"Legitimate Actions Not Recognized Due to Undermining Election Fairness"

A guilty verdict has been confirmed for members of the University Students Progressive Alliance who, ahead of the 21st general election in 2020, carried out pre-election campaigning and disrupted the campaign activities of Oh Se-hoon, then the United Future Party candidate, with the aim of causing his defeat.

Students from the Progressive Student Alliance holding a picket around Oh Se-hoon, the United Future Party candidate, during the 21st general election in 2020. Yonhap News Agency

Students from the Progressive Student Alliance holding a picket around Oh Se-hoon, the United Future Party candidate, during the 21st general election in 2020. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to the legal community on October 2, the Third Division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Eom Sang-pil) recently dismissed all appeals by 16 members of the University Students Progressive Alliance, who had been indicted for violating the Public Official Election Act, thereby upholding the lower court's ruling.


The members of the alliance were charged with using pickets, banners, and other means to campaign before the official campaign period, with the intent of causing the defeat of candidate Oh, who was running in the Gwangjin B district of Seoul for the 21st general election. They displayed allegations on pickets that Oh had provided money and goods to apartment security guards and cleaners during the holidays.


Some of these members were also charged with surrounding Oh for about 20 minutes on the morning of March 23, 2020, in the concourse of a subway station in Gwangjin-gu, Seoul, holding pickets, shouting, and arguing with the candidate's campaign staff, thereby disrupting his campaign activities. Prosecutors viewed these actions as pre-election campaigning and an obstruction to the freedom of election by improper means, as defined under the Public Official Election Act.


The first trial found most of the defendants guilty and imposed fines ranging from 1 million to 6 million won. The second trial also determined that the members' actions were mainly aimed at urging voters not to elect a particular candidate, posed a risk of undermining the fairness of the election or causing excessive agitation, and thus could not be regarded as legitimate actions. However, for one member, the court found it difficult to conclude that the individual had participated in the election disruption and pre-election campaigning at the subway station, and therefore acquitted that portion of the charges, lowering the sentence to a 1 million won fine suspended for one year.


For another member, although the guilty verdict was maintained, the court considered the passive level of involvement, the fact that the person was a university freshman at the time, and the absence of a prior criminal record, and thus suspended the imposition of a 2.5 million won fine. The appeals by the remaining defendants and by the prosecutor were dismissed.



The Supreme Court also found no fault with the lower court's judgement. The court stated, "There is no error in the original judgment in that it does not violate the principles of logic and experience, goes beyond the limits of free evaluation of evidence, or misapplies the legal principles relating to legitimate acts that do not contravene social norms and thus affected the outcome of the ruling."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing