Call for Full Disclosure of Evaluation Criteria, Score Sheets, and Site Verification Materials

While Mokpo National University's request for an injunction to halt the execution of the nomination and recommendation of candidate universities for the new national medical school in Jeonnam-Gwangju was dismissed by the court, a civil society organization in the Mokpo area is urging the full disclosure of evaluation materials, stating, "The court's decision does not constitute recognition of the fairness in the candidate selection process."


On October 2, Mokpo Culture Solidarity issued an emergency statement, saying, "This dismissal must not be interpreted as an exoneration for the administrative authorities" and added, "Citizens still question whether the evaluation process for determining candidate universities for the national medical school was truly fair and transparent."

AI-generated image.

AI-generated image.

View original image

On the same day, the Administrative Division 1 of the Gwangju District Court dismissed Mokpo National University's request for a provisional suspension of the effectiveness of the candidate selection and recommendation process against the Jeonnam-Gwangju Unified Metropolitan City.


The court found it difficult to view the city’s act of recommending candidate universities as an exercise of public authority subject to administrative litigation and also found it difficult to acknowledge any legal interest that would justify suspension of the process. Therefore, this decision did not pertain to the validity or fairness of the evaluation content itself.


Based on this, Mokpo Culture Solidarity reiterated, "The dismissal is a separate issue from a substantive ruling on whether the criteria and evaluation in the recommendation process were fair," and once again emphasized the need to verify the candidate selection process.


In particular, the organization focused on the fact that the final evaluation scores between Suncheon National University and Mokpo National University differed by only 1.3 points.


The Jeonnam-Gwangju Unified Metropolitan City had commissioned the Jeonnam Research Institute to evaluate candidate universities; Suncheon National University received a score of 89.15, while Mokpo National University scored 87.85, resulting in the selection of Suncheon National University as the recommended candidate to the government.


Mokpo Culture Solidarity stated, "It must be clearly disclosed what standards, materials, and verification procedures were involved in arriving at that 1.3-point difference," and further demanded, "Details regarding when the criteria for assessing 'site acquisition certainty' were established and whether they were applied uniformly to both universities must also be released."


The organization also highlighted the point that the candidate decision was made within a short time frame, arguing that the process for selecting the external evaluation body, the composition of evaluators, and even detailed evaluation criteria must be transparently disclosed.


The group called on Mayor Min Hyung-bae of the Jeonnam-Gwangju Unified Metropolitan City to release all relevant evaluation materials as well.


They stated, "What citizens are asking is not merely whether the process to establish a new medical school was undertaken," adding, "What truly matters is whether administrative fairness and trust were maintained throughout the decision-making process for the new medical school."


They consequently urged Mayor Min to disclose the evaluation criteria and score sheets, the materials submitted by both universities, the verification procedures for securing the site, and minutes or records of meetings and decision-making to the public.


The group also called on the Democratic Party of Korea to review the fairness issues raised regarding the candidate selection process.


Mokpo Culture Solidarity asserted, "A national medical school is not just a political achievement for any particular party, but rather a national project directly tied to the right to life for Jeonnam residents and the future of the region," stressing, "Given the ongoing controversy over fairness and ensuing legal disputes, citizens deserve answers not only about the outcome but also about the appropriateness of the process."


Due to the court’s decision to dismiss the case, the request to suspend the effectiveness of the process by which Suncheon National University was recommended as a candidate by the Jeonnam-Gwangju Unified Metropolitan City was not accepted. The court's judgment was based on the legal nature of the recommendation act and the legal interest of the applicant, focusing on the requirements for litigation.


Mokpo Culture Solidarity, however, maintained the position that its demand for disclosure regarding the selection process is a separate matter from the court’s dismissal.


The organization emphasized, "While the court ruled on the procedural threshold for the lawsuit, it is now the administration that must cross the threshold of fairness in front of the public," and continued, "Although Mokpo National University's lawsuit was dismissed, the question, ‘Was the evaluation truly fair?’ posed by citizens, has not been dismissed."



The group concluded, "The answer must not be mere words, but proven with documents and records by Mayor Min Hyung-bae and the Jeonnam-Gwangju Unified Metropolitan City," declaring, "Residents of Mokpo and the southwestern region will continue to raise this issue until the fairness of the selection process is fully verified."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing