[Seojunsik's Market and Economy] A 4.8% Stake Changed the Shareholders' Meeting... The Power of Shareholders Lies in Solidarity, Not Ownership
Dual Role of Pursuing Profit and Social Function
Divergent Views Toward Activist Investors
Minority Shareholders Gain Strength Amid Major Shareholder Abuses
Limited Impact One Year After Commercial Act Amendment on Minority Shareholde
"Professor Seo, is that you? Hello!"
In the summer of 2022, as I was hurrying to an appointment near Cheonggyecheon, a young stranger greeted me with enthusiasm. At the time, I was appearing on several economics YouTube channels as a value investor. Each year, I also disclosed my investment holdings in the "Advisor’s Portfolio Analysis" section of an investment guide published by students in my classes. So I occasionally found myself in situations like this. However, what the young man said next came as a shock.
"I saw that you also own shares of Company K, Professor Seo. What should we do? My father trusted the investment seminar during that company’s IPO and invested most of his retirement money in it. Now he’s bedridden and all he ever talks about is how the stress from this investment has made him ill."
For some reason, the young man's story kept replaying in my mind even after I returned home. How upset and angry everyone involved must be. While general shareholders participated in the capital increase at a price 34% higher than the net asset value, controlling shareholders raised their stakes over the following years at prices 7% and 17% lower than the net asset value, behaving abusively. Considering the situation of minority shareholders, such abuse has clearly gone too far. In the 2009 IPO, investors who entrusted large sums of retirement or nest-egg funds to the unlisted Company K, relying solely on the promise that the company would go public "three years later" (with additional trust because its controlling shareholder was a public enterprise), have since been plagued by economic anxiety and family discord. Losses suffered in this case are less the result of poor investment decisions, and more akin to losses due to the company’s mis-selling, so it is unfair to place the blame entirely on these investors. In such circumstances, if someone takes the lead, many shareholders are likely to rally together. For minority shareholders to properly exercise their rights—such as appointing auditors, proposing shareholder resolutions, or requesting access to accounting records—they need to consolidate their shares, which is necessary to improve their chances of success. The more severe the abuse by the controlling shareholder, the more tightly minority shareholders band together, thereby strengthening their collective power.
After deliberating for about ten days, I began buying shares of Company K in the over-the-counter market. I needed a certain level of stake to gain enough influence to take the lead. This marked my first attempt at activist investing in my life.
Public opinion about activist investors is divided. Some criticize activist investors as "self-serving traders seeking to boost stock prices for their own profit." This is not entirely untrue. Activist investing is, after all, a form of investing for profit. I am no exception. My investment in Company K was not solely an act of public service. I believed that if the rights of minority shareholders, long ignored by the controlling shareholder, were properly restored, the value for shareholders would increase and thereby deliver returns on the investment.
However, this is where an interesting paradox arises. If activist investing succeeds, numerous other minority shareholders also benefit. This aligns both with the logic of Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations—that "human self-interest sustains economic development"—and with the tenets of capitalism, whereby "companies, though founded for profit, contribute to the socioeconomic fabric through employment and production." When shareholders push for divestment of unnecessary corporate assets, demand more efficient capital allocation, hold management accountable for illegal acts or mismanagement, and insist on independent audits, such efforts can ultimately increase the company’s value. As a result, not only activist investors but also those who merely observe from the sidelines enjoy the gains from a rising share price. In summary, as individuals pursue their own interests, public benefits are inadvertently produced. Correcting corporate governance and revitalizing the stock market through activist investing likewise serves the public good.
Last summer, an amendment to the Commercial Act focused on "strengthening minority shareholder rights" was finally passed after a long wait. Yet, more than a year on, its impact has fallen short of expectations. Contrary to forecasts, few investors—including asset management firms—have moved assertively into activist investing. If I were still working in asset management, I would likely be busy setting up an activist investment fund and raising capital. However, such activity is rarely seen in the field these days.
No revolution for minority shareholders or sustained stock market revitalization can be achieved solely through amending the law. The law has merely equipped shareholders with the necessary tools. Unless we put these tools to use, nothing will change. For that reason, society’s attitude toward activist investing must also evolve. Activist investors are not the enemy of companies—but neither are they their friend. They are simply shareholders. They invest their money and want the company to be run properly, with rising corporate value. Naturally, they hope to earn a return on their investment in this process.
On September 15, at Company K’s extraordinary general meeting of shareholders, proposals to appoint two audit committee members were rejected. This was only possible because disgruntled minority shareholders managed to consolidate 4.8% of the shareholding. Although this is just the beginning, seeing so many shareholders joining hands to celebrate at the meeting moved me deeply. I resolved to undertake more activist investments in the future. Wherever I find communities of wronged minority shareholders, I will step in and add my strength against controlling shareholder abuses. There is always a risk of significant loss if things go wrong, but a successful outcome brings not only investment gains but also the joy of seeing many people happy. I hope society develops greater understanding and support for activist investors. And I hope their numbers continue to grow.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Seo Joonsik, Professor of Economics at Soongsil University
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.