"Referring Investment Reconsideration to the Board
Is Not Outside the Agreement"

The court ruled in favor of Chairman Shin Dongguk of Hanyang Precision in a lawsuit filed by Song Youngsook, Chairwoman of Hanmi Pharmaceutical Group, who sought to claim a penalty of over 60 billion won from Chairman Shin for alleged breach of a shareholder agreement among a "four-party alliance."

Hanmi Pharmaceutical

Hanmi Pharmaceutical

View original image

On October 1, the Civil Settlement Division 30 of the Seoul Central District Court (Presiding Judge Kim Seok-beom) dismissed all claims brought by Chairwoman Song, Im Joohyun, Vice Chairman of Hanmi Science, and Killington Ltd. against Chairman Shin for penalty payments. The plaintiffs were also ordered to bear the litigation costs. Killington is a special purpose vehicle operated by the private equity firm La Defense Partners.


The court stated, "Referring the investment reconsideration to the board of directors for a final decision cannot be regarded as acting outside the agreement between the plaintiffs and the defendant."


The court also did not recognize liability for penalty payments due to the failure of the agenda. It concluded there is no evidence that the parties reached any agreement beyond submitting the investment to the board for a vote to the point of an actual investment agreement.


Chairwoman Song, Vice Chairman Im, Chairman Shin, and La Defense formed a four-party alliance in July 2024 to counter the interests of brothers Lim Jongyun and Lim Jonghoon. They agreed to exercise voting rights jointly and to decide on major management issues together. The agreement stipulated a penalty of 60 billion won in case of breach.



The conflict arose over the senior care business in Banpo-dong, Seocho-gu, Seoul. The mother-daughter party alleged that Chairman Shin initially agreed to advance the project but changed his stance in June 2025, leading to a reversal of the board resolution. The lawsuit was filed in September the same year, claiming a breach of the agreement for joint exercise of voting rights. In contrast, Chairman Shin's side argued the project fell through due to pressure from Meritz Securities.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing