A Tragedy Born of Good Intentions and Fueled by Silence [Slate]
The Theatrical Film "Chiikawa: The Secret of Mermaid Island"
※ This article contains many potential movie spoilers.
The theatrical film "Chiikawa: The Secret of Mermaid Island" begins with a tempting offer. A flyer that drops from the sky promises 100 times the usual reward for catching a monster. Drawn in by the offer, Chiikawa, Hachiware, and Usagi set off for Mermaid Island.
Director Kei Oikawa conceals a bleak tragedy beneath the film's pastel-toned exterior. The siren the group sets out to catch is not simply a villain. She is a victim who lost her fellow mermaids and became an invader. Hitoha, a resident of the island who hires the group, is the one who killed the mermaids. Neither side has complete moral justification. The same is true of Chiikawa. Even after learning both sides of the story, Chiikawa keeps quiet.
Hitoha's crime stems from her love for a friend. To save Futaba, who had been mortally wounded, Hitoha killed a mermaid and fed her flesh to her. It was an act driven not by greed for immortality but by personal altruism. Yet even good intentions become violence when another's life is used as a means to an end. The siren, too, torments the islanders out of love for her fellow mermaids. Her actions are an expression of anger and grief over an unjust death. As victims become perpetrators and perpetrators become avengers, absolute evil disappears. All that remains are crimes committed in the name of love.
The tragedy takes root in the island's isolation. It echoes Japan's "mura society," which excludes outsiders and prioritizes internal unity. The residents do not question what led to the mermaid's murder and the siren's attacks. Instead of exposing their community's dark secrets, they close ranks in silence. They welcome Chiikawa and his companions from outside the island, then use them as a shield on the front line.
The way this community operates resembles director Ari Aster's horror film "Midsommar." Like a Swedish village that strengthens its unity by sacrificing outsiders behind the bright festivities of the midnight sun, the residents of Mermaid Island deceive Chiikawa and his companions with cheerful faces. There is little sign of guilt. Their solidarity is all the more cruel for being so unyielding despite the absence of malice.
The full story emerges when Chiikawa comes into possession of crucial evidence: a red mermaid scale hidden in curry powder and the AA batteries attached to Futaba's body. In that moment, the kind neighbors appear to Chiikawa as murderers, while the monster destroying the island appears as a bereaved survivor seeking justice for her companion's death. Yet Chiikawa chooses silence. Rather than expose the truth and disrupt the community's stability, Chiikawa lets the siren escape and leaves the island. This is neither compassion nor mature mercy. It is an evasion, a retreat out of fear of responsibility, and an act of complicity in allowing catastrophe to unfold.
There is no particular malice here. It is closer to the "banality of evil" Hannah Arendt described. In her book "Eichmann in Jerusalem," she noted that great evil can arise not from demonic motives but from a failure to think. The islanders, who never question the causes of events, and Chiikawa, who turns away despite witnessing the truth, can be understood in the same context. The absence of malice does not grant absolution.
Responsibility does not rest in one place. Hitoha directly killed a mermaid, the residents covered up the act through their silence, and Chiikawa left despite knowing the truth. Political philosopher Iris Marion Young argued that responsibility for structural injustice is shared by everyone who participates in the structure, rather than resting solely with an individual perpetrator. From this perspective, known as the "social connection model," a bystander is not merely an onlooker but part of the structure.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
"Chiikawa: The Secret of Mermaid Island" asks which of the three parties is more guilty. Private compassion and collective self-interest involve visible acts of violence, making them easy to condemn. Bystanders are less likely to be condemned, but that is precisely why their behavior is more easily repeated. Rather than offering an answer, Director Oikawa keeps the camera on Chiikawa's silence to the very end. The audience that watches that scene is a witness.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.