Security Budget at 40.6 Billion Won This Year
Less Than Half of KB Kookmin Bank’s Allocation
Five-Year Average at 41.4 Billion Won
Lowest Proportion Among Major Banks
Experts: "Management Must See Security as an Essential Investment"

The information security budget of Shinhan Bank, which experienced a customer data breach affecting approximately 25,000 individuals, has been the lowest among the five major commercial banks for each of the past five years. The proportion of the information security budget within the total IT budget was also consistently the lowest among the five banks during the same period. As cyber attack methods become increasingly sophisticated with advancements in artificial intelligence (AI), there are growing calls for top management to view information security not as a mere cost but as an essential investment, and to proactively strengthen security capabilities.



[Exclusive] Shinhan Bank’s Security Investment Budget Lowest Among Top 5 Banks [Growing Financial Security Threats] ① View original image

According to data submitted by Assemblyman Kim Jaeseop of the People Power Party, a member of the National Assembly’s Political Affairs Committee, and provided by the Financial Supervisory Service on October 2, Shinhan Bank allocated KRW 40.591 billion for its information security budget this year, ranking last among the five major banks (KB Kookmin, Shinhan, Hana, Woori, NH Nonghyup).


KB Kookmin Bank’s budget was KRW 86.075 billion—more than double that of Shinhan Bank. Nonghyup Bank followed with KRW 80.134 billion, then Hana Bank at KRW 63.635 billion, and Woori Bank at KRW 61.566 billion. Shinhan Bank’s budget was about KRW 21 billion less than Woori Bank, reaching only around 66% of Woori Bank’s level.


This gap is not unique to this year. Shinhan Bank’s information security budget has been the lowest among the five major banks for all five years included in the data, from 2022 through this year. On a five-year average basis, Shinhan Bank’s annual information security budget was only KRW 41.414 billion. By comparison, Nonghyup Bank averaged KRW 73.25 billion, KB Kookmin Bank KRW 69.499 billion, Woori Bank KRW 61.426 billion, and Hana Bank KRW 56.812 billion. Each of these banks allocated, on average, KRW 15.4 to 31.8 billion more per year than Shinhan Bank.


[Exclusive] Shinhan Bank’s Security Investment Budget Lowest Among Top 5 Banks [Growing Financial Security Threats] ① View original image

A similar trend appears when considering the proportion of the information security budget relative to each bank’s total IT budget. Shinhan Bank’s information security budget as a share of its IT budget increased overall from 7.4% in 2022 to 8.6% in 2023, 8.5% in 2024, 10.0% in 2025, and 9.1% this year. However, in all five years, Shinhan Bank ranked the lowest among the five major banks. Over the past five years, Shinhan’s average was just 8.7%. In comparison, Nonghyup Bank recorded 11.4%, Woori Bank 11.0%, Hana Bank 10.4%, and KB Kookmin Bank 10.1%, all surpassing Shinhan Bank with double-digit figures. According to a 2024 survey by IANS and Atico Search, companies in the United States, Canada, and elsewhere on average allocated 13.2% of their IT budgets to information security. While a direct comparison is limited by industry differences, all five major banks fell short of this figure, with Shinhan Bank in particular standing at only 8.5% that year, reflecting the widest gap.


[Exclusive] Shinhan Bank’s Security Investment Budget Lowest Among Top 5 Banks [Growing Financial Security Threats] ① View original image

The relatively low information security budget at Shinhan Bank has prompted calls for the executive team to prioritize security investment. Jung Sanghyuk, who has led Shinhan Bank since 2023, was previously the head of the Management Planning Group, serving as both Chief Financial Officer (CFO) and Chief Strategy Officer (CSO), overseeing finance and strategy. Because information security is an area where it is difficult to demonstrate short-term returns, experts stress the importance of top management viewing it not as a simple expenditure, but as a long-term risk management investment.


Particularly recently, as an unauthorized external party gained illegal access to Shinhan Bank’s simplified loan broker inquiry service, resulting in the leak of personal and credit information for approximately 25,000 customers, the need to examine the security system and internal controls has grown. The compromised data included customer names, phone numbers, annual income, and calculated loan limits. In addition, the resident registration numbers of 66 customers and 97 cases of connected information (CI) were leaked. The Financial Supervisory Service is currently conducting an on-site inspection of Shinhan Bank to determine the circumstances of the incident and evaluate the actual state of internal controls.


Assemblyman Kim stated, “Financial institutions should not stop at merely introducing countermeasures after incidents occur; rather, they must proactively expand their information security budgets and professional staffing to establish systems that prevent personal data leaks and IT-related accidents in advance.”


Experts advise that, as cyber attacks employing AI become more advanced, simply increasing the budget is not enough; banks must also expand professional staffing and enhance both preventive and detection capabilities. Seo Ji-Yong, a professor of business administration at Sangmyung University, said, “Financial institutions must shift their information security systems to focus on prevention rather than post-incident response. In addition to recruiting more professionals, they need to strengthen management of access rights and contractors, continuous detection of abnormal signs, and regular simulation-based hacking tests.”



There are also recommendations that, to ensure security investment leads to tangible improvements in preventive capabilities, executive leadership should strengthen their responsibilities and roles. Chae Sangmi, professor at Ewha Womans University’s School of Business, said, “To improve the quality of the information security system, the board of directors and C-level management must provide unwavering support and a high level of understanding. When incidents occur, there must be a system in place to hold not just working-level staff but also the CEO or responsible executives truly accountable, and if necessary, implement a clawback policy requiring the return of incentive pay.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing