Appeals court overturns first-trial ruling, dismisses descendant's unjust enrichment claim
Land recognized as property Min Young-hwi held in trust under his son's name
Prevents additional unjust enrichment payments; paves way to recover pro-Japanese property

Namyangju City, Gyeonggi Province (Mayor Choi Hyun-deok), won an appeals court case seeking the return of unjust enrichment brought by a descendant of Min Young-hwi, a pro-Japanese collaborator, overturning its defeat in the first trial. The court ruled that the land registered in the name of Min Young-hwi's son was pro-Japanese property held in trust under the son's name by Min Young-hwi.

Namyangju City Hall. Photo courtesy of Namyangju City.

Namyangju City Hall. Photo courtesy of Namyangju City.

View original image

Namyangju City said on October 8 that the appeals court ruling became final on September 29, 2026.


The lawsuit concerned land in Toegyewon-ri, Toegyewon-eup. The land was surveyed and registered in the name of Min Young-hwi's son in 1913. Ownership was transferred to Min's descendants after they won a 2005 lawsuit against the Republic of Korea seeking cancellation of the registration of preservation of ownership. Citing that ruling, the descendant filed a claim against Namyangju City last year, in 2025, seeking the return of unjust enrichment.


The city argued that Min Young-hwi, the father, was the land's actual owner, even though the person named on the title had not been designated a pro-Japanese collaborator. It presented historical records and circumstantial evidence—including the son's age and whether he was engaged in economic activity at the time, how he came to acquire a substantial amount of land, and lawsuits related to the recovery of property associated with Min Young-hwi—to establish that the land was held in trust under the son's name.


The first-trial court rejected the city's arguments. The appeals court, however, ruled that Min Young-hwi had held the land in trust under his son's name. It dismissed the plaintiff's claim, finding that the land was pro-Japanese property that had reverted to the state under the Special Act on the Reversion of Property of Pro-Japanese Collaborators to the State.


The city said the final ruling prevented it from having to make additional payments for unjust enrichment and provided grounds to pursue the recovery of pro-Japanese property. It also said the ruling was significant because it showed that land registered in the name of a descendant who had not been designated a pro-Japanese collaborator could still be recognized as pro-Japanese property if the circumstances of its acquisition and the nominee arrangement were established.


Namyangju Mayor Choi Hyun-deok said, "This ruling is significant because it established the actual ownership of property held in trust under a descendant's name and recognized it as pro-Japanese property." He added, "We will continue to respond actively to related lawsuits and work closely with relevant agencies to ensure that pro-Japanese property is transferred to the state through due legal procedures."



Namyangju City plans to provide relevant records and case materials to the Pro-Japanese Property Investigation Committee, which is scheduled to begin operating in December 2026. For land confirmed to be pro-Japanese property, the city plans to ask relevant agencies to take the necessary steps, including transferring it to the state and recovering it.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing