The Trump Administration's "forced labor tariffs," which target 60 economic zones including Korea, are now being tested in a U.S. court. The U.S. Court of International Trade (CIT) intensely scrutinized whether Section 301 of the trade law could be broadly applied to impose widespread tariffs for failing to block imports of goods made with forced labor, and whether sufficient justification was provided for each country involved.

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to Bloomberg News on September 30 (local time), the three-judge panel questioned Jamieson Greer, representative of the U.S. Trade Representative (USTR), during the hearing about whether he had properly followed the legal frameworks set out decades ago by Congress. The panel also raised issues over whether there were concrete grounds and analyses presented to justify imposing tariffs on individual countries. However, the judges did not agree with the arguments made by the plaintiffs, who included small businesses and Democratic state governments. The plaintiffs argued that these Section 301 tariffs were an indirect way to reinstate global tariffs that had previously been invalidated by the Supreme Court, but the judges expressed skepticism about this claim.


First, Judge Timothy Stanceu repeatedly pressed Greer during the hearing, via the Department of Justice, to specify which legal provisions authorized him to impose the tariffs. When the Justice Department responded that neither of the two provisions defining "unfair" acts by trading partners had been used as a basis, Stanceu pointed out, according to Bloomberg, that this amounted to disregarding the trade law framework established by Congress. Eric Hamilton, an attorney for the Department of Justice, countered that the administration interpreted the structure of the law differently and had imposed tariffs based on a separate provision that granted Greer broad discretionary authority.


The judges also closely examined whether there was sufficient country-specific evidence and analysis to support the determination that these countries had failed to block forced labor imports and that this had resulted in harm to the U.S. economy. Judge Jennifer Choe-Groves pointed out that the administration's evidence connecting certain goods to forced labor was not sufficiently specific.


Plaintiff attorney Pratik Shah argued that Greer's report only stated that the practices of various countries "could" harm the United States, without making any concrete determinations regarding actual harm. In response, the Justice Department insisted that even just a few cases were sufficient to explain the underlying economic principles that would apply across all the affected economic zones.

Section 301 Forced Labor Tariff Also Challenged? U.S. Trade Court Questions Trump Administration's Justification View original image

The judges also asked Shah whether the public statements of President Trump and high-level officials could support the argument that the Section 301 tariffs acted as an indirect means to revive tariffs nullified by the Supreme Court. Shah maintained that there were indications the forced labor issue was merely a pretext for imposing tariffs. As an example, he argued that while the administration cited imports of Brazilian beef as a "case" related to forced labor in China, Brazilian beef itself was excluded from the actual tariff list.


The panel further questioned to what extent public statements by Trump and top officials could be taken into account, given that Greer had provided separate substantive grounds for imposing the tariffs. Judge Lisa Wang asked, "So what does that mean?" In response, Shah replied that, while such statements alone might not be enough to invalidate the tariffs, they nevertheless supported the plaintiffs' argument that the administration had failed to provide sufficient justification to legitimize the tariffs.


The tariff policy under review was implemented by the Trump Administration, which counted the 27 member states of the European Union (EU) as a single economic entity, resulting in tariffs of 10% or 12.5% on goods from 60 economic zones across a total of 86 countries. Court documents show that imports from these economic zones accounted for 99.4% of total U.S. imports. Specific goods from Korea faced a 12.5% tariff.



Before imposing these Section 301 forced labor tariffs, the Trump Administration twice attempted to implement tariffs on other legal grounds. Tariffs based on emergency authority were invalidated by the Supreme Court earlier this year. Another temporary set of tariffs was blocked by the Court of International Trade in May, yet the Court of Appeals allowed them to remain in effect during litigation. The Trump Administration introduced the Section 301 tariffs when those temporary tariffs expired. Since the beginning of his second administration, President Donald Trump has used tariffs both as a means to revive U.S. manufacturing and to pressure trading partners, as well as to expand federal revenue. However, these tariff policies have encountered successive legal challenges.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing