10-year Bond Yields Surge to 4.8%

Largest Increase Among G7 Since Iran Conflict

Presidential Election and Fiscal Deficit Concerns Loom for Next Year

Vanguard, one of the world’s largest asset management firms, has warned that France’s national credit rating is deteriorating and that government bond yields may rise further. Analysts now view France, saddled with massive fiscal deficits and mounting political instability, as an emerging epicenter of fiscal anxiety in Europe.


On the 28th (local time), French President Emmanuel Macron had an audience with the Pope. Photo by AP Yonhap News

On the 28th (local time), French President Emmanuel Macron had an audience with the Pope. Photo by AP Yonhap News

View original image

According to the Financial Times (FT) on September 30 (local time), Ales Koutny, Head of International Rates at Vanguard, which manages $12 trillion (approximately KRW 16,230 trillion) in assets, described France as “a country whose credit quality is worsening over the long term” and issued this warning.


He pointed out that if France's fiscal situation deteriorates further, the spread between French and German government bond yields could widen to more than 1.5 percentage points. Currently, Vanguard maintains a French government bond weighting below its benchmark level.


France's 10-year government bond yield surged from 3.2% during the outbreak of the Iran war in February to over 4.8% at the end of September, reaching its highest level since 2008. This marks the largest increase among the Group of Seven (G7) countries during the period. The yield spread with German government bonds also surpassed 1.1 percentage points this month, the widest gap since 2012.


More notably, France's borrowing costs are now roughly 0.2 percentage points higher than those of Italy, which was at the center of the past European fiscal crisis. This is the highest differential since comparable statistics began in the 1990s. Recently, yields on French government bonds of similar maturities have even surpassed those of corporate bonds issued by domestic firms like LVMH.


Market skepticism is growing over the French government’s ability to cut its fiscal deficit. The government has projected this year’s deficit at 5.5% of gross domestic product (GDP), exceeding its original 5% target. As economic growth slows, prospects for fiscal reform are further diminishing.


Political instability is adding to the pressure. French Prime Minister Sebastien Lecornu has included EUR 54 billion worth of spending cuts in next year’s budget proposal, but its passage through the opposition-controlled parliament remains uncertain. With a presidential election scheduled for April next year, analysts note that opposition candidates have little incentive to support austerity measures.


Investor anxiety intensified after far-left presidential candidate Jean-Luc Melenchon suggested that portions of French national debt held by the central bank could effectively be forgiven. Koutny warned that if parties roll out fiscal expansion pledges ahead of the election, France’s credit outlook could further deteriorate.


Indeed, France’s sovereign credit rating was recently downgraded. In early September, credit rating agency Scope cut France’s national rating from ‘AA-’ to ‘A+’. Scope cited high fiscal deficits, increased interest expenses, and rising public debt as reasons for the downgrade.


Amid these developments, the French Treasury plans to issue a net amount of EUR 340 billion in medium- and long-term government bonds next year, excluding redemptions. This is a record issuance, up about 10% from this year. Interest expenses are expected to reach EUR 72.9 billion.



However, the FT reported that some investors now view the recent decline in French government bond prices as excessive and are moving to buy at lower prices. HSBC analyzed that, by either comparison with other eurozone countries or based on France’s debt ratio, these bonds are currently the most undervalued since 2008.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing