Repeated Sanctions by Fair Trade Commission Against NongHyup Distribution

Time to Overhaul Supplier Transaction Practices

Public Disclosure of Exclusive Contracts—Evaluation and Sanctions Essential

Private contracts with specific companies and inflated construction costs.


These are among the corruption allegations submitted to an anonymous tip center for Nonghyup-related matters, which the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs has operated since November last year. Other tips allege that suppliers delivered agricultural products to cooperatives under family members' names or supplied substandard goods, causing demand to plunge. More than 1,000 tips have poured in over 10 months. The right to select suppliers for the goods that fill Hanaro Mart stores nationwide, including agricultural products, gives Nonghyup tremendous power to make or break suppliers. The abuse of that power has been repeated, leading to allegations of kickbacks.


Experts say that, to prevent repeated allegations of unfair transactions in Nonghyup's purchasing, supply, and construction contracting processes, the first step in reforming Nonghyup should be to change its closed business practices.


Customers are shopping on the 22nd at Yangjae Hanaro Mart in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Jinhyung Kang aymsdream@

Customers are shopping on the 22nd at Yangjae Hanaro Mart in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Jinhyung Kang aymsdream@

View original image

Building a Competitive System

According to the distribution industry on October 2, Nonghyup Distribution purchases agricultural products from NH Economic Holdings and supplies them to Hanaro Mart, while holding purchasing rights for livestock and seafood. Hanwoo is distributed through three channels. Apart from whole-carcass sets of Hanwoo, covering every cut, purchased through auctions at livestock product wholesale markets, the other distribution channels leave room for vested interests to intervene.


For custom slaughtering (non-auction sales), Nonghyup Distribution's merchandise managers and store managers decide in advance on the slaughter volume and slaughterhouse through consultations. For portioned meat, Nonghyup Distribution has Hanwoo purchased at auction processed on a contract basis by partner companies with direct-purchase agreements, then receives the products back. For seafood, Nonghyup Distribution obtains quotes for live fish from multiple suppliers and purchases them from the selected suppliers, while chilled fish is sourced from companies with direct-purchase agreements.


Because both the head of the National Agricultural Cooperative Federation and the heads of individual cooperatives are elected, allegations of corruption involving favors for election support and the recouping of campaign costs have repeatedly surfaced. In fact, tips submitted to the anonymous tip center and forwarded to the Ministry of Agriculture by Lee Jae-kwan, a Democratic Party of Korea lawmaker, included allegations that cooperative heads purchased high-priced assets and pursued reckless projects for personal gain or to repay election support. The tips also included allegations of providing money and valuables related to elections, privatizing personnel and budget decisions, and causing losses to cooperatives through new investments in Hanaro Mart and the construction of new business facilities.


Opaque private contracts have also been uncovered in audits. One regional cooperative awarded a private contract for the construction of a curing facility, with an estimated price of KRW 235 million, exceeding the KRW 200 million threshold for private contracts. It also failed to obtain any quotes for an external audit contract worth KRW 10 million. At NH Economic Holdings, auditors also found that goods contracts were handled as private contracts despite there being no grounds for doing so.

[The World of Kickback Schemes]⑤The Pitfalls of Exclusive Contracts...Time to Reform Closed Trading Practices View original image

For these reasons, advice for Nonghyup's distribution businesses is to prioritize creating a structure that allows market competition to function properly when selecting products and suppliers. Choi Byung-ok, a research fellow at the Korea Rural Economic Institute (KREI), said, "The bigger problem is that the structure leaves room for sales to be driven by influential regional cooperatives, rather than managing suppliers based on their competitiveness. What matters is creating a system driven by competition, not deciding who holds the purchasing rights." Choi added, "Moving the purchasing rights alone will not make the business more competitive if the closed structure, which does not operate according to market competition, remains unchanged." 

Disclose Private Contracts... and Ensure Review and Sanctions

Some have also called for a system to compare external quotes and construction and delivery terms, and to examine why contracts are repeatedly awarded to the same company, even when private contracts are used. Cho Chun-han, a professor at Gyeonggi University of Science and Technology, said, "It should not be enough simply to disclose the reason for a contract. Transparency can only be ensured if prices, quality, and repeat contracts are reviewed after the contract is awarded, and problems lead to actual restrictions on future contracts." The point is that, rather than relying on formal procedures for preparing statements of reasons for contracts, Nonghyup should evaluate the results of deliveries and construction work and reflect those evaluations in subsequent contracts.


It is also worth considering the measures to improve private contracting that the Anti-Corruption and Civil Rights Commission recommended to public institutions. In December last year, the commission recommended that 331 public institutions disclose the reasons for private contracts in advance, expand the disclosure of contract information, and restrict repeated private contracts with the same company. The recommendations included setting limits on the number and cumulative value of contracts with the same company and requiring institutions to provide reasons when exceptions are unavoidable. Nonghyup should also review the number and value of contracts awarded to each company to check whether work is being concentrated among specific suppliers.

[The World of Kickback Schemes]⑤The Pitfalls of Exclusive Contracts...Time to Reform Closed Trading Practices View original image

Establish an Independent Audit Body

With the abuse of suppliers continuing, some have also called for an independent body to monitor such conduct. In August, the Fair Trade Commission imposed a fine of KRW 462 million on Nonghyup Hanaro Distribution. The company used promotional staff from suppliers without prior agreements and received store-entry incentives by treating 187 products that had been on the market for more than six months as "new products." 


Earlier, in 2020, the Fair Trade Commission imposed total fines of KRW 780 million on Nonghyup Distribution and Nonghyup Hanaro Distribution. Nonghyup Distribution failed to comply with procedures for providing contracts and using supplier employees. Nonghyup Hanaro Distribution received approximately KRW 2.212 billion from 77 suppliers under the name of "performance incentives." In 2019, Nonghyup Distribution was found to have returned approximately KRW 120.65 million worth of frozen seafood to 18 suppliers without justifiable reasons. It was also found to have generated approximately KRW 323.4 million in false sales at its Yangjae store and then received approximately KRW 3.23 million from suppliers, equivalent to 1% of that amount. Similar violations involving the provision of contracts and the use of supplier staff were uncovered again, despite promises to improve.


Lee Jae-kwan said, "The fact that around 1,000 tips poured in over a period of less than a year shows just how serious corruption is across the Nonghyup organization. It is time to establish an independent audit body and transform the organization into one that serves farmers."


Leverage Strengths at the Source and Tailor Strategies to Each Store

Some have also said that store operations and product assortments need to be reviewed alongside changes to business practices. Rather than operating every store in the same way, investment and marketing should be tailored to each store's trade area and conditions. Seo Sang-yoon, a professor at Kyungnam University, explained, "The factors that determine performance vary according to each store's characteristics, such as its floor space, parking conditions, and marketing. Strategies tailored to each store and its trade area are needed, rather than a one-size-fits-all approach."


Fresh food is seen as central to product strategy. Rather than competing with general retailers using similar product assortments, Nonghyup should leverage its nationwide network of agricultural producers to build its own competitive advantage, analysts say. Lee Sang-yeol, a professor at the Korea National University of Agriculture and Fisheries, said, "Our analysis of the competitive relationship between Hanaro Mart and corporate-owned supermarkets (SSMs) found that successful groups have a high share of sales from agricultural, fishery, and livestock products. Hanaro Mart's distinctive competitive strength also lies in agricultural, livestock, and fishery products."



To turn the strengths of its producer network into sales, Nonghyup must also overhaul its logistics and online sales systems. In addition to securing high-quality products, it needs to improve its distribution network so consumers can conveniently purchase and receive deliveries. Kim Sung-woo, a research fellow at KREI, said, "A transition to, and improvements in, a structure that can support expanding online distribution channels are needed." Choi said, "Unviable businesses should be wound down, and distribution, logistics, and sales systems should be rebuilt around agricultural products that Nonghyup is inherently well placed to handle, especially fresh produce. A specialized, integrated supply chain for fresh produce should be established, linking producers at the source to consumers' retail outlets through small-portion packaging and logistics centers."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing