Lee Chang-yong Raises the Issue of Work Hour Structure Reform... Calls for Introduction of "Korean-Style White-Collar Exemption"
Seeking Ways to Improve Both Quality of Life and Productivity Beyond Merely Cutting Working Hours
Proposing a System Where Employees Focus on Performance Without Time Constraints While Working,
and Take Proper Rest with Extended Vacations
Lee Chang-yong, former Governor of the Bank of Korea and Distinguished Professor at Seoul National University, has proposed the introduction of a "Korean-style white-collar exemption" (a performance- and autonomy-centered work hour system). He suggested lifting the 52-hour weekly work cap for managers, professionals, and office workers whose total annual pay exceeds 200% of the median wage—specifically, those earning at least 82 million won. Under his proposal, work would be evaluated based on performance, allowing employees to work autonomously without time restrictions, while also enabling them to take proper long-term breaks when resting.
He also emphasized the need to reform the compensation structure. Lee argued that overtime pay, which compensates for extra hours worked, should be abolished and replaced by a clear system for annual salaries and performance bonuses, so that compensation is determined by performance. He pointed out that such discussions have recently been limited to the semiconductor industry and argued that the scope of eligible positions and the way the system is implemented should both be significantly expanded.
At the Population Cluster Forum hosted by the SNU Institute for National Future Strategies on October 6, Lee unveiled a paper titled "How Should We Reform the Work Hour System?" and stressed, "For white-collar workers, even if the annual total work hours remain the same, they should be able to autonomously focus on work when needed." He explained that setting salaries and bonuses based on performance and tasks could prevent the adverse effect of working less efficiently during the day and then earning extra overtime pay at night.
Lee criticized the current discretionary work hour system, which only applies to legally designated professions, for failing to address these problems. As an example, he cited global financial firms that, after the introduction of the 52-hour workweek, reduced domestic staff and relocated desks to Hong Kong. He noted that "Even if there is an agreement to work on a discretionary basis, if the relationship sours later and someone claims, 'I agreed involuntarily,' it could result in legal liability, which is a real deterrent."
On the 6th, at Seoul National University in Gwanak-gu, Seoul, Lee Chang-yong, former Governor of the Bank of Korea (right in the photo), and attendees are taking a commemorative photo at the Population Cluster Forum hosted by the SNU Institute for National Future Strategies. Photo by Yuri Kim
View original image"We Need to Lift the 52-Hour Cap and Shift to Performance-Based Compensation, Not Overtime Pay"
Oh explained, "For performance-based, highly skilled, knowledge-oriented jobs in fields such as R&D, IT, and finance, creativity and concentration are essential, and focused working hours are critical in a globally competitive environment." He also noted, "The higher the proportion of knowledge-based workers in an industry, the stronger the positive relationship between work hour flexibility and per capita productivity."
The estimated potential pool is about 1.49 million workers, accounting for 10.8% of regular employees. Oh stated that the eligible group comprises managers, professionals, and office workers who earn at least 200% of the median wage; among them, 79% of managers, 19% of professionals, and 16% of clerical workers qualify. About 42% of these potential candidates are employed in knowledge-based services. The average portion of performance bonuses relative to their total pay is 18.5%, indicating that the foundation for adopting a performance-linked compensation system is already in place.
In the United States, the white-collar exemption exempts managers and professionals above a certain salary threshold from the obligation to pay overtime. In Japan, the “High-Level Professional System” was introduced in 2019 for highly skilled professionals earning at least 10.75 million yen annually. Oh pointed out, "In Japan, a vast majority of workers (87.7%) reported satisfaction, especially regarding performance and autonomy." However, he also noted criticisms about long working hours (68.5%), suggesting that health protection measures must be implemented in conjunction.
For the design of the Korean-style white-collar exemption, it is necessary first to exclude the application of work hour and overtime pay provisions. This means waiving the 40-hour and 52-hour weekly caps (Articles 50 and 53 of the Labor Standards Act) and the requirements for extra pay for extended, night, or holiday work (Article 56 of the Act).
Oh also argued that there must be clear and regularly updated criteria for eligible employees. He noted, "The exemption should apply to those earning at least 200% of the median wage for regular workers, but this threshold should be adjusted periodically based on wage growth and working hour conditions. Furthermore, from a job role perspective, positions where real autonomy and performance can be measured should be eligible, while tasks where the employer retains substantial control over work hours and methods must be excluded."
Based on these foundations, the need for a performance-based compensation structure has been emphasized. He explained that performance metrics and calculation methods should be specified in employment contracts, fixed base wages be guaranteed, and agreed-upon performance be linked to additional bonuses. Sufficient health safeguards should also be established. Oh stated, "There must be measures such as guaranteeing minimum consecutive rest hours, requiring use of annual holidays and leave, mandatory health check-ups and consultations for long work hours, and employer-mandated health protection."
"Rigid Standard Work Formats: Employees Should Work Intensely and Rest Properly"
Over the past 20 years, total working hours have steadily decreased—from 2,447 hours per year in 2000 to 1,846 hours last year. The gap with the OECD average has also dropped from 687 hours to 141 hours. However, Korea's growth potential is rapidly weakening. According to OECD data, Korea's potential growth rate fell by 0.6 percentage points, from 2.5% in 2021 to 1.9% last year, a sharper drop than the major G7 countries, which saw changes ranging from -0.4 percentage points to 0.5 percentage points.
Oh stated, "The way we work now is defined by low productivity and long hours, rigid work hour structures, low vacation utilization, and limited use of flexible work arrangements." He pointed out that although the cap on working hours through the 52-hour workweek has reduced overtime, the reduction in income has mainly impacted lower-income workers. In companies with a high share of performance bonuses, productivity has been negatively affected.
Oh said, "Potential growth rate per work hour (GDP) is below the OECD average. The current structure compensates for low productivity through longer hours." He also observed, "The rigid work pattern of Monday through Friday, from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m., has become deeply entrenched." He pointed out that flexible work—working intensively when needed and resting adequately afterward—is not yet a reality.
The most significant issue identified was the rigidity and standardization of working hours. Oh explained, "Despite the existence of various flexible work systems, real-world utilization is low due to requirements like pre-scheduling shifts, short application periods, limited eligible roles, and legal uncertainties. Korea’s paid leave utilization rate is 75%, the second lowest among 12 major countries after Japan (63%). Not only do workers struggle to use their assigned leave, but the use of extended vacations is also extremely low."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Looking ahead, Oh emphasized that indiscriminate reduction of working hours should be approached with caution, and a culture of "resting properly when resting" must be established. He stated, "If the vacation usage rate rises from 75% to 95%, the average annual work hours can decrease by about 31 hours." He reiterated the need for a Korean-style white-collar exemption.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.