Analysis of Six FTAs including the US and Australia

Annual Damages 27.7 Billion Won Higher than Initial Predictions


On CPTPP Accession, "Effective Measures Needed That Reflect Farmer and Fisher Feedback"

The post-impact assessment for six FTAs that included compensation measures for damages to the agricultural and fisheries sectors estimated the average annual damage at 832.8 billion won. This figure is 27.7 billion won higher than the government's initial prediction of 805.1 billion won made before the agreements were signed.


Suh Samsok, Chairperson of the National Assembly’s Agriculture, Food, Rural Affairs, Oceans and Fisheries Committee and a member of the Democratic Party (Yeongam, Muan, Shinan), revealed these findings based on an analysis of materials submitted by the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy. He urged a review of the FTA damage prediction system and improvements to farmer and fisher support measures.

Sangseok Seo, Member of the National Assembly.

Sangseok Seo, Member of the National Assembly.

View original image

The analysis covered FTAs concluded with the United States, Australia, Canada, China, Vietnam, and New Zealand, for which agricultural and fisheries damage compensation measures have been established since 2010. According to the post-impact assessment, the total damage amounted to 802.1 billion won for the agriculture and livestock sector, and 30.7 billion won for the fisheries sector.


By agreement, the average annual damage from the Korea-United States FTA reached 703.7 billion won, 22.5 billion won higher than the forecasted 681.2 billion won. The Korea-Australia FTA also saw annual damage rise by 4.3 billion won compared to initial estimates.


Representative Suh stressed the need to review the differences between preliminary and post-impact assessments of existing FTAs and to develop compensation measures that reflect the realities faced by farmers and fishers, especially as the government discusses joining the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP).


The level of market liberalization is also a key issue. According to the Ministry of Oceans and Fisheries, the average fisheries product market liberalization rate among the 12 CPTPP member countries stands at 99.4% based on the number of items—higher than Korea’s average fisheries market liberalization rate of 87.8% under its existing FTAs. This refers to the liberalization rate for fisheries products specifically, not for the agricultural and fisheries sector as a whole.


On September 28, the government announced provisional results of its economic impact analysis on joining the CPTPP. The government stated that the analysis is based on economic models and that the actual impact could vary depending on the outcomes of accession negotiations. It planned to gather feedback from various stakeholders through briefings and meetings.



Representative Suh expressed his position that inadequate damage predictions should not be allowed to compromise food sovereignty or the agricultural and fisheries sectors. He emphasized, “The FTA damage prediction system must be thoroughly reviewed, and farmer and fisher feedback should be strengthened in order to develop practical and effective measures.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing