Key Health Features Restricted to Users Aged 22 and Older

Sleep Apnea Detection Unavailable During Pregnancy

Aligned with US FDA Clinical Age Standards

In Mok-dong, Seoul, Soo-hyung Kim gifted his 17-year-old son Samsung Electronics' "Galaxy Watch9" for Chuseok. His son enjoys running and frequently rides his bike, so the wide range of health features made it seem more suitable than a regular watch. While reading the manual to learn more about the features, Kim came across an unexpected notice: although the Galaxy Watch9 offers various useful health check functions, such as sleep apnea detection, there was a statement indicating it is "only available to users aged 22 and older." When users under 22 attempt to use these functions, restrictions and warning messages appear. Kim, who had often seen teenagers around him using smartwatches instead of smartphones, found himself curious about this age restriction mentioned in the manual, and felt a bit uneasy, wondering if there might be safety concerns for teenage users.


Smartwatch Gifted for Chuseok, Why Can't Users Under 22 Use It? [Why&Next] View original image

The reason why the Galaxy Watch9 imposes an age restriction for users under 22 is due to the criteria for clinical trials and performance verification. When these features were developed as software as a medical device (SaMD), all clinical trials and performance evaluations were conducted only with adult participants aged 22 and older. Because there is a lack of clinical data for users under 22, and it is challenging to officially guarantee the same level of accuracy, Samsung has restricted these features for people under the age of 22.


A Samsung Electronics official stated, "The applications (apps) for measuring blood pressure and electrocardiogram (ECG) on Samsung Health Monitor must be approved by regulatory agencies such as the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), and for such approval, the clinical trial participants are adults aged 22 and older," adding, "This age standard is based on U.S. medical device guidelines and corresponding clinical trial protocols, which is in line with global standards."


According to the U.S. FDA and other global health authorities, the minimum clinical age standard for approving over-the-counter (OTC) medical apps is 22. In addition, algorithms and sensor measurement values designed for adults may be somewhat inaccurate for minors, so they are excluded from use for safety reasons.


Various health features equipped in the Galaxy Watch9. Photo by Sojeong Seo.

Various health features equipped in the Galaxy Watch9. Photo by Sojeong Seo.

View original image

In particular, the arrhythmia and sleep apnea-related conditions detected by the Galaxy Watch are most common among adults and high-risk age groups. Samsung Electronics received approval from both the U.S. FDA and the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS) of South Korea in 2023 for its irregular heart rhythm notification, which detects potential atrial fibrillation. However, the sleep apnea detection feature of the Galaxy Watch9 is currently only available in certain countries, and it is also advised that users who are pregnant or have previously been diagnosed with sleep apnea refrain from using this function.


An MFDS official stated, "Samsung Electronics reflected the restriction for users under age 22 in the user precautions to obtain domestic approval for the device," adding, "Samsung is not currently pursuing procedures to lower the minimum user age."



Some point out that warnings should be strengthened for pregnant users who require additional caution. Jiyeon Park, a pregnant woman in her 30s, commented, "I had no idea there was a restriction on using the Galaxy Watch9 during pregnancy," adding, "Even if it is harmless to the human body, there could still be effects, so I think the information should be made clearer." A Samsung Electronics official explained, "Bioelectrical impedance analysis passes a microcurrent between the fingers and the watch during body composition measurement and, while this current is harmless to the human body, because even minimal risks could affect pregnant women, we recommend not using this measurement to guard against any unlikely risks."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing