Cho Heedae Unusually States Position Despite Refusing Testimony
"Second Yoon Suk-yeol? That Is Insulting"

Chief Justice Hoedai Cho is responding to legislators' questions during the National Assembly audit of the Supreme Court held on October 6, 2026. Photo by Dongju Yoon

Chief Justice Hoedai Cho is responding to legislators' questions during the National Assembly audit of the Supreme Court held on October 6, 2026. Photo by Dongju Yoon

View original image

Chief Justice Hoedai Cho stated during the National Assembly's audit of the Supreme Court on October 6 that the remark "Are you dreaming of becoming the second Yoon Suk-yeol?" was "deeply insulting and saddening." The comment was made by Assemblywoman Sol Son of the Progressive Party, who asked, "Are you perhaps aiming to become the second Yoon Suk-yeol? Many citizens are questioning whether you are engaging in politics while still wearing judicial robes." Chief Justice Cho broke his silence to respond to this question.


Although Chief Justice Cho had been called as a general witness and refused both the witness oath and to testify, he took the unusual step of proactively expressing his stance in response to various allegations raised by members of the ruling party.


In response to the question from Assemblyman Gipyo Kim of the Democratic Party of Korea, who asked, "The most severe breach of judicial independence was the incident at the Western District Court. Why didn't you express your position at the time?" Chief Justice Cho replied, "On that day, the Chief Judge of the National Court Administration issued a strong statement directly at the scene." He explained further, "I was also about to go to the site, but I was advised that further presence might hinder the resolution process and that it would be better if I visited once the situation had stabilized to some extent." He went on to say, "After things had settled, I went and gathered all the relevant parties to listen to their concerns one by one and hear about what should be done in the future. All the necessary actions they wanted were subsequently taken," he emphasized.


Chief Justice Cho also responded to questions regarding his refusal to take the oath. He said, "Many people are curious, so I feel compelled to specifically explain my decision to refuse both the oath and testimony." He cited Article 104 of the Constitution, which stipulates that "Supreme Court Justices are appointed by the President with the consent of the National Assembly upon the recommendation of the Chief Justice." He then explained, "Just as the Chief Justice cannot intervene at all in the consent procedure of the National Assembly or the appointment procedure of the President, neither the National Assembly nor the President can interfere in the Chief Justice's recommendation. For the National Assembly to interfere with the Chief Justice's recommendation is an unconstitutional action that violates the constitutional division of powers among institutions and the independence of the judiciary, as expressly set forth in the Constitution."


Chief Justice Hoidae Cho sat in his seat refusing to take the witness oath during the National Assembly's audit of the Supreme Court held on the 6th. 2026.10.06 Photo by Dongjoo Yoon

Chief Justice Hoidae Cho sat in his seat refusing to take the witness oath during the National Assembly's audit of the Supreme Court held on the 6th. 2026.10.06 Photo by Dongjoo Yoon

View original image

He further pointed out that there is no constitutional basis for the President and Chief Justice to negotiate recommendations for Supreme Court Justices. "There is no constitutional foundation for such negotiations, but Chief Justices have voluntarily cooperated for the sake of prompt and smooth appointments," he said. "Even if the Chief Justice does not engage in such consultations, there are no constitutional issues. In fact, all past Presidents have ultimately respected the Chief Justice's authority to recommend, and the Constitution places no restrictions on written recommendations," he added.


Chief Justice Cho noted, "When submitting a request for appointment consent, the Chief Justice's constitutional role ends upon the recommendation, and the process is complete." He explained that requiring the Chief Justice to submit a request for appointment consent to the National Assembly has nothing to do with the recommendation itself. "Once the Chief Justice exercises this constitutional authority, the official obligations also end. Since the National Assembly has no constitutional grounds to raise such questions, I am explicitly stating the reasons for my refusal to take the oath or testify," he said.



Chief Justice Cho also made comments regarding martial law. He stated, "As you know, the Supreme Court was the first institution to publicly declare that emergency martial law was unconstitutional. The security director visited several times requesting confirmation of personnel from the Martial Law Command or at least a list of names, but I instructed, 'Do not send anyone because it is absolutely unconstitutional conduct, and do not provide any lists.' The Supreme Court did not cooperate with martial law in any way," he asserted.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing