Experts: "Announcing First, Then Setting Negotiation Baselines"

Practical Responses Needed in Follow-up Negotiations

Consideration of Tariff Exemptions and Joint Investment Proposals

South Korea and the United States have finalized the construction of a gas combined cycle power plant in Texas, with a total project budget of 22.3 billion dollars, as the first major Korean investment in the U.S. The two countries also reached a broad agreement on the potential construction of eight large nuclear power plants in the U.S., with a maximum estimated value of up to 120 billion dollars. However, an ongoing controversy has emerged after U.S. President Donald Trump officially designated the Alaska liquefied natural gas (LNG) development project as an investment target, despite the fact that the two countries only cited it at the review initiation stage in the official agreement documents.


Experts have pointed out that President Trump’s announcement was made unilaterally, without sufficient consultation with the South Korean government. Nevertheless, they emphasized the importance of securing as many opportunities as possible for domestic companies to participate and clear investment terms for Korean firms through future follow-up negotiations.


In a phone interview with The Asia Business Daily on the 1st, Chung In-kyo, former Director-General for Trade Negotiations at the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, said, "The only project that South Korea agreed to in any form was the gas combined cycle power plant construction, and the rest were unilateral announcements," adding, "Such actions are unreasonable and controversy is inevitable."


There is also analysis that President Trump’s approach of making announcements first and setting negotiation baselines is not unusual. Shin Won-gyu, Senior Research Fellow at the Korea Economic Research Institute, said, "Even in the recent U.S.-China summit, President Trump actively highlighted agreed-upon issues as his own negotiation achievements," and stressed, "Instead of overreacting to the announcement itself, what matters now is the direction and outcome of ongoing negotiations."


The announcement is also seen as being influenced by political pressure on President Trump to highlight economic achievements ahead of the November midterm elections. Amid rising energy price burdens due to the recent Iran crisis and increases in global oil prices, there is a growing concern within the U.S. over the burgeoning electricity demand driven by the expansion of the artificial intelligence (AI) industry and the resulting shortages in power grid infrastructure. Consequently, U.S. industrial policy is rapidly shifting from the traditional focus on manufacturing renaissance to an emphasis on expanding the electricity grid, data centers, and energy infrastructure.


President Lee Jae-myung, who is visiting the United States to attend the United Nations General Assembly, is having a summit meeting with U.S. President Donald Trump at a hotel in New York on the 22nd of last month (local time). Yonhap News.

President Lee Jae-myung, who is visiting the United States to attend the United Nations General Assembly, is having a summit meeting with U.S. President Donald Trump at a hotel in New York on the 22nd of last month (local time). Yonhap News.

View original image

From South Korea’s perspective, the commercial viability of U.S.-bound investments remains a crucial standard. For the U.S., however, there is a strong incentive to secure Korean investment resources to expand infrastructure such as the electric grid, LNG, and nuclear power—sectors where it is difficult for private companies to make large investments solely based on profitability.


Experts recommended that, rather than accepting the U.S. announcements at face value under these circumstances, South Korean negotiators should focus on securing tangible interests in follow-up talks. Shin emphasized, "Amid President Trump’s urgency before the midterm elections, Korea should highlight the public nature of energy sector investments and the exceptional nature of Korea-U.S. cooperation, using this as an opportunity to further expand into U.S. markets—particularly for industries weakened by Chinese overproduction, such as steel, petrochemicals, and energy. Follow-up negotiations should aim to secure tariff exemptions for intermediate goods and equipment. A strategy maximizing profits must be developed given the current environment."


Specifically, proposals being discussed include applying tariff exemptions or tariff-rate quotas (TRQ) for Korean-made steel, petrochemical materials, power equipment, and nuclear power plant parts used by Korean companies participating in U.S. energy projects, or temporarily waiving tariffs for the duration of local investment implementation periods.



Some have also argued that there should be efforts to renegotiate the detailed business structures as cooperation on investments moves forward. Kim Tae-hwang, Professor of International Trade at Myongji University, said, "In the case of the Alaska LNG project, rather than Korea investing alone, Korea could suggest joint investments with countries like Japan or adjustments to the investment amount. For projects other than the Texas power plant, Korea could also pursue a negotiation strategy aimed at buying time for detailed talks after the midterm elections."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing