Prison Sentence of Two Years and Six Months Confirmed
Only Education Program Order Overturned

The Supreme Court has ruled that an individual convicted solely of trading drugs, without actual use, cannot be ordered to complete a drug rehabilitation education program.

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to the legal community on October 6, the Supreme Court Second Division (Presiding Justice Oh Kyungmi) recently overturned part of the original verdict against Mr. A, who had been sentenced to two years and six months in prison, a forfeiture of 500,000 won, and a 40-hour drug rehabilitation education program order for violating the Narcotics Control Act (stimulants). The Supreme Court specifically struck down the education program order while upholding the rest of the ruling.


Mr. A was indicted for allegedly handing over 1.4 grams of methamphetamine to Mr. B inside a car parked on a road in Changwon, Gyeongsangnam-do, at around 9 p.m. on January 12, 2025, and receiving 500,000 won via a bank transfer to a third party’s account as payment. Mr. B, after receiving the methamphetamine, immediately returned it due to the smaller-than-expected quantity, and Mr. A also returned the 500,000 won payment.


Mr. A was also indicted on charges of methamphetamine use between May 10 and June 9, 2025. The prosecution estimated the period of the alleged use based on the detection of methamphetamine in Mr. A’s hair, but left the place and method unspecified in the indictment.


The main issues were whether a drug sale is acknowledged even if Mr. B immediately returned the methamphetamine, and whether Mr. A, who was convicted solely for trading, could be ordered to complete a rehabilitation course. Under the Narcotics Control Act, a person convicted of using, smoking, or ingesting narcotics may be ordered to attend up to 200 hours of an education or rehabilitation program.


The trial court acquitted Mr. A of completed drug trading, convicting him only of attempted trading, and sentenced him to one year and two months in prison, a 40-hour rehabilitation program order, and a forfeiture of 500,000 won. It found that, since Mr. B immediately refused receipt and returned the methamphetamine, full possession had not passed. The indictment for drug use was dismissed for lack of specific details on the time, place, and method.


However, the appellate court found that Mr. A had already received all payment in advance and provided the methamphetamine, and that, since Mr. B could have taken it without interference, the sale was completed at the moment Mr. B received it. The fact that Mr. B returned the methamphetamine was “an event after the completion of the crime.” The appellate court overturned the first-instance verdict on the trading charge and sentenced Mr. A to two years and six months in prison, a 40-hour rehabilitation program order, and forfeiture of 500,000 won. The previous dismissal of the use charge was upheld.



The Supreme Court found no error in the appellate court’s decision to recognize the crime as completed trade. However, it reviewed the education program order ex officio. The panel stated, “A narcotics offender, as defined by law, refers to someone who has used, smoked, or ingested drugs.” It continued, “As the defendant was not convicted for use, smoking, or ingestion of narcotics, he does not qualify as a narcotics offender under the law, and therefore cannot be ordered to complete a program under the Narcotics Control Act.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing