Even with a 1% success fee, stakes are enormous
Focus intensifies on possible change or reinforcement of legal counsel

The divorce lawsuit of Smilegate founder Kwon Hyukbin, involving the largest-ever property division, has moved to the appellate court after both parties filed appeals, drawing significant attention from the legal industry. This is because the case involves not only massive legal fees but also control over the company.


Kwon filed an appeal on September 28, 2026, followed by his wife, Lee Hwajin, who filed her appeal the next day. On September 9, the Seoul Family Court’s 3rd Civil Division for Family Affairs (presided over by Chief Judge Jeong Donghyuk) ruled in favor of Lee’s divorce petition and ordered Kwon to transfer 35% of Smilegate Holdings shares and KRW 65 billion in cash to her. The total scale of the property division amounts to approximately KRW 2.55 trillion.


The legal community is focused on whether Kwon will change or strengthen his legal counsel. Prominent law firm attorneys, speaking on condition of anonymity, said, "We have heard that Kwon is considering several law firms. Given that both reinforcement and replacement of counsel are options, law firms are expected to compete fiercely for this case."


For law firms, Kwon’s divorce case—where property division is worth trillions of won—represents a major work opportunity. A victory could bring substantial revenue. Typically, the success fee in divorce lawsuits is set at around 5–15% of the property division amount. However, in cases involving astronomical amounts such as Kwon’s, the success fee rate may decrease, and the criteria for calculation are not always strictly tied to the amount won. Nevertheless, even applying just 0.1% to the property division amount of approximately KRW 2.55 trillion set in the first trial, the success fee would reach KRW 2.55 billion; if a 1% rate is applied, it would reach KRW 25.5 billion.


Some have commented that the fierce competition among law firms for this case recalls the divorce proceedings of SK Group Chairman Chey Tae-won. In May 2024, after Chey was ordered in the appeals court to pay KRW 1.3808 trillion to Noh So-young, director of Art Center Nabi, he also reorganized his legal team, with major law firms giving presentations and competing to take on his case.


Beyond legal fees, law firms are also interested in the networking opportunities with Smilegate. According to the first-instance decision, if Lee objects, Kwon would not be able to unilaterally handle significant matters requiring a special resolution, such as mergers and splits, amendment of the articles of incorporation, capital reduction, and dismissal of directors. This would create significant uncertainty in Smilegate’s management. Therefore, if a law firm can resolve this issue on appeal, it is expected to build a close relationship with Smilegate in the future.


For the first trial, Lee's legal representation included Kang Namgyu (31st Judicial Training Institute) of Gaon Lawfirm, and Yoon Jisang (35th Judicial Training Institute) of Jonjae Lawfirm, both serving as lead attorneys.


Lee’s side demanded half of the shares, citing her initial shareholding, list as a director during Smilegate’s founding, and more than 20 years of contribution to the family and child-rearing. Meanwhile, Kwon’s side argued for maintaining the marriage at first instance, while denying Lee’s contribution through investment or management. Whether either side will revise their legal strategy is another key point to watch in the appellate court proceedings.



Reporter Sangwoo Lee, The Law Times


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing