[Exclusive] "Promised Premium Discounts"... Three Out of Four Who Agreed to Share Driving Data Received No Discount
Nine Non-life Insurers Obtained 14.52 Million Driving Data Consents from January to August, but Only 3.88 Million Signed Up
10.64 Million Provided Data Without Receiving Discounts
Stronger Consumer Protections Needed for "Safe Driving" Crite
Despite agreeing to provide their driving data to insurance companies in order to receive premium discounts, only 1 in 4 drivers actually ended up enrolling in the discounted insurance plan. This is because, even after agreeing to share driving data, drivers must still meet additional eligibility requirements, such as a minimum safe driving score or mileage criteria. Critics point out that for some insurance companies with particularly stringent enrollment requirements, regulatory improvements are needed to ensure that providing one’s driving data actually leads to receiving a discount.
According to the “Status of UBI (Usage-Based Insurance) Special Contracts” report, which Assemblywoman Kim Hyun-jung’s office obtained from the Financial Supervisory Service on October 5, the nine non-life insurance companies collected a total of 14.52 million consents to provide driving data for UBI special contract enrollment between January and August of this year.
However, only 3.88 million of those actually led to the signing of a UBI special contract, accounting for just 26.7% of the total. The remaining 10.64 million cases involved drivers who agreed to provide their driving data, but did not end up enrolling in the special contract. Effectively, 3 out of every 4 drivers who consented to share their driving information did not receive the premium discount benefit.
Assemblywoman Kim commented, “Three out of four drivers who agreed to provide their driving information after seeing promotional materials about discounted premiums never actually received a discount, but merely handed over their personal driving data.” She further stated, “We need to consider whether the insurance companies are collecting data before fully informing drivers about the discount requirements and the possibility of not qualifying.” She also added, “Financial authorities should examine the gap between the number of drivers who consent versus those who enroll, and move to improve the system, such as ensuring advance notification of eligibility requirements and establishing clear guidelines for destroying the data of non-enrollees.”
UBI special contracts are insurance products where companies collect and analyze information related to driving habits or annual mileage to determine whether the driver operates the vehicle safely, and provide discounts on premiums based on that assessment. While requirements vary by insurer, drivers typically must meet certain standards—such as maintaining a safe driving record or driving within a specified mileage—before receiving a discount on their insurance premiums.
The issue is that, in many cases, agreeing to the use of driving data has not actually resulted in enrollment in the special contract. This gap between consent to provide data and actual enrollment is not unique to this year. Looking at data from 2023 through this year among the four non-life insurers that provided statistics, the number of cases where consent was provided but the driver did not enroll grew from 2.78 million in 2023, to 4.88 million in 2024, and then to 5.84 million in 2025.
There were also significant differences in actual enrollment rates among insurers relative to the number of data consents. The gap was especially pronounced for the connected car mileage special contracts: Company I succeeded in converting 91.0% of consent cases to actual enrollments, while Company E posted a conversion rate of 59.8%. In contrast, Company B’s rate was just 2.5% and Company D’s just 1.4%. The difference between the highest (Company I) and lowest (Company D) conversion rates amounts to a factor of about 65.
Particularly notable is that Company D, after introducing the special contract, managed consent for over 1 year and 4 months through a generalized consent process for all insurance product designs, rather than differentiating between consent for the special contract and broader policy consent, according to the assembly office. This made it unclear whether the customer consented specifically to the safe driving special contract, or merely consented to data provision as part of the generic policy enrollment process.
Company E stated that, instead of obtaining separate consent for the special contract, it collected data through an integrated consent process for its connected car and connected safe driving products in collaboration with manufacturers. This meant that the company broadly acquired driving data through insurance quotes or while providing various connected car services, regardless of whether the customer enrolled in a special contract.
One major reason behind the gap between the number of data consents and actual enrollments is the high threshold for qualifying. Some insurance companies require a minimum safe driving score of 80 points or above to be eligible for a discount. However, in areas with heavy traffic and complex driving conditions, such as downtown Seoul, sudden acceleration or braking is more likely, potentially lowering the driving score and making it harder to qualify.
Industry insiders say that they are considering easing their enrollment requirements to address this issue. For instance, Company E, which has a much lower enrollment rate than its peers, intends to loosen its safe driving score requirement to make it easier for drivers to qualify for the special contract.
However, the insurance industry also contends that, due to the nature of safe driving special contracts, it is difficult to indiscriminately lower the standards for eligibility or discount rates.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
An official at a domestic non-life insurer said, “Safe driving special contracts do not provide a uniform premium discount to all policyholders. Instead, they assess safe driving behavior using metrics such as driving scores and apply differentiated discounts to subscribers deemed to have lower risk. Given loss rates in auto insurance and the current level of premiums, it is difficult to simply lower the eligibility criteria or discount rates.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.