroactive support lets the government take credit today while passing the debt on to future generations. Rather than fear an immediate increase in spending, we need fundamental reforms, including a shift to upfront support and stronger measures to stabilize pension finances. That is the only way to achieve both fiscal stability and a reduced burden on future generations.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.