[The World of Back Margin] ④Suspicion of Split Contracts at Nonghyup Distribution
Allegations Filed Through Nonghyup’s Anonymous Tip Line ‘Red Whistle’
Increase in Privately Awarded Projects After CEO Donggeun Lee’s Appointment
Separate Con

Lee Donggeun, CEO of Nonghyup Distribution (59), is reportedly under a special audit over allegations that he received kickbacks through renovation work at Hanaro Mart stores nationwide and used the money to travel overseas. The number of store construction projects nearly doubled in the year after he took office. Records also show that large-scale renovation projects were split into smaller contracts and that work was commissioned again at similar facilities. After allegations of purchasing irregularities involving Nonghyup Distribution’s MDs (merchandisers), the company’s top executives have also become embroiled in a kickback controversy, prompting calls for thorough oversight of what critics say is systematic moral hazard.


According to documents obtained on the 1st through the office of Lee Jaegwan, a Democratic Party of Korea lawmaker on the National Assembly’s Agriculture, Food, Rural Affairs, Oceans and Fisheries Committee, a report alleging violations of the code of conduct by three employees, including Lee, was filed with the internal anonymous whistleblowing system “Red Whistle” on June 23. The report was titled “Overseas Travel Using Improperly Obtained Funds.”


Donggeun Lee, CEO of Nonghyup Distribution, provided by Nonghyup Distribution.

Donggeun Lee, CEO of Nonghyup Distribution, provided by Nonghyup Distribution.

View original image

The report alleged that they financed trips to Mongolia and Japan unrelated to work by arranging unnecessary construction projects and other work. In particular, it claimed that they traveled to Mongolia from June 19 to 22 under the pretext of a business trip. The whistleblower said the information had come from a colleague and could be verified through individual interviews and expense records.


The report was referred to Nonghyup Distribution’s compliance support team on June 30, after passing through the risk management team of Nonghyup Economic Holdings. Nonghyup Distribution’s audit office began an on-site investigation on July 8. After finding some issues during the investigation, it escalated the matter to a special audit on the 21st of that month. An official from the National Agricultural Cooperative Federation said, “This matter was referred to Nonghyup Distribution’s compliance department via the federation’s compliance support department and the risk management team of Nonghyup Economic Holdings, and Nonghyup Distribution’s audit office is conducting a special audit.”


Lee’s side says he has been unfairly accused. It says he and some employees paid for the Japan trip themselves. According to bank records and hotel booking details provided by Lee’s side, five people, including Lee, each transferred 1 million won to a person surnamed Han in February this year. They booked a hotel on the 23rd of that month and airline tickets on the 25th. The hotel was an apartment-style accommodation in Tokyo, booked for two nights starting April 10. The Mongolia trip was a package tour that included Lee and two employees who had joined him on the Japan trip; it lasted four days and three nights starting June 19.


An official from Nonghyup Distribution stressed, “The company did not provide any travel expenses, and no company funds or construction-related costs were used to pay for the trips. Nor was a separate slush fund created to cover the travel expenses.” The official also said, “There were two construction projects in question, and explanations were provided for both during the audit.”

139 construction projects after Lee took office; 97% awarded through private contracts

Questions remain, however, given the sharp increase in construction projects after Lee took office and the fact that most were awarded through private contracts. According to construction records from Nonghyup Distribution provided to Lee’s office, the company carried out 139 construction projects over the past three years, at a total cost of 23.3 billion won.


Lee was appointed in August 2024. The number of construction projects rose from 32 in his first year to 63 the following year, nearly doubling. Another 44 projects had already been carried out by August this year. During this period, 135 projects, or 97.1%, were awarded through private contracts, meaning most were contracted to specific companies without competitive bidding. The value of these privately contracted projects rose from 4.909 billion won in 2024 to 8.946 billion won. This year, 7.763 billion won worth of construction work had been awarded through private contracts by August.


The contracts were concentrated among affiliates of the National Agricultural Cooperative Federation. Of approximately 21.618 billion won in private contracts over the past three years, 26 contracts with Nonghyup Networks were worth approximately 15.411 billion won, or 71.3% of the total. Although the federation announced that it would restrict private contracts with affiliates starting this year, the concentration of construction contracts among affiliates continued.

[Exclusive] "Overseas Trips Funded by Split Construction Contracts"... Nonghyup Distribution CEO Lee Donggeun Under 'Special Audit' [The World of Kickbacks] (4) View original image

Projects split into smaller contracts: 4.34078 billion won in work at Jeonju store divided into seven contracts

Records also show that renovation and opening-related work at the same stores was divided into multiple contracts. After paying 40 million won for design services at the Jeonju store last year, the company awarded seven construction contracts this year worth a total of 4.34078 billion won. The work was split among building, electrical, communications, fire protection, exterior painting, heating and cooling facilities, and replacement of the main entrance lighting. Only the fire protection work went through competitive bidding; the other six contracts were awarded privately. The renovation’s electrical work and replacement of the lighting on the main entrance canopy were also contracted separately.


All seven contracts for this year’s opening work at the Oedae Station store, worth a total of 1.982987 billion won, were awarded privately. Separate contracts were made for interior construction, fire protection, electrical work, air conditioning, heating and cooling, and communications. In addition to the electrical work for the store opening, the company also commissioned electrical work for the air-conditioning system in the outdoor unit room.


All six renovation contracts at the Busan store in 2024, worth a total of 3.3312 billion won, were awarded privately. In addition to work on interior facilities, fire protection, electrical systems, and communications, floor work and the construction of a deli corner were contracted separately. This year, two more projects were awarded privately: installing safety components on the moving walkways and replacing the LED lighting in the first-floor store. The contracts totaled 188.02 million won. An employee of Nonghyup Distribution said, “People close to Lee went to Busan and carried out unnecessary facility work,” adding, “They poured tens of billions of won into Busan alone.”


All five renovation contracts at the Changdong store last year, covering interior facilities, electrical systems, communications, heating and cooling, and fire protection, were also awarded privately, for a total of 1.7443 billion won. This year, the company separately commissioned improvements to the produce section and replacement of the display cases. The two contracts totaled 20.58 million won. The employee alleged, “After splitting the projects into separate contracts, they ask the contractors to do additional work outside the contracted scope and pocket the difference in construction costs,” adding, “They did construction work wherever they could.”

[Exclusive] "Overseas Trips Funded by Split Construction Contracts"... Nonghyup Distribution CEO Lee Donggeun Under 'Special Audit' [The World of Kickbacks] (4) View original image

51 contracts at headquarters and Yangjae store over three years; office and cooling tower work commissioned again

At the Yangjae store, which is located at the same site as the headquarters, all 51 construction projects over the past three years were awarded privately, for a total of 2.45191 billion won. This figure includes construction work at the headquarters, which was not listed under a store name. There were 16 projects worth 754.76 million won in 2024, 21 worth 1.10313 billion won last year, and 14 worth 594.02 million won through August this year.


Records also show that work was commissioned again at similar facilities. A company that carried out an office improvement project on the third floor in 2024 was hired again this year to improve an office inside an executive office on the same floor. After commissioning improvements to a cooling tower last year, the company also commissioned replacement and repair of the tower’s fill material this year. It requires further verification whether both projects involved the same cooling tower. At Hanaro Park last year, contracts for installing a deck in a rest area and improving the rest area were awarded separately to the same company.


There were also further cases in Yangjae of the same project being divided into multiple contracts. Improvements to the entrance of the food ingredients store in 2024 were split into two contracts for mechanical systems and interior work, totaling 59.44 million won. The bowling alley foundation work last year was divided into three contracts for interior, heating and cooling, and electrical work, totaling 302.5 million won. This year, a major renovation project for the integrated operation of the retail and food ingredients sections was divided into three contracts for building work, facilities and refrigeration/freezing, and facilities and fire shutters. The contracts totaled 147.91 million won, and all were awarded privately.



Lee Jaegwan said, “Nonghyup Distribution has recorded losses of 116.2 billion won over the past four years. To avoid further loss of trust, the allegations must be investigated rigorously, and those responsible must be held accountable in proportion to the facts established.” He added, “I question whether it is appropriate for a company’s audit office to audit the company’s own CEO,” and said, “An audit system is needed under which audits of executives at subsidiaries can be conducted by an audit body at the federation or economic-holdings level, rather than by the subsidiary’s own audit office.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing